A General Approach to Predicting Ecological Responses to Environmental Flows: Making Best Use of the Literature, Expert Knowledge, and Monitoring Data

J.A. Webb, S.C. de Little, K.A. Miller, M.J. Stewardson, I.D. Rutherfurd, A.K. Sharpe, L. Patulny, LeRoy POFF

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

29 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Around the world, governments are making huge investments in environmental flows. However, much of the rationale for these releases is based on expert opinion and is thus open to challenge. Empirical studies that relate ecological responses to flow restoration are mostly case studies of limited generality. Radically, different approaches are required to inform the development of general models that will allow us to predict the effects of environmental flows. Here, we describe the modelling framework being used in a major study of environmental flows in the Australian state of Victoria. The framework attempts to make best use of all the information available from the literature, experts, and monitoring data, to inform the development of general quantitative response models. It uses systematic review of the literature to develop evidence-based conceptual models, formal expert elicitation to provide an initial quantification of model links, and data derived from purpose-designed monitoring programs over large spatial scales. These elements come together in a Bayesian hierarchical model that quantifies the relationship between flow variation and ecological response and hence can be used to predict ecological responses to flow restoration. We illustrate the framework using the example of terrestrial vegetation encroachment into regulated river channels. Our modelling framework aims to develop general flow-response models and can immediately be used to demonstrate the ecological return on investment from environmental flow programs. However, the framework also has the potential to be incorporated into planning and decision-making processes, helping to drive a transformation in evidence-based practice for environmental flow management.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)505-514
Number of pages10
JournalRiver Research and Applications
Volume31
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 May 2015
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Monitoring
Restoration
monitoring data
Decision making
Rivers
river channel
Planning
modeling
decision making
vegetation
monitoring
programme
restoration

Cite this

Webb, J.A. ; de Little, S.C. ; Miller, K.A. ; Stewardson, M.J. ; Rutherfurd, I.D. ; Sharpe, A.K. ; Patulny, L. ; POFF, LeRoy. / A General Approach to Predicting Ecological Responses to Environmental Flows: Making Best Use of the Literature, Expert Knowledge, and Monitoring Data. In: River Research and Applications. 2015 ; Vol. 31, No. 4. pp. 505-514.
@article{e8cb57da22b54d4ba020f75f96cc591c,
title = "A General Approach to Predicting Ecological Responses to Environmental Flows: Making Best Use of the Literature, Expert Knowledge, and Monitoring Data",
abstract = "Around the world, governments are making huge investments in environmental flows. However, much of the rationale for these releases is based on expert opinion and is thus open to challenge. Empirical studies that relate ecological responses to flow restoration are mostly case studies of limited generality. Radically, different approaches are required to inform the development of general models that will allow us to predict the effects of environmental flows. Here, we describe the modelling framework being used in a major study of environmental flows in the Australian state of Victoria. The framework attempts to make best use of all the information available from the literature, experts, and monitoring data, to inform the development of general quantitative response models. It uses systematic review of the literature to develop evidence-based conceptual models, formal expert elicitation to provide an initial quantification of model links, and data derived from purpose-designed monitoring programs over large spatial scales. These elements come together in a Bayesian hierarchical model that quantifies the relationship between flow variation and ecological response and hence can be used to predict ecological responses to flow restoration. We illustrate the framework using the example of terrestrial vegetation encroachment into regulated river channels. Our modelling framework aims to develop general flow-response models and can immediately be used to demonstrate the ecological return on investment from environmental flow programs. However, the framework also has the potential to be incorporated into planning and decision-making processes, helping to drive a transformation in evidence-based practice for environmental flow management.",
keywords = "Eco Evidence, Flow-response modelling, Hierarchical Bayes, Monitoring and assessment",
author = "J.A. Webb and {de Little}, S.C. and K.A. Miller and M.J. Stewardson and I.D. Rutherfurd and A.K. Sharpe and L. Patulny and LeRoy POFF",
note = "cited By 5",
year = "2015",
month = "5",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1002/rra.2832",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "505--514",
journal = "River Research and Applications",
issn = "0886-9375",
publisher = "John Wiley & Sons",
number = "4",

}

Webb, JA, de Little, SC, Miller, KA, Stewardson, MJ, Rutherfurd, ID, Sharpe, AK, Patulny, L & POFF, L 2015, 'A General Approach to Predicting Ecological Responses to Environmental Flows: Making Best Use of the Literature, Expert Knowledge, and Monitoring Data', River Research and Applications, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 505-514. https://doi.org/10.1002/rra.2832

A General Approach to Predicting Ecological Responses to Environmental Flows: Making Best Use of the Literature, Expert Knowledge, and Monitoring Data. / Webb, J.A.; de Little, S.C.; Miller, K.A.; Stewardson, M.J.; Rutherfurd, I.D.; Sharpe, A.K.; Patulny, L.; POFF, LeRoy.

In: River Research and Applications, Vol. 31, No. 4, 01.05.2015, p. 505-514.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A General Approach to Predicting Ecological Responses to Environmental Flows: Making Best Use of the Literature, Expert Knowledge, and Monitoring Data

AU - Webb, J.A.

AU - de Little, S.C.

AU - Miller, K.A.

AU - Stewardson, M.J.

AU - Rutherfurd, I.D.

AU - Sharpe, A.K.

AU - Patulny, L.

AU - POFF, LeRoy

N1 - cited By 5

PY - 2015/5/1

Y1 - 2015/5/1

N2 - Around the world, governments are making huge investments in environmental flows. However, much of the rationale for these releases is based on expert opinion and is thus open to challenge. Empirical studies that relate ecological responses to flow restoration are mostly case studies of limited generality. Radically, different approaches are required to inform the development of general models that will allow us to predict the effects of environmental flows. Here, we describe the modelling framework being used in a major study of environmental flows in the Australian state of Victoria. The framework attempts to make best use of all the information available from the literature, experts, and monitoring data, to inform the development of general quantitative response models. It uses systematic review of the literature to develop evidence-based conceptual models, formal expert elicitation to provide an initial quantification of model links, and data derived from purpose-designed monitoring programs over large spatial scales. These elements come together in a Bayesian hierarchical model that quantifies the relationship between flow variation and ecological response and hence can be used to predict ecological responses to flow restoration. We illustrate the framework using the example of terrestrial vegetation encroachment into regulated river channels. Our modelling framework aims to develop general flow-response models and can immediately be used to demonstrate the ecological return on investment from environmental flow programs. However, the framework also has the potential to be incorporated into planning and decision-making processes, helping to drive a transformation in evidence-based practice for environmental flow management.

AB - Around the world, governments are making huge investments in environmental flows. However, much of the rationale for these releases is based on expert opinion and is thus open to challenge. Empirical studies that relate ecological responses to flow restoration are mostly case studies of limited generality. Radically, different approaches are required to inform the development of general models that will allow us to predict the effects of environmental flows. Here, we describe the modelling framework being used in a major study of environmental flows in the Australian state of Victoria. The framework attempts to make best use of all the information available from the literature, experts, and monitoring data, to inform the development of general quantitative response models. It uses systematic review of the literature to develop evidence-based conceptual models, formal expert elicitation to provide an initial quantification of model links, and data derived from purpose-designed monitoring programs over large spatial scales. These elements come together in a Bayesian hierarchical model that quantifies the relationship between flow variation and ecological response and hence can be used to predict ecological responses to flow restoration. We illustrate the framework using the example of terrestrial vegetation encroachment into regulated river channels. Our modelling framework aims to develop general flow-response models and can immediately be used to demonstrate the ecological return on investment from environmental flow programs. However, the framework also has the potential to be incorporated into planning and decision-making processes, helping to drive a transformation in evidence-based practice for environmental flow management.

KW - Eco Evidence

KW - Flow-response modelling

KW - Hierarchical Bayes

KW - Monitoring and assessment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85027958276&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/general-approach-predicting-ecological-responses-environmental-flows-making-best-literature-expert-k

U2 - 10.1002/rra.2832

DO - 10.1002/rra.2832

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 505

EP - 514

JO - River Research and Applications

JF - River Research and Applications

SN - 0886-9375

IS - 4

ER -