An approximate Bayesian algorithm for training fuzzy cognitive map models of forest responses to deer control in a New Zealand adaptive management experiment

David S.L. Ramsey, David M. Forsyth, Clare J. Veltman, Simon J. Nicol, Charles R. Todd, Robert B. Allen, Will J. Allen, Peter J. Bellingham, Sarah J. Richardson, Chris L. Jacobson, Richard J. Barker

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Forest management decisions are characterised by a high level of uncertainty because responses reflect a range of interacting ecological processes. Faced with this situation, modelling can be a useful tool for characterising that uncertainty and for predicting its impacts on management decisions. In the adaptive management paradigm, different model structures are essentially hypotheses of system behaviour that are formulated to encapsulate structural uncertainty about the system. Here we report upon the initial stages of a management-scale experiment designed to increase our understanding of the effects of deer control on forest ecosystems in New Zealand. Using a modelling approach based on fuzzy cognitive maps (FCM) we were able to formalise expert knowledge and explore how growth rates of tree seedlings would respond to lower deer densities, with or without responses by other plants in the forest understorey. Alternative models predicted that the response of seedling growth and biomass in small (16m 2) plots used in the experiment were dependent on hypotheses about the strength of plant competition for soil nutrients and moisture which, in turn, were conditional on light availability in the plot. To learn about which model best may describe the system, we used recently proposed methods in Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) to perform model selection and inference using a simulated data set generated from one of our candidate models. Using a novel Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm together with ABC model selection on our simulated data we show that these procedures provide reliable model selection and parameter inference and hence, should be suitable for confronting our candidate FCM models with data collected at the end of the experiment.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)93-104
Number of pages12
JournalEcological Modelling
Volume240
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 10 Aug 2012
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

adaptive management
deer
experiment
seedling
light availability
Markov chain
soil nutrient
forest ecosystem
understory
modeling
forest management
soil moisture
biomass

Cite this

Ramsey, David S.L. ; Forsyth, David M. ; Veltman, Clare J. ; Nicol, Simon J. ; Todd, Charles R. ; Allen, Robert B. ; Allen, Will J. ; Bellingham, Peter J. ; Richardson, Sarah J. ; Jacobson, Chris L. ; Barker, Richard J. / An approximate Bayesian algorithm for training fuzzy cognitive map models of forest responses to deer control in a New Zealand adaptive management experiment. In: Ecological Modelling. 2012 ; Vol. 240. pp. 93-104.
@article{50e7e706da0948edb4bc9e32add20037,
title = "An approximate Bayesian algorithm for training fuzzy cognitive map models of forest responses to deer control in a New Zealand adaptive management experiment",
abstract = "Forest management decisions are characterised by a high level of uncertainty because responses reflect a range of interacting ecological processes. Faced with this situation, modelling can be a useful tool for characterising that uncertainty and for predicting its impacts on management decisions. In the adaptive management paradigm, different model structures are essentially hypotheses of system behaviour that are formulated to encapsulate structural uncertainty about the system. Here we report upon the initial stages of a management-scale experiment designed to increase our understanding of the effects of deer control on forest ecosystems in New Zealand. Using a modelling approach based on fuzzy cognitive maps (FCM) we were able to formalise expert knowledge and explore how growth rates of tree seedlings would respond to lower deer densities, with or without responses by other plants in the forest understorey. Alternative models predicted that the response of seedling growth and biomass in small (16m 2) plots used in the experiment were dependent on hypotheses about the strength of plant competition for soil nutrients and moisture which, in turn, were conditional on light availability in the plot. To learn about which model best may describe the system, we used recently proposed methods in Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) to perform model selection and inference using a simulated data set generated from one of our candidate models. Using a novel Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm together with ABC model selection on our simulated data we show that these procedures provide reliable model selection and parameter inference and hence, should be suitable for confronting our candidate FCM models with data collected at the end of the experiment.",
keywords = "Approximate Bayesian Computation, Fuzzy logic, Herbivory, Seedling growth",
author = "Ramsey, {David S.L.} and Forsyth, {David M.} and Veltman, {Clare J.} and Nicol, {Simon J.} and Todd, {Charles R.} and Allen, {Robert B.} and Allen, {Will J.} and Bellingham, {Peter J.} and Richardson, {Sarah J.} and Jacobson, {Chris L.} and Barker, {Richard J.}",
year = "2012",
month = "8",
day = "10",
doi = "10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2012.04.022",
language = "English",
volume = "240",
pages = "93--104",
journal = "Ecological Modelling",
issn = "0304-3800",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Ramsey, DSL, Forsyth, DM, Veltman, CJ, Nicol, SJ, Todd, CR, Allen, RB, Allen, WJ, Bellingham, PJ, Richardson, SJ, Jacobson, CL & Barker, RJ 2012, 'An approximate Bayesian algorithm for training fuzzy cognitive map models of forest responses to deer control in a New Zealand adaptive management experiment', Ecological Modelling, vol. 240, pp. 93-104. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2012.04.022

An approximate Bayesian algorithm for training fuzzy cognitive map models of forest responses to deer control in a New Zealand adaptive management experiment. / Ramsey, David S.L.; Forsyth, David M.; Veltman, Clare J.; Nicol, Simon J.; Todd, Charles R.; Allen, Robert B.; Allen, Will J.; Bellingham, Peter J.; Richardson, Sarah J.; Jacobson, Chris L.; Barker, Richard J.

In: Ecological Modelling, Vol. 240, 10.08.2012, p. 93-104.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - An approximate Bayesian algorithm for training fuzzy cognitive map models of forest responses to deer control in a New Zealand adaptive management experiment

AU - Ramsey, David S.L.

AU - Forsyth, David M.

AU - Veltman, Clare J.

AU - Nicol, Simon J.

AU - Todd, Charles R.

AU - Allen, Robert B.

AU - Allen, Will J.

AU - Bellingham, Peter J.

AU - Richardson, Sarah J.

AU - Jacobson, Chris L.

AU - Barker, Richard J.

PY - 2012/8/10

Y1 - 2012/8/10

N2 - Forest management decisions are characterised by a high level of uncertainty because responses reflect a range of interacting ecological processes. Faced with this situation, modelling can be a useful tool for characterising that uncertainty and for predicting its impacts on management decisions. In the adaptive management paradigm, different model structures are essentially hypotheses of system behaviour that are formulated to encapsulate structural uncertainty about the system. Here we report upon the initial stages of a management-scale experiment designed to increase our understanding of the effects of deer control on forest ecosystems in New Zealand. Using a modelling approach based on fuzzy cognitive maps (FCM) we were able to formalise expert knowledge and explore how growth rates of tree seedlings would respond to lower deer densities, with or without responses by other plants in the forest understorey. Alternative models predicted that the response of seedling growth and biomass in small (16m 2) plots used in the experiment were dependent on hypotheses about the strength of plant competition for soil nutrients and moisture which, in turn, were conditional on light availability in the plot. To learn about which model best may describe the system, we used recently proposed methods in Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) to perform model selection and inference using a simulated data set generated from one of our candidate models. Using a novel Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm together with ABC model selection on our simulated data we show that these procedures provide reliable model selection and parameter inference and hence, should be suitable for confronting our candidate FCM models with data collected at the end of the experiment.

AB - Forest management decisions are characterised by a high level of uncertainty because responses reflect a range of interacting ecological processes. Faced with this situation, modelling can be a useful tool for characterising that uncertainty and for predicting its impacts on management decisions. In the adaptive management paradigm, different model structures are essentially hypotheses of system behaviour that are formulated to encapsulate structural uncertainty about the system. Here we report upon the initial stages of a management-scale experiment designed to increase our understanding of the effects of deer control on forest ecosystems in New Zealand. Using a modelling approach based on fuzzy cognitive maps (FCM) we were able to formalise expert knowledge and explore how growth rates of tree seedlings would respond to lower deer densities, with or without responses by other plants in the forest understorey. Alternative models predicted that the response of seedling growth and biomass in small (16m 2) plots used in the experiment were dependent on hypotheses about the strength of plant competition for soil nutrients and moisture which, in turn, were conditional on light availability in the plot. To learn about which model best may describe the system, we used recently proposed methods in Approximate Bayesian Computation (ABC) to perform model selection and inference using a simulated data set generated from one of our candidate models. Using a novel Markov chain Monte Carlo algorithm together with ABC model selection on our simulated data we show that these procedures provide reliable model selection and parameter inference and hence, should be suitable for confronting our candidate FCM models with data collected at the end of the experiment.

KW - Approximate Bayesian Computation

KW - Fuzzy logic

KW - Herbivory

KW - Seedling growth

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84861814016&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2012.04.022

DO - 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2012.04.022

M3 - Article

VL - 240

SP - 93

EP - 104

JO - Ecological Modelling

JF - Ecological Modelling

SN - 0304-3800

ER -