Composing the Whole Thing

Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

Abstract

A central mode of thinking for built environment practitioners generally and architects in particular is that based on part to whole relationships, the idea that fractional relationships necessarily characterise coherent objects and building ensembles and in turn reference nature as the basis for beauty. The notion that all parts relate to a whole can be taken as one index of the limits practitioners, educators, and scholars have identified in certain modes of thinking and practice whether at the scale of the building or the scale of urban form. This paper pursues research into alternate modes of architectural design that challenge perceived limits of part-whole logics, revealing other manners of thinking that deploy specific form-generation strategies and devices and contribute to a practice that embraces complexity and in turn reveals unforeseen potentialities on the edge of design research. The paper does this through the analysis of the work of architect Peter Eisenman (b.1932). While there is evidence of this temperament at play in office projects, the paper focuses on Eisenman’s university studio teaching. Through an analysis of select university studios, the paper reveals instances in Eisenman’s teaching that promote different issues, different problematics, and singular form-composition strategies that together embrace ambiguity through such notions as partial fragment, superposition, and aggregation. Referencing published and unpublished teaching materials and student work, the paper examines Eisenman’s three-year Venice Project studio (2009, 2010, 2011) and Aggregation Project studio (2013) delivered at the Yale School of Architecture. The paper contributes to secondary scholarship on Eisenman with its focus on a little studied aspect of his work, adds to investigations in design research, and is aligned with the conference theme scholarship and theory of design research in architecture.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18)
EditorsDuncan Maxwell
Place of PublicationSydney
PublisherUniversity of Sydney
Pages687-697
Number of pages11
ISBN (Print)9780646992495
Publication statusPublished - 8 Oct 2018

Fingerprint

Studios
Teaching
Agglomeration
Architectural design
Students
Chemical analysis

Cite this

JASPER, M. (2018). Composing the Whole Thing: Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching. In D. Maxwell (Ed.), Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18) (pp. 687-697). Sydney: University of Sydney.
JASPER, Michael. / Composing the Whole Thing : Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching. Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18). editor / Duncan Maxwell. Sydney : University of Sydney, 2018. pp. 687-697
@inbook{5ea8fb87cee74ad490aff6fdc6b7b4a3,
title = "Composing the Whole Thing: Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching",
abstract = "A central mode of thinking for built environment practitioners generally and architects in particular is that based on part to whole relationships, the idea that fractional relationships necessarily characterise coherent objects and building ensembles and in turn reference nature as the basis for beauty. The notion that all parts relate to a whole can be taken as one index of the limits practitioners, educators, and scholars have identified in certain modes of thinking and practice whether at the scale of the building or the scale of urban form. This paper pursues research into alternate modes of architectural design that challenge perceived limits of part-whole logics, revealing other manners of thinking that deploy specific form-generation strategies and devices and contribute to a practice that embraces complexity and in turn reveals unforeseen potentialities on the edge of design research. The paper does this through the analysis of the work of architect Peter Eisenman (b.1932). While there is evidence of this temperament at play in office projects, the paper focuses on Eisenman’s university studio teaching. Through an analysis of select university studios, the paper reveals instances in Eisenman’s teaching that promote different issues, different problematics, and singular form-composition strategies that together embrace ambiguity through such notions as partial fragment, superposition, and aggregation. Referencing published and unpublished teaching materials and student work, the paper examines Eisenman’s three-year Venice Project studio (2009, 2010, 2011) and Aggregation Project studio (2013) delivered at the Yale School of Architecture. The paper contributes to secondary scholarship on Eisenman with its focus on a little studied aspect of his work, adds to investigations in design research, and is aligned with the conference theme scholarship and theory of design research in architecture.",
keywords = "design research, architecture, part to whole, studio teaching",
author = "Michael JASPER",
note = "Jasper, M. 2018. “Composing the Whole Thing.” In Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18). University of Sydney, Sydney 27-28 September 2018, edited by Duncan W. Maxwell, 687-697. Sydney: The University of Sydney.",
year = "2018",
month = "10",
day = "8",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780646992495",
pages = "687--697",
editor = "Duncan Maxwell",
booktitle = "Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18)",
publisher = "University of Sydney",
address = "Australia",

}

JASPER, M 2018, Composing the Whole Thing: Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching. in D Maxwell (ed.), Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18). University of Sydney, Sydney, pp. 687-697.

Composing the Whole Thing : Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching. / JASPER, Michael.

Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18). ed. / Duncan Maxwell. Sydney : University of Sydney, 2018. p. 687-697.

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Composing the Whole Thing

T2 - Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching

AU - JASPER, Michael

N1 - Jasper, M. 2018. “Composing the Whole Thing.” In Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18). University of Sydney, Sydney 27-28 September 2018, edited by Duncan W. Maxwell, 687-697. Sydney: The University of Sydney.

PY - 2018/10/8

Y1 - 2018/10/8

N2 - A central mode of thinking for built environment practitioners generally and architects in particular is that based on part to whole relationships, the idea that fractional relationships necessarily characterise coherent objects and building ensembles and in turn reference nature as the basis for beauty. The notion that all parts relate to a whole can be taken as one index of the limits practitioners, educators, and scholars have identified in certain modes of thinking and practice whether at the scale of the building or the scale of urban form. This paper pursues research into alternate modes of architectural design that challenge perceived limits of part-whole logics, revealing other manners of thinking that deploy specific form-generation strategies and devices and contribute to a practice that embraces complexity and in turn reveals unforeseen potentialities on the edge of design research. The paper does this through the analysis of the work of architect Peter Eisenman (b.1932). While there is evidence of this temperament at play in office projects, the paper focuses on Eisenman’s university studio teaching. Through an analysis of select university studios, the paper reveals instances in Eisenman’s teaching that promote different issues, different problematics, and singular form-composition strategies that together embrace ambiguity through such notions as partial fragment, superposition, and aggregation. Referencing published and unpublished teaching materials and student work, the paper examines Eisenman’s three-year Venice Project studio (2009, 2010, 2011) and Aggregation Project studio (2013) delivered at the Yale School of Architecture. The paper contributes to secondary scholarship on Eisenman with its focus on a little studied aspect of his work, adds to investigations in design research, and is aligned with the conference theme scholarship and theory of design research in architecture.

AB - A central mode of thinking for built environment practitioners generally and architects in particular is that based on part to whole relationships, the idea that fractional relationships necessarily characterise coherent objects and building ensembles and in turn reference nature as the basis for beauty. The notion that all parts relate to a whole can be taken as one index of the limits practitioners, educators, and scholars have identified in certain modes of thinking and practice whether at the scale of the building or the scale of urban form. This paper pursues research into alternate modes of architectural design that challenge perceived limits of part-whole logics, revealing other manners of thinking that deploy specific form-generation strategies and devices and contribute to a practice that embraces complexity and in turn reveals unforeseen potentialities on the edge of design research. The paper does this through the analysis of the work of architect Peter Eisenman (b.1932). While there is evidence of this temperament at play in office projects, the paper focuses on Eisenman’s university studio teaching. Through an analysis of select university studios, the paper reveals instances in Eisenman’s teaching that promote different issues, different problematics, and singular form-composition strategies that together embrace ambiguity through such notions as partial fragment, superposition, and aggregation. Referencing published and unpublished teaching materials and student work, the paper examines Eisenman’s three-year Venice Project studio (2009, 2010, 2011) and Aggregation Project studio (2013) delivered at the Yale School of Architecture. The paper contributes to secondary scholarship on Eisenman with its focus on a little studied aspect of his work, adds to investigations in design research, and is aligned with the conference theme scholarship and theory of design research in architecture.

KW - design research

KW - architecture

KW - part to whole

KW - studio teaching

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780646992495

SP - 687

EP - 697

BT - Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18)

A2 - Maxwell, Duncan

PB - University of Sydney

CY - Sydney

ER -

JASPER M. Composing the Whole Thing: Design Research in Peter Eisenman’s Recent Studio Teaching. In Maxwell D, editor, Proceedings of the 1st Annual Design Research Conference (ADR18). Sydney: University of Sydney. 2018. p. 687-697