Accuracy of tympanic temperature measurement in firefighters completing a simulated structural firefighting task

Toby Keene, Matt Brearley, Beth Bowen, Anthony Walker

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    3 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    In the course of their duties, firefighters risk heat stroke and other medical conditions due to exertion in high-temperature environments. Infrared tympanic temperature measurement (TTym) is often used by Emergency Medical Services (EMS) to assess the core body temperature of firefighters. The accuracy of TTym in this setting has been called into question. Hypothesis/Problem This study aimed to examine the accuracy of TTym for core body temperature assessment at emergency firefighting events compared with gastrointestinal temperature measurement (TGI) as measured by ingestible thermometers. Methods Forty-five (42 male, three female) professional urban firefighters from an Australian fire service completed two 20-minute work periods in a 100°C (± 5°C) heat chamber while wearing personal protective clothing (PPC) and breathing apparatus (weighing approximately 22 kg). Measurements were taken immediately before entering, and on exiting, the heat chamber. Tympanic temperature was assessed by an infrared tympanic thermometer and TGI was measured by ingestible sensor and radio receiver. Results Complete data were available for 37 participants. Participant temperatures were higher on exiting the heat chamber than at baseline (TTym: 35.9°C (SD=0.7) vs 37.5°C (SD=0.8); TGI: 37.2°C (SD=0.4) vs 38.6°C (SD=0.5)). Tympanic temperature underestimated TGI on average by 1.3°C (SD=0.5) before entering the chamber and by 1.0°C (SD=0.8) following the exercise. Using pooled data, the average underestimation was 1.2°C (SD=0.7). Conclusion Tympanic thermometers cause an unreliable measure of core body temperature for firefighters engaged in fire suppression activities. Accurate and practical measures of core body temperature are required urgently.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)461-465
    Number of pages5
    JournalPrehospital and Disaster Medicine
    Volume30
    Issue number5
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 19 Aug 2015

    Fingerprint

    Firefighters
    Body Temperature
    Thermometers
    Temperature
    Hot Temperature
    Protective Clothing
    Heat Stroke
    Emergency Medical Services
    Radio
    Respiration
    Emergencies
    Exercise

    Cite this

    Keene, Toby ; Brearley, Matt ; Bowen, Beth ; Walker, Anthony. / Accuracy of tympanic temperature measurement in firefighters completing a simulated structural firefighting task. In: Prehospital and Disaster Medicine. 2015 ; Vol. 30, No. 5. pp. 461-465.
    @article{45058539d97c47229e2611918cdc0c0c,
    title = "Accuracy of tympanic temperature measurement in firefighters completing a simulated structural firefighting task",
    abstract = "In the course of their duties, firefighters risk heat stroke and other medical conditions due to exertion in high-temperature environments. Infrared tympanic temperature measurement (TTym) is often used by Emergency Medical Services (EMS) to assess the core body temperature of firefighters. The accuracy of TTym in this setting has been called into question. Hypothesis/Problem This study aimed to examine the accuracy of TTym for core body temperature assessment at emergency firefighting events compared with gastrointestinal temperature measurement (TGI) as measured by ingestible thermometers. Methods Forty-five (42 male, three female) professional urban firefighters from an Australian fire service completed two 20-minute work periods in a 100°C (± 5°C) heat chamber while wearing personal protective clothing (PPC) and breathing apparatus (weighing approximately 22 kg). Measurements were taken immediately before entering, and on exiting, the heat chamber. Tympanic temperature was assessed by an infrared tympanic thermometer and TGI was measured by ingestible sensor and radio receiver. Results Complete data were available for 37 participants. Participant temperatures were higher on exiting the heat chamber than at baseline (TTym: 35.9°C (SD=0.7) vs 37.5°C (SD=0.8); TGI: 37.2°C (SD=0.4) vs 38.6°C (SD=0.5)). Tympanic temperature underestimated TGI on average by 1.3°C (SD=0.5) before entering the chamber and by 1.0°C (SD=0.8) following the exercise. Using pooled data, the average underestimation was 1.2°C (SD=0.7). Conclusion Tympanic thermometers cause an unreliable measure of core body temperature for firefighters engaged in fire suppression activities. Accurate and practical measures of core body temperature are required urgently.",
    keywords = "body temperature, Emergency Medical Services, firefighters, thermometers",
    author = "Toby Keene and Matt Brearley and Beth Bowen and Anthony Walker",
    year = "2015",
    month = "8",
    day = "19",
    doi = "10.1017/S1049023X15005038",
    language = "English",
    volume = "30",
    pages = "461--465",
    journal = "Prehospital and Disaster Medicine",
    issn = "1049-023X",
    publisher = "World Association for Disaster and Emergency Medicine",
    number = "5",

    }

    Accuracy of tympanic temperature measurement in firefighters completing a simulated structural firefighting task. / Keene, Toby; Brearley, Matt; Bowen, Beth; Walker, Anthony.

    In: Prehospital and Disaster Medicine, Vol. 30, No. 5, 19.08.2015, p. 461-465.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Accuracy of tympanic temperature measurement in firefighters completing a simulated structural firefighting task

    AU - Keene, Toby

    AU - Brearley, Matt

    AU - Bowen, Beth

    AU - Walker, Anthony

    PY - 2015/8/19

    Y1 - 2015/8/19

    N2 - In the course of their duties, firefighters risk heat stroke and other medical conditions due to exertion in high-temperature environments. Infrared tympanic temperature measurement (TTym) is often used by Emergency Medical Services (EMS) to assess the core body temperature of firefighters. The accuracy of TTym in this setting has been called into question. Hypothesis/Problem This study aimed to examine the accuracy of TTym for core body temperature assessment at emergency firefighting events compared with gastrointestinal temperature measurement (TGI) as measured by ingestible thermometers. Methods Forty-five (42 male, three female) professional urban firefighters from an Australian fire service completed two 20-minute work periods in a 100°C (± 5°C) heat chamber while wearing personal protective clothing (PPC) and breathing apparatus (weighing approximately 22 kg). Measurements were taken immediately before entering, and on exiting, the heat chamber. Tympanic temperature was assessed by an infrared tympanic thermometer and TGI was measured by ingestible sensor and radio receiver. Results Complete data were available for 37 participants. Participant temperatures were higher on exiting the heat chamber than at baseline (TTym: 35.9°C (SD=0.7) vs 37.5°C (SD=0.8); TGI: 37.2°C (SD=0.4) vs 38.6°C (SD=0.5)). Tympanic temperature underestimated TGI on average by 1.3°C (SD=0.5) before entering the chamber and by 1.0°C (SD=0.8) following the exercise. Using pooled data, the average underestimation was 1.2°C (SD=0.7). Conclusion Tympanic thermometers cause an unreliable measure of core body temperature for firefighters engaged in fire suppression activities. Accurate and practical measures of core body temperature are required urgently.

    AB - In the course of their duties, firefighters risk heat stroke and other medical conditions due to exertion in high-temperature environments. Infrared tympanic temperature measurement (TTym) is often used by Emergency Medical Services (EMS) to assess the core body temperature of firefighters. The accuracy of TTym in this setting has been called into question. Hypothesis/Problem This study aimed to examine the accuracy of TTym for core body temperature assessment at emergency firefighting events compared with gastrointestinal temperature measurement (TGI) as measured by ingestible thermometers. Methods Forty-five (42 male, three female) professional urban firefighters from an Australian fire service completed two 20-minute work periods in a 100°C (± 5°C) heat chamber while wearing personal protective clothing (PPC) and breathing apparatus (weighing approximately 22 kg). Measurements were taken immediately before entering, and on exiting, the heat chamber. Tympanic temperature was assessed by an infrared tympanic thermometer and TGI was measured by ingestible sensor and radio receiver. Results Complete data were available for 37 participants. Participant temperatures were higher on exiting the heat chamber than at baseline (TTym: 35.9°C (SD=0.7) vs 37.5°C (SD=0.8); TGI: 37.2°C (SD=0.4) vs 38.6°C (SD=0.5)). Tympanic temperature underestimated TGI on average by 1.3°C (SD=0.5) before entering the chamber and by 1.0°C (SD=0.8) following the exercise. Using pooled data, the average underestimation was 1.2°C (SD=0.7). Conclusion Tympanic thermometers cause an unreliable measure of core body temperature for firefighters engaged in fire suppression activities. Accurate and practical measures of core body temperature are required urgently.

    KW - body temperature

    KW - Emergency Medical Services

    KW - firefighters

    KW - thermometers

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84948387377&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1017/S1049023X15005038

    DO - 10.1017/S1049023X15005038

    M3 - Article

    VL - 30

    SP - 461

    EP - 465

    JO - Prehospital and Disaster Medicine

    JF - Prehospital and Disaster Medicine

    SN - 1049-023X

    IS - 5

    ER -