A Similarity-Index–Based Method to Estimate Chemical Concentration Limits Protective for Ecological Communities

Ben Kefford, R Schäfer, M Liess, Peter Goonan, Leon Metzeling

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    17 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    A new method is presented to determine retrospectively proportional changes of species composition in a community at risk from particular concentrations of chemical stressors. The method makes estimates with some similarities to those claimed by species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) but is based on species presence/absence field data and requires assumptions that are more likely to be met. The method uses Jaccard’s index (JI), the proportion of species in common to two samples. At a similar level of contamination, the occurrence of species is usually highly variable, and thus JI values between individual pairs of samples can be low. However, by pooling samples with a similar contamination level, an increasingly complete set of species present at this level of contamination is gained. Our method involves calculating JI between randomly selected groups of samples (pooled sample sets) with similar and different levels of contamination. It then relates changes in JI to the difference in contamination and produces estimates of the proportional change in species between preselected categories of contamination. The application of the method is illustrated by using data on riverine freshwater macroinvertebrates exposed to salinity in southeastern Australia; pesticide runoff potential in the Aller River Catchment, Germany; and metal pollution (principle Cu) in the Clark Fork River Catchment, Montana, USA.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)2123-2131
    Number of pages9
    JournalEnvironmental Toxicology and Chemistry
    Volume29
    Issue number9
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2010

    Fingerprint

    Biota
    Ecosystems
    Contamination
    Rivers
    Catchments
    Salinity
    catchment
    Fresh Water
    Pesticides
    Germany
    Runoff
    Metals
    chemical
    method
    ecological community
    river
    Pollution
    macroinvertebrate
    contamination
    pesticide

    Cite this

    @article{a3bb8d2745c849649c384f45095d3f0a,
    title = "A Similarity-Index–Based Method to Estimate Chemical Concentration Limits Protective for Ecological Communities",
    abstract = "A new method is presented to determine retrospectively proportional changes of species composition in a community at risk from particular concentrations of chemical stressors. The method makes estimates with some similarities to those claimed by species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) but is based on species presence/absence field data and requires assumptions that are more likely to be met. The method uses Jaccard’s index (JI), the proportion of species in common to two samples. At a similar level of contamination, the occurrence of species is usually highly variable, and thus JI values between individual pairs of samples can be low. However, by pooling samples with a similar contamination level, an increasingly complete set of species present at this level of contamination is gained. Our method involves calculating JI between randomly selected groups of samples (pooled sample sets) with similar and different levels of contamination. It then relates changes in JI to the difference in contamination and produces estimates of the proportional change in species between preselected categories of contamination. The application of the method is illustrated by using data on riverine freshwater macroinvertebrates exposed to salinity in southeastern Australia; pesticide runoff potential in the Aller River Catchment, Germany; and metal pollution (principle Cu) in the Clark Fork River Catchment, Montana, USA.",
    keywords = "Risk assessment, Community change, Stream invertebrates, Similarity indexes.",
    author = "Ben Kefford and R Sch{\"a}fer and M Liess and Peter Goonan and Leon Metzeling",
    year = "2010",
    doi = "10.1002/etc.256",
    language = "English",
    volume = "29",
    pages = "2123--2131",
    journal = "Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry",
    issn = "0730-7268",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "9",

    }

    A Similarity-Index–Based Method to Estimate Chemical Concentration Limits Protective for Ecological Communities. / Kefford, Ben; Schäfer, R; Liess, M; Goonan, Peter; Metzeling, Leon.

    In: Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, Vol. 29, No. 9, 2010, p. 2123-2131.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - A Similarity-Index–Based Method to Estimate Chemical Concentration Limits Protective for Ecological Communities

    AU - Kefford, Ben

    AU - Schäfer, R

    AU - Liess, M

    AU - Goonan, Peter

    AU - Metzeling, Leon

    PY - 2010

    Y1 - 2010

    N2 - A new method is presented to determine retrospectively proportional changes of species composition in a community at risk from particular concentrations of chemical stressors. The method makes estimates with some similarities to those claimed by species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) but is based on species presence/absence field data and requires assumptions that are more likely to be met. The method uses Jaccard’s index (JI), the proportion of species in common to two samples. At a similar level of contamination, the occurrence of species is usually highly variable, and thus JI values between individual pairs of samples can be low. However, by pooling samples with a similar contamination level, an increasingly complete set of species present at this level of contamination is gained. Our method involves calculating JI between randomly selected groups of samples (pooled sample sets) with similar and different levels of contamination. It then relates changes in JI to the difference in contamination and produces estimates of the proportional change in species between preselected categories of contamination. The application of the method is illustrated by using data on riverine freshwater macroinvertebrates exposed to salinity in southeastern Australia; pesticide runoff potential in the Aller River Catchment, Germany; and metal pollution (principle Cu) in the Clark Fork River Catchment, Montana, USA.

    AB - A new method is presented to determine retrospectively proportional changes of species composition in a community at risk from particular concentrations of chemical stressors. The method makes estimates with some similarities to those claimed by species sensitivity distributions (SSDs) but is based on species presence/absence field data and requires assumptions that are more likely to be met. The method uses Jaccard’s index (JI), the proportion of species in common to two samples. At a similar level of contamination, the occurrence of species is usually highly variable, and thus JI values between individual pairs of samples can be low. However, by pooling samples with a similar contamination level, an increasingly complete set of species present at this level of contamination is gained. Our method involves calculating JI between randomly selected groups of samples (pooled sample sets) with similar and different levels of contamination. It then relates changes in JI to the difference in contamination and produces estimates of the proportional change in species between preselected categories of contamination. The application of the method is illustrated by using data on riverine freshwater macroinvertebrates exposed to salinity in southeastern Australia; pesticide runoff potential in the Aller River Catchment, Germany; and metal pollution (principle Cu) in the Clark Fork River Catchment, Montana, USA.

    KW - Risk assessment

    KW - Community change

    KW - Stream invertebrates

    KW - Similarity indexes.

    U2 - 10.1002/etc.256

    DO - 10.1002/etc.256

    M3 - Article

    VL - 29

    SP - 2123

    EP - 2131

    JO - Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry

    JF - Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry

    SN - 0730-7268

    IS - 9

    ER -