Comment on “Evaluating and modelling splash detachment capacity based on laboratory experiments” by Wu et al. (2019) Catena 176, 189–196

P. I.A. Kinnell

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

Abstract

In an experiment where one of the objectives was to evaluate the effects of slope gradient and rainfall intensity on splash detachment capacity, the authors measured material splashed into slots along the sides of an area eroding by rain-impacted flow. They concluded from their results that their finding was not consistent with previous reports which suggested that splash detachment capacity could be predicted by a power function of rainfall intensity and slope gradient. In rain-impacted flows, a number of transport mechanisms operate in the flow in addition to material transported by splash. Given that only particles that are transported by the transport by splash are considered in the work reported in this paper, the results presented do not give data on how rainfall characteristics and slope gradient influence detachment in raindrop driven erosion. Also, because the transport mechanisms that exist in rain-impacted flow are not 100% efficient, it is not possible to determine detachment by raindrops in rain-impacted flows from the measurement of sediments discharged by splash and surface water flows in experiments like those reported in this paper.

Original languageEnglish
Article number104189
Pages (from-to)1-2
Number of pages2
JournalCatena
Volume183
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2019

Fingerprint

catena
modeling
raindrop
precipitation intensity
water flow
experiment
laboratory experiment
surface water
erosion
rainfall
rain
sediment

Cite this

@article{8a444e343eaa477b9dca8b67dfb00ea5,
title = "Comment on “Evaluating and modelling splash detachment capacity based on laboratory experiments” by Wu et al. (2019) Catena 176, 189–196",
abstract = "In an experiment where one of the objectives was to evaluate the effects of slope gradient and rainfall intensity on splash detachment capacity, the authors measured material splashed into slots along the sides of an area eroding by rain-impacted flow. They concluded from their results that their finding was not consistent with previous reports which suggested that splash detachment capacity could be predicted by a power function of rainfall intensity and slope gradient. In rain-impacted flows, a number of transport mechanisms operate in the flow in addition to material transported by splash. Given that only particles that are transported by the transport by splash are considered in the work reported in this paper, the results presented do not give data on how rainfall characteristics and slope gradient influence detachment in raindrop driven erosion. Also, because the transport mechanisms that exist in rain-impacted flow are not 100{\%} efficient, it is not possible to determine detachment by raindrops in rain-impacted flows from the measurement of sediments discharged by splash and surface water flows in experiments like those reported in this paper.",
keywords = "Rain-impacted flows, Raindrop detachment, Rainfall erosion",
author = "Kinnell, {P. I.A.}",
year = "2019",
month = "12",
doi = "10.1016/j.catena.2019.104189",
language = "English",
volume = "183",
pages = "1--2",
journal = "Catena",
issn = "0341-8162",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Comment on “Evaluating and modelling splash detachment capacity based on laboratory experiments” by Wu et al. (2019) Catena 176, 189–196. / Kinnell, P. I.A.

In: Catena, Vol. 183, 104189, 12.2019, p. 1-2.

Research output: Contribution to journalComment/debate

TY - JOUR

T1 - Comment on “Evaluating and modelling splash detachment capacity based on laboratory experiments” by Wu et al. (2019) Catena 176, 189–196

AU - Kinnell, P. I.A.

PY - 2019/12

Y1 - 2019/12

N2 - In an experiment where one of the objectives was to evaluate the effects of slope gradient and rainfall intensity on splash detachment capacity, the authors measured material splashed into slots along the sides of an area eroding by rain-impacted flow. They concluded from their results that their finding was not consistent with previous reports which suggested that splash detachment capacity could be predicted by a power function of rainfall intensity and slope gradient. In rain-impacted flows, a number of transport mechanisms operate in the flow in addition to material transported by splash. Given that only particles that are transported by the transport by splash are considered in the work reported in this paper, the results presented do not give data on how rainfall characteristics and slope gradient influence detachment in raindrop driven erosion. Also, because the transport mechanisms that exist in rain-impacted flow are not 100% efficient, it is not possible to determine detachment by raindrops in rain-impacted flows from the measurement of sediments discharged by splash and surface water flows in experiments like those reported in this paper.

AB - In an experiment where one of the objectives was to evaluate the effects of slope gradient and rainfall intensity on splash detachment capacity, the authors measured material splashed into slots along the sides of an area eroding by rain-impacted flow. They concluded from their results that their finding was not consistent with previous reports which suggested that splash detachment capacity could be predicted by a power function of rainfall intensity and slope gradient. In rain-impacted flows, a number of transport mechanisms operate in the flow in addition to material transported by splash. Given that only particles that are transported by the transport by splash are considered in the work reported in this paper, the results presented do not give data on how rainfall characteristics and slope gradient influence detachment in raindrop driven erosion. Also, because the transport mechanisms that exist in rain-impacted flow are not 100% efficient, it is not possible to determine detachment by raindrops in rain-impacted flows from the measurement of sediments discharged by splash and surface water flows in experiments like those reported in this paper.

KW - Rain-impacted flows

KW - Raindrop detachment

KW - Rainfall erosion

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85069941673&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.catena.2019.104189

DO - 10.1016/j.catena.2019.104189

M3 - Comment/debate

VL - 183

SP - 1

EP - 2

JO - Catena

JF - Catena

SN - 0341-8162

M1 - 104189

ER -