Conceptualising goodies and baddies through narratives of Jesus and Superman

Miriam Giugni

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Religion, like Superhero discourse, is a contested topic of question and debate in early childhood education. This article draws on data from a small ethnographic study that took place in a long day care centre in Sydney Australia. The study examined how children negotiated their ‘identity work’ in the context of popular culture. In this article, the author explores one example from the study in which a group of four-year-old boys drew upon discourses of Christianity and Superheroes in the negotiation of their identities within an early childhood curriculum. Using post-structural and critical theory, the article highlights how these moral and cultural epistemologies appeared easily accessible and desirable to the children and were particularly useful in their negotiated narratives of goodies and baddies. Consequently, questions are asked of the ways early childhood guidelines for practice both embody and reject discourses of religion and Superheroes because such values appear to be culturally risky in an inclusive curriculum. It is clear, therefore, that both superheroes and religion hold exchange value for some children in the negotiation of their identities, yet, such discourses are often invisible or banned in early childhood curriculum
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)97-108
Number of pages12
JournalContemporary Issues in Early Childhood
Volume7
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2006
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Religion
Curriculum
childhood
Negotiating
narrative
discourse
curriculum
Christianity
Practice Guidelines
day care
critical theory
popular culture
epistemology
Education
Values
education
Group

Cite this

@article{715d9e7b01a148b189d894d5af55efd7,
title = "Conceptualising goodies and baddies through narratives of Jesus and Superman",
abstract = "Religion, like Superhero discourse, is a contested topic of question and debate in early childhood education. This article draws on data from a small ethnographic study that took place in a long day care centre in Sydney Australia. The study examined how children negotiated their ‘identity work’ in the context of popular culture. In this article, the author explores one example from the study in which a group of four-year-old boys drew upon discourses of Christianity and Superheroes in the negotiation of their identities within an early childhood curriculum. Using post-structural and critical theory, the article highlights how these moral and cultural epistemologies appeared easily accessible and desirable to the children and were particularly useful in their negotiated narratives of goodies and baddies. Consequently, questions are asked of the ways early childhood guidelines for practice both embody and reject discourses of religion and Superheroes because such values appear to be culturally risky in an inclusive curriculum. It is clear, therefore, that both superheroes and religion hold exchange value for some children in the negotiation of their identities, yet, such discourses are often invisible or banned in early childhood curriculum",
author = "Miriam Giugni",
year = "2006",
doi = "10.2304/ciec.2006.7.2.97",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "97--108",
journal = "Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood",
issn = "1463-9491",
publisher = "Triangle Journals Ltd.",
number = "2",

}

Conceptualising goodies and baddies through narratives of Jesus and Superman. / Giugni, Miriam.

In: Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood, Vol. 7, No. 2, 2006, p. 97-108.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Conceptualising goodies and baddies through narratives of Jesus and Superman

AU - Giugni, Miriam

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - Religion, like Superhero discourse, is a contested topic of question and debate in early childhood education. This article draws on data from a small ethnographic study that took place in a long day care centre in Sydney Australia. The study examined how children negotiated their ‘identity work’ in the context of popular culture. In this article, the author explores one example from the study in which a group of four-year-old boys drew upon discourses of Christianity and Superheroes in the negotiation of their identities within an early childhood curriculum. Using post-structural and critical theory, the article highlights how these moral and cultural epistemologies appeared easily accessible and desirable to the children and were particularly useful in their negotiated narratives of goodies and baddies. Consequently, questions are asked of the ways early childhood guidelines for practice both embody and reject discourses of religion and Superheroes because such values appear to be culturally risky in an inclusive curriculum. It is clear, therefore, that both superheroes and religion hold exchange value for some children in the negotiation of their identities, yet, such discourses are often invisible or banned in early childhood curriculum

AB - Religion, like Superhero discourse, is a contested topic of question and debate in early childhood education. This article draws on data from a small ethnographic study that took place in a long day care centre in Sydney Australia. The study examined how children negotiated their ‘identity work’ in the context of popular culture. In this article, the author explores one example from the study in which a group of four-year-old boys drew upon discourses of Christianity and Superheroes in the negotiation of their identities within an early childhood curriculum. Using post-structural and critical theory, the article highlights how these moral and cultural epistemologies appeared easily accessible and desirable to the children and were particularly useful in their negotiated narratives of goodies and baddies. Consequently, questions are asked of the ways early childhood guidelines for practice both embody and reject discourses of religion and Superheroes because such values appear to be culturally risky in an inclusive curriculum. It is clear, therefore, that both superheroes and religion hold exchange value for some children in the negotiation of their identities, yet, such discourses are often invisible or banned in early childhood curriculum

U2 - 10.2304/ciec.2006.7.2.97

DO - 10.2304/ciec.2006.7.2.97

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 97

EP - 108

JO - Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood

JF - Contemporary Issues in Early Childhood

SN - 1463-9491

IS - 2

ER -