Citizen surveillance for environmental monitoring

combining the efforts of citizen science and crowdsourcing in a quantitative data framework

Marijke Welvaert, Peter Caley

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

8 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Citizen science and crowdsourcing have been emerging as methods to collect data for surveillance and/or monitoring activities. They could be gathered under the overarching term citizen surveillance. The discipline, however, still struggles to be widely accepted in the scientific community, mainly because these activities are not embedded in a quantitative framework. This results in an ongoing discussion on how to analyze and make useful inference from these data. When considering the data collection process, we illustrate how citizen surveillance can be classified according to the nature of the underlying observation process measured in two dimensions—the degree of observer reporting intention and the control in observer detection effort. By classifying the observation process in these dimensions we distinguish between crowdsourcing, unstructured citizen science and structured citizen science. This classification helps the determine data processing and statistical treatment of these data for making inference. Using our framework, it is apparent that published studies are overwhelmingly associated with structured citizen science, and there are well developed statistical methods for the resulting data. In contrast, methods for making useful inference from purely crowd-sourced data remain under development, with the challenges of accounting for the unknown observation process considerable. Our quantitative framework for citizen surveillance calls for an integration of citizen science and crowdsourcing and provides a way forward to solve the statistical challenges inherent to citizen-sourced data.
Original languageEnglish
Article number1890
Number of pages14
JournalSpringer Plus
Volume5
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 28 Oct 2016
Externally publishedYes

Cite this

@article{5870eb8035d14e94a542cc26a119ca05,
title = "Citizen surveillance for environmental monitoring: combining the efforts of citizen science and crowdsourcing in a quantitative data framework",
abstract = "Citizen science and crowdsourcing have been emerging as methods to collect data for surveillance and/or monitoring activities. They could be gathered under the overarching term citizen surveillance. The discipline, however, still struggles to be widely accepted in the scientific community, mainly because these activities are not embedded in a quantitative framework. This results in an ongoing discussion on how to analyze and make useful inference from these data. When considering the data collection process, we illustrate how citizen surveillance can be classified according to the nature of the underlying observation process measured in two dimensions—the degree of observer reporting intention and the control in observer detection effort. By classifying the observation process in these dimensions we distinguish between crowdsourcing, unstructured citizen science and structured citizen science. This classification helps the determine data processing and statistical treatment of these data for making inference. Using our framework, it is apparent that published studies are overwhelmingly associated with structured citizen science, and there are well developed statistical methods for the resulting data. In contrast, methods for making useful inference from purely crowd-sourced data remain under development, with the challenges of accounting for the unknown observation process considerable. Our quantitative framework for citizen surveillance calls for an integration of citizen science and crowdsourcing and provides a way forward to solve the statistical challenges inherent to citizen-sourced data.",
keywords = "Citizen science, Crowdsourcing, Data generation process, Environmental statistics, General surveillance",
author = "Marijke Welvaert and Peter Caley",
year = "2016",
month = "10",
day = "28",
doi = "10.1186/s40064-016-3583-5",
language = "English",
volume = "5",
journal = "Springer Plus",
issn = "2193-1801",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "1",

}

Citizen surveillance for environmental monitoring : combining the efforts of citizen science and crowdsourcing in a quantitative data framework. / Welvaert, Marijke; Caley, Peter.

In: Springer Plus, Vol. 5, No. 1, 1890, 28.10.2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Citizen surveillance for environmental monitoring

T2 - combining the efforts of citizen science and crowdsourcing in a quantitative data framework

AU - Welvaert, Marijke

AU - Caley, Peter

PY - 2016/10/28

Y1 - 2016/10/28

N2 - Citizen science and crowdsourcing have been emerging as methods to collect data for surveillance and/or monitoring activities. They could be gathered under the overarching term citizen surveillance. The discipline, however, still struggles to be widely accepted in the scientific community, mainly because these activities are not embedded in a quantitative framework. This results in an ongoing discussion on how to analyze and make useful inference from these data. When considering the data collection process, we illustrate how citizen surveillance can be classified according to the nature of the underlying observation process measured in two dimensions—the degree of observer reporting intention and the control in observer detection effort. By classifying the observation process in these dimensions we distinguish between crowdsourcing, unstructured citizen science and structured citizen science. This classification helps the determine data processing and statistical treatment of these data for making inference. Using our framework, it is apparent that published studies are overwhelmingly associated with structured citizen science, and there are well developed statistical methods for the resulting data. In contrast, methods for making useful inference from purely crowd-sourced data remain under development, with the challenges of accounting for the unknown observation process considerable. Our quantitative framework for citizen surveillance calls for an integration of citizen science and crowdsourcing and provides a way forward to solve the statistical challenges inherent to citizen-sourced data.

AB - Citizen science and crowdsourcing have been emerging as methods to collect data for surveillance and/or monitoring activities. They could be gathered under the overarching term citizen surveillance. The discipline, however, still struggles to be widely accepted in the scientific community, mainly because these activities are not embedded in a quantitative framework. This results in an ongoing discussion on how to analyze and make useful inference from these data. When considering the data collection process, we illustrate how citizen surveillance can be classified according to the nature of the underlying observation process measured in two dimensions—the degree of observer reporting intention and the control in observer detection effort. By classifying the observation process in these dimensions we distinguish between crowdsourcing, unstructured citizen science and structured citizen science. This classification helps the determine data processing and statistical treatment of these data for making inference. Using our framework, it is apparent that published studies are overwhelmingly associated with structured citizen science, and there are well developed statistical methods for the resulting data. In contrast, methods for making useful inference from purely crowd-sourced data remain under development, with the challenges of accounting for the unknown observation process considerable. Our quantitative framework for citizen surveillance calls for an integration of citizen science and crowdsourcing and provides a way forward to solve the statistical challenges inherent to citizen-sourced data.

KW - Citizen science

KW - Crowdsourcing

KW - Data generation process

KW - Environmental statistics

KW - General surveillance

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84994056177&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/citizen-surveillance-environmental-monitoring-combining-efforts-citizen-science-crowdsourcing-quanti

U2 - 10.1186/s40064-016-3583-5

DO - 10.1186/s40064-016-3583-5

M3 - Article

VL - 5

JO - Springer Plus

JF - Springer Plus

SN - 2193-1801

IS - 1

M1 - 1890

ER -