A scrutiny of the evidence for pressure-induced state shifts in estuarine and nearshore ecosystems

Ralph MAC NALLY, Christine Albano, Erica Fleishman

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    19 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    The concept of nonlinear, sudden responses of ecosystems or species to environmental change has engendered significant interest in the past two decades. Many reviews and theoretical papers have addressed alternative states or stable states, regime shifts, tipping points and phase shifts, but the empirical evidence for these phenomena, which we refer to as stark changes, has not been evaluated in estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems. We developed standard definitions for these phenomena and examined the functional forms of ecological responses to environmental pressures (i.e. proximate influences on ecosystem state).We searched for publications related to estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems that included common descriptors of stark change in their keywords. Our search yielded 376 papers, of which we retained 98 that met four criteria: (1) claimed a stepped biological change; (2) inferred change from empirical data; (3) addressed changes that occurred in one or more semi-enclosed, tidally influenced ecosystems; and (4) described a connection to long-term patterns of ecological change. Although there were many instances of changes in ecological states, most were not stark changes. Evidence generally was not derived from time-series data, and many studies inferred temporal change from spatial differences.We describe the eight studies that provided some evidence of stark changes in ecosystem state. We suggest that compelling evidence of stark changes that can be related to pressures requires concurrent time-series data on the ecological response and pressures that were claimed to induce the stark changes.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)898-906
    Number of pages9
    JournalAustral Ecology
    Volume39
    Issue number8
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2014

    Fingerprint

    ecosystems
    ecosystem
    marine ecosystem
    time series analysis
    estuaries
    estuary
    time series
    environmental change
    marine ecosystems

    Cite this

    MAC NALLY, Ralph ; Albano, Christine ; Fleishman, Erica. / A scrutiny of the evidence for pressure-induced state shifts in estuarine and nearshore ecosystems. In: Austral Ecology. 2014 ; Vol. 39, No. 8. pp. 898-906.
    @article{f7e6662b563848dfb6efe99c0cda8bea,
    title = "A scrutiny of the evidence for pressure-induced state shifts in estuarine and nearshore ecosystems",
    abstract = "The concept of nonlinear, sudden responses of ecosystems or species to environmental change has engendered significant interest in the past two decades. Many reviews and theoretical papers have addressed alternative states or stable states, regime shifts, tipping points and phase shifts, but the empirical evidence for these phenomena, which we refer to as stark changes, has not been evaluated in estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems. We developed standard definitions for these phenomena and examined the functional forms of ecological responses to environmental pressures (i.e. proximate influences on ecosystem state).We searched for publications related to estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems that included common descriptors of stark change in their keywords. Our search yielded 376 papers, of which we retained 98 that met four criteria: (1) claimed a stepped biological change; (2) inferred change from empirical data; (3) addressed changes that occurred in one or more semi-enclosed, tidally influenced ecosystems; and (4) described a connection to long-term patterns of ecological change. Although there were many instances of changes in ecological states, most were not stark changes. Evidence generally was not derived from time-series data, and many studies inferred temporal change from spatial differences.We describe the eight studies that provided some evidence of stark changes in ecosystem state. We suggest that compelling evidence of stark changes that can be related to pressures requires concurrent time-series data on the ecological response and pressures that were claimed to induce the stark changes.",
    keywords = "alternative stable state, phase shifts, regime shift, stark change, sudden change, time series",
    author = "{MAC NALLY}, Ralph and Christine Albano and Erica Fleishman",
    year = "2014",
    doi = "10.1111/aec.12162",
    language = "English",
    volume = "39",
    pages = "898--906",
    journal = "Austral Ecology",
    issn = "1442-9985",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "8",

    }

    A scrutiny of the evidence for pressure-induced state shifts in estuarine and nearshore ecosystems. / MAC NALLY, Ralph; Albano, Christine; Fleishman, Erica.

    In: Austral Ecology, Vol. 39, No. 8, 2014, p. 898-906.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A scrutiny of the evidence for pressure-induced state shifts in estuarine and nearshore ecosystems

    AU - MAC NALLY, Ralph

    AU - Albano, Christine

    AU - Fleishman, Erica

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - The concept of nonlinear, sudden responses of ecosystems or species to environmental change has engendered significant interest in the past two decades. Many reviews and theoretical papers have addressed alternative states or stable states, regime shifts, tipping points and phase shifts, but the empirical evidence for these phenomena, which we refer to as stark changes, has not been evaluated in estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems. We developed standard definitions for these phenomena and examined the functional forms of ecological responses to environmental pressures (i.e. proximate influences on ecosystem state).We searched for publications related to estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems that included common descriptors of stark change in their keywords. Our search yielded 376 papers, of which we retained 98 that met four criteria: (1) claimed a stepped biological change; (2) inferred change from empirical data; (3) addressed changes that occurred in one or more semi-enclosed, tidally influenced ecosystems; and (4) described a connection to long-term patterns of ecological change. Although there were many instances of changes in ecological states, most were not stark changes. Evidence generally was not derived from time-series data, and many studies inferred temporal change from spatial differences.We describe the eight studies that provided some evidence of stark changes in ecosystem state. We suggest that compelling evidence of stark changes that can be related to pressures requires concurrent time-series data on the ecological response and pressures that were claimed to induce the stark changes.

    AB - The concept of nonlinear, sudden responses of ecosystems or species to environmental change has engendered significant interest in the past two decades. Many reviews and theoretical papers have addressed alternative states or stable states, regime shifts, tipping points and phase shifts, but the empirical evidence for these phenomena, which we refer to as stark changes, has not been evaluated in estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems. We developed standard definitions for these phenomena and examined the functional forms of ecological responses to environmental pressures (i.e. proximate influences on ecosystem state).We searched for publications related to estuaries and nearshore marine ecosystems that included common descriptors of stark change in their keywords. Our search yielded 376 papers, of which we retained 98 that met four criteria: (1) claimed a stepped biological change; (2) inferred change from empirical data; (3) addressed changes that occurred in one or more semi-enclosed, tidally influenced ecosystems; and (4) described a connection to long-term patterns of ecological change. Although there were many instances of changes in ecological states, most were not stark changes. Evidence generally was not derived from time-series data, and many studies inferred temporal change from spatial differences.We describe the eight studies that provided some evidence of stark changes in ecosystem state. We suggest that compelling evidence of stark changes that can be related to pressures requires concurrent time-series data on the ecological response and pressures that were claimed to induce the stark changes.

    KW - alternative stable state

    KW - phase shifts

    KW - regime shift

    KW - stark change

    KW - sudden change

    KW - time series

    U2 - 10.1111/aec.12162

    DO - 10.1111/aec.12162

    M3 - Article

    VL - 39

    SP - 898

    EP - 906

    JO - Austral Ecology

    JF - Austral Ecology

    SN - 1442-9985

    IS - 8

    ER -