Changes in students' moral development during medical school

A cohort study

Johane Patenaude, Theophile Niyonsenga, Diane Fafard

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

116 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Introduction: The requirements of professionalism and the expected qualities of medical staff, including high moral character, motivate institutions to care about the ethical development of students during their medical education. We assessed progress in moral reasoning in a cohort of medical students over the first 3 years of their education. Methods: We invited all 92 medical students enrolled at the University of Sherbrooke, Que., to complete a questionnaire on moral reasoning at the start of their first year of medical school and at the end of their third year. We used the French version of Kohlberg's Moral Judgment Interview. Responses to the questionnaire were coded by stage of moral development, and weighted average scores were assigned according to frequency of use of each stage. Results: Of the 92 medical students, 54 completed the questionnaire in the fall of the first year and again at the end of their third year. The average age of the students at the end of the third year was 21 years, and 79% of the students included in the study were women. Over the 3-year period, the stage of moral development did not change substantially (i.e., by more than half a stage) for 39 (72%) of the students, shifted to a lower stage for 7 (13%) and shifted to a higher stage for 8 (15%). The overall mean change in stage was not significant (from mean 3.46 in year 1 to 3.48 in year 3, p = 0.86); however, the overall mean change in weighted average scores showed a significant decline in moral development (p = 0.028). Interpretation: Temporal variations in students' scores show a levelling process of their moral reasoning. This finding prompts us to ask whether a hidden curriculum exists in the structure of medical education that inhibits rather than facilitates the development of moral reasoning.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)840-844
Number of pages5
JournalCMAJ
Volume168
Issue number7
Publication statusPublished - 2003
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Moral Development
Medical Schools
Cohort Studies
Students
Medical Students
Medical Education
Medical Staff
Curriculum
Interviews
Education
Surveys and Questionnaires

Cite this

Patenaude, Johane ; Niyonsenga, Theophile ; Fafard, Diane. / Changes in students' moral development during medical school : A cohort study. In: CMAJ. 2003 ; Vol. 168, No. 7. pp. 840-844.
@article{2fcebd5a97eb420d939988555ddd0e3d,
title = "Changes in students' moral development during medical school: A cohort study",
abstract = "Introduction: The requirements of professionalism and the expected qualities of medical staff, including high moral character, motivate institutions to care about the ethical development of students during their medical education. We assessed progress in moral reasoning in a cohort of medical students over the first 3 years of their education. Methods: We invited all 92 medical students enrolled at the University of Sherbrooke, Que., to complete a questionnaire on moral reasoning at the start of their first year of medical school and at the end of their third year. We used the French version of Kohlberg's Moral Judgment Interview. Responses to the questionnaire were coded by stage of moral development, and weighted average scores were assigned according to frequency of use of each stage. Results: Of the 92 medical students, 54 completed the questionnaire in the fall of the first year and again at the end of their third year. The average age of the students at the end of the third year was 21 years, and 79{\%} of the students included in the study were women. Over the 3-year period, the stage of moral development did not change substantially (i.e., by more than half a stage) for 39 (72{\%}) of the students, shifted to a lower stage for 7 (13{\%}) and shifted to a higher stage for 8 (15{\%}). The overall mean change in stage was not significant (from mean 3.46 in year 1 to 3.48 in year 3, p = 0.86); however, the overall mean change in weighted average scores showed a significant decline in moral development (p = 0.028). Interpretation: Temporal variations in students' scores show a levelling process of their moral reasoning. This finding prompts us to ask whether a hidden curriculum exists in the structure of medical education that inhibits rather than facilitates the development of moral reasoning.",
author = "Johane Patenaude and Theophile Niyonsenga and Diane Fafard",
year = "2003",
language = "English",
volume = "168",
pages = "840--844",
journal = "CMAJ",
issn = "0820-3946",
publisher = "Canadian Medical Association",
number = "7",

}

Patenaude, J, Niyonsenga, T & Fafard, D 2003, 'Changes in students' moral development during medical school: A cohort study', CMAJ, vol. 168, no. 7, pp. 840-844.

Changes in students' moral development during medical school : A cohort study. / Patenaude, Johane; Niyonsenga, Theophile; Fafard, Diane.

In: CMAJ, Vol. 168, No. 7, 2003, p. 840-844.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Changes in students' moral development during medical school

T2 - A cohort study

AU - Patenaude, Johane

AU - Niyonsenga, Theophile

AU - Fafard, Diane

PY - 2003

Y1 - 2003

N2 - Introduction: The requirements of professionalism and the expected qualities of medical staff, including high moral character, motivate institutions to care about the ethical development of students during their medical education. We assessed progress in moral reasoning in a cohort of medical students over the first 3 years of their education. Methods: We invited all 92 medical students enrolled at the University of Sherbrooke, Que., to complete a questionnaire on moral reasoning at the start of their first year of medical school and at the end of their third year. We used the French version of Kohlberg's Moral Judgment Interview. Responses to the questionnaire were coded by stage of moral development, and weighted average scores were assigned according to frequency of use of each stage. Results: Of the 92 medical students, 54 completed the questionnaire in the fall of the first year and again at the end of their third year. The average age of the students at the end of the third year was 21 years, and 79% of the students included in the study were women. Over the 3-year period, the stage of moral development did not change substantially (i.e., by more than half a stage) for 39 (72%) of the students, shifted to a lower stage for 7 (13%) and shifted to a higher stage for 8 (15%). The overall mean change in stage was not significant (from mean 3.46 in year 1 to 3.48 in year 3, p = 0.86); however, the overall mean change in weighted average scores showed a significant decline in moral development (p = 0.028). Interpretation: Temporal variations in students' scores show a levelling process of their moral reasoning. This finding prompts us to ask whether a hidden curriculum exists in the structure of medical education that inhibits rather than facilitates the development of moral reasoning.

AB - Introduction: The requirements of professionalism and the expected qualities of medical staff, including high moral character, motivate institutions to care about the ethical development of students during their medical education. We assessed progress in moral reasoning in a cohort of medical students over the first 3 years of their education. Methods: We invited all 92 medical students enrolled at the University of Sherbrooke, Que., to complete a questionnaire on moral reasoning at the start of their first year of medical school and at the end of their third year. We used the French version of Kohlberg's Moral Judgment Interview. Responses to the questionnaire were coded by stage of moral development, and weighted average scores were assigned according to frequency of use of each stage. Results: Of the 92 medical students, 54 completed the questionnaire in the fall of the first year and again at the end of their third year. The average age of the students at the end of the third year was 21 years, and 79% of the students included in the study were women. Over the 3-year period, the stage of moral development did not change substantially (i.e., by more than half a stage) for 39 (72%) of the students, shifted to a lower stage for 7 (13%) and shifted to a higher stage for 8 (15%). The overall mean change in stage was not significant (from mean 3.46 in year 1 to 3.48 in year 3, p = 0.86); however, the overall mean change in weighted average scores showed a significant decline in moral development (p = 0.028). Interpretation: Temporal variations in students' scores show a levelling process of their moral reasoning. This finding prompts us to ask whether a hidden curriculum exists in the structure of medical education that inhibits rather than facilitates the development of moral reasoning.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0037387844&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

VL - 168

SP - 840

EP - 844

JO - CMAJ

JF - CMAJ

SN - 0820-3946

IS - 7

ER -