Changes in the components of moral reasoning during students' medical education

A pilot study

Johane Patenaude, T. Niyonsenga, D. Fafard

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

17 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Introduction: Many authors are concerned by students' moral reasoning not developing normally during medical education. Aim: This study is concerned with how the components of student' moral reasoning are affected by their medical studies. Methods: Ninety-two medical students were tested on entry into first year and on finishing third year, to determine evolutionary changes in their moral reasoning. Changes in their use of arguments specific to each stage of moral development were measured. Results: Significant changes were observed in the weighted global score (-18.14 ± 59.17, P = 2.8%). Changes in global score correlated with changes in stages of moral reasoning. The multivariate structure of moral reasoning was reorganised into two principal components, which, respectively, explained almost 82% (first year) and 72% (third year) of the total variability in scores. Moral reasoning stages characterized by law-and-order and social-contract/legalistic orientations proved important for explaining the variability in students' moral reasoning at the start of medical training, while instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations explained variability post third year. Conclusions: Students restructure their handling of ethical questions by using arguments with more instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations, rather than those of the more desirable law-and-order or social-contract/legalistic type. To assess better the skills required for moral reasoning, a more sophisticated approach is needed than that of a simple measure of improvement/stagnation/deterioration.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)822-829
Number of pages8
JournalMedical Education
Volume37
Issue number9
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2003
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Medical Education
medical student
Students
law and order
Contracts
education
student
Moral Development
stagnation
Medical Students

Cite this

@article{ad9fecfbc23f4a1b9e222f96c574e0a9,
title = "Changes in the components of moral reasoning during students' medical education: A pilot study",
abstract = "Introduction: Many authors are concerned by students' moral reasoning not developing normally during medical education. Aim: This study is concerned with how the components of student' moral reasoning are affected by their medical studies. Methods: Ninety-two medical students were tested on entry into first year and on finishing third year, to determine evolutionary changes in their moral reasoning. Changes in their use of arguments specific to each stage of moral development were measured. Results: Significant changes were observed in the weighted global score (-18.14 ± 59.17, P = 2.8{\%}). Changes in global score correlated with changes in stages of moral reasoning. The multivariate structure of moral reasoning was reorganised into two principal components, which, respectively, explained almost 82{\%} (first year) and 72{\%} (third year) of the total variability in scores. Moral reasoning stages characterized by law-and-order and social-contract/legalistic orientations proved important for explaining the variability in students' moral reasoning at the start of medical training, while instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations explained variability post third year. Conclusions: Students restructure their handling of ethical questions by using arguments with more instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations, rather than those of the more desirable law-and-order or social-contract/legalistic type. To assess better the skills required for moral reasoning, a more sophisticated approach is needed than that of a simple measure of improvement/stagnation/deterioration.",
keywords = "*Moral development, Education medical undergraduate/*standards, Medical/psychology, Multivariante analysis, Quebec/epidemiology, Questionnaires, Student",
author = "Johane Patenaude and T. Niyonsenga and D. Fafard",
year = "2003",
doi = "10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01593.x",
language = "English",
volume = "37",
pages = "822--829",
journal = "British journal of medical education",
issn = "0308-0110",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "9",

}

Changes in the components of moral reasoning during students' medical education : A pilot study. / Patenaude, Johane; Niyonsenga, T.; Fafard, D.

In: Medical Education, Vol. 37, No. 9, 2003, p. 822-829.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Changes in the components of moral reasoning during students' medical education

T2 - A pilot study

AU - Patenaude, Johane

AU - Niyonsenga, T.

AU - Fafard, D.

PY - 2003

Y1 - 2003

N2 - Introduction: Many authors are concerned by students' moral reasoning not developing normally during medical education. Aim: This study is concerned with how the components of student' moral reasoning are affected by their medical studies. Methods: Ninety-two medical students were tested on entry into first year and on finishing third year, to determine evolutionary changes in their moral reasoning. Changes in their use of arguments specific to each stage of moral development were measured. Results: Significant changes were observed in the weighted global score (-18.14 ± 59.17, P = 2.8%). Changes in global score correlated with changes in stages of moral reasoning. The multivariate structure of moral reasoning was reorganised into two principal components, which, respectively, explained almost 82% (first year) and 72% (third year) of the total variability in scores. Moral reasoning stages characterized by law-and-order and social-contract/legalistic orientations proved important for explaining the variability in students' moral reasoning at the start of medical training, while instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations explained variability post third year. Conclusions: Students restructure their handling of ethical questions by using arguments with more instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations, rather than those of the more desirable law-and-order or social-contract/legalistic type. To assess better the skills required for moral reasoning, a more sophisticated approach is needed than that of a simple measure of improvement/stagnation/deterioration.

AB - Introduction: Many authors are concerned by students' moral reasoning not developing normally during medical education. Aim: This study is concerned with how the components of student' moral reasoning are affected by their medical studies. Methods: Ninety-two medical students were tested on entry into first year and on finishing third year, to determine evolutionary changes in their moral reasoning. Changes in their use of arguments specific to each stage of moral development were measured. Results: Significant changes were observed in the weighted global score (-18.14 ± 59.17, P = 2.8%). Changes in global score correlated with changes in stages of moral reasoning. The multivariate structure of moral reasoning was reorganised into two principal components, which, respectively, explained almost 82% (first year) and 72% (third year) of the total variability in scores. Moral reasoning stages characterized by law-and-order and social-contract/legalistic orientations proved important for explaining the variability in students' moral reasoning at the start of medical training, while instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations explained variability post third year. Conclusions: Students restructure their handling of ethical questions by using arguments with more instrumental-relativist and interpersonal-concordance orientations, rather than those of the more desirable law-and-order or social-contract/legalistic type. To assess better the skills required for moral reasoning, a more sophisticated approach is needed than that of a simple measure of improvement/stagnation/deterioration.

KW - Moral development

KW - Education medical undergraduate/standards

KW - Medical/psychology

KW - Multivariante analysis

KW - Quebec/epidemiology

KW - Questionnaires

KW - Student

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0041832116&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01593.x

DO - 10.1046/j.1365-2923.2003.01593.x

M3 - Article

VL - 37

SP - 822

EP - 829

JO - British journal of medical education

JF - British journal of medical education

SN - 0308-0110

IS - 9

ER -