Detecting rare carnivores using scats: Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania

David S L Ramsey, Candida Barclay, Catriona D Campbell, Elise Dewar, Anna J MacDonald, Elodie Modave, Sumaiya Quasim, Stephen D Sarre

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The ability to detect the incursion of an invasive species or destroy the last individuals during an eradication program are some of the most difficult aspects of invasive species management. The presence of foxes in Tasmania is a contentious issue with recent structured monitoring efforts, involving collection of carnivore scats and testing for fox DNA, failing to detect any evidence of foxes. Understanding the likelihood that monitoring efforts would detect fox presence, given at least one is present, is therefore critical for understanding the role of scat monitoring for informing the response to an incursion. We undertook trials to estimate the probability of fox scat detection through monitoring by scat-detector dogs and person searches and used this information to critically evaluate the power of scat monitoring efforts for detecting foxes in the Tasmanian landscape. The probability of detecting a single scat present in a 1-km2 survey unit was highest for scat-detector dogs searches (0.053) compared with person searches (x¯≅0.015) for each 10 km of search effort. Simulation of the power of recent scat monitoring efforts undertaken in Tasmania from 2011 to 2015 suggested that single foxes would have to be present in at least 20 different locations or fox breeding groups present in at least six different locations, in order to be detected with a high level of confidence (>0.80). We have shown that highly structured detection trials can provide managers with the quantitative tools needed to make judgments about the power of large-scale scat monitoring programs. Results suggest that a fox population, if present in Tasmania, could remain undetected by a large-scale, structured scat monitoring program. Therefore, it is likely that other forms of surveillance, in conjunction with scat monitoring, will be necessary to demonstrate that foxes are absent from Tasmania with high confidence.

LanguageEnglish
Pages732-743
Number of pages12
JournalEcology and Evolution
Volume8
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2018
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Tasmania
carnivore
foxes
carnivores
feces
monitoring
invasive species
detectors
dogs
managers
breeding
DNA

Cite this

Ramsey, D. S. L., Barclay, C., Campbell, C. D., Dewar, E., MacDonald, A. J., Modave, E., ... Sarre, S. D. (2018). Detecting rare carnivores using scats: Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania. Ecology and Evolution, 8(1), 732-743. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.3694
Ramsey, David S L ; Barclay, Candida ; Campbell, Catriona D ; Dewar, Elise ; MacDonald, Anna J ; Modave, Elodie ; Quasim, Sumaiya ; Sarre, Stephen D. / Detecting rare carnivores using scats : Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania. In: Ecology and Evolution. 2018 ; Vol. 8, No. 1. pp. 732-743.
@article{c10aaea7323847ee9bb7d9aa78e15bcd,
title = "Detecting rare carnivores using scats: Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania",
abstract = "The ability to detect the incursion of an invasive species or destroy the last individuals during an eradication program are some of the most difficult aspects of invasive species management. The presence of foxes in Tasmania is a contentious issue with recent structured monitoring efforts, involving collection of carnivore scats and testing for fox DNA, failing to detect any evidence of foxes. Understanding the likelihood that monitoring efforts would detect fox presence, given at least one is present, is therefore critical for understanding the role of scat monitoring for informing the response to an incursion. We undertook trials to estimate the probability of fox scat detection through monitoring by scat-detector dogs and person searches and used this information to critically evaluate the power of scat monitoring efforts for detecting foxes in the Tasmanian landscape. The probability of detecting a single scat present in a 1-km2 survey unit was highest for scat-detector dogs searches (0.053) compared with person searches (x¯≅0.015) for each 10 km of search effort. Simulation of the power of recent scat monitoring efforts undertaken in Tasmania from 2011 to 2015 suggested that single foxes would have to be present in at least 20 different locations or fox breeding groups present in at least six different locations, in order to be detected with a high level of confidence (>0.80). We have shown that highly structured detection trials can provide managers with the quantitative tools needed to make judgments about the power of large-scale scat monitoring programs. Results suggest that a fox population, if present in Tasmania, could remain undetected by a large-scale, structured scat monitoring program. Therefore, it is likely that other forms of surveillance, in conjunction with scat monitoring, will be necessary to demonstrate that foxes are absent from Tasmania with high confidence.",
keywords = "Journal Article",
author = "Ramsey, {David S L} and Candida Barclay and Campbell, {Catriona D} and Elise Dewar and MacDonald, {Anna J} and Elodie Modave and Sumaiya Quasim and Sarre, {Stephen D}",
year = "2018",
month = "1",
doi = "10.1002/ece3.3694",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "732--743",
journal = "Ecology and Evolution",
issn = "2045-7758",
publisher = "John Wiley & Sons",
number = "1",

}

Ramsey, DSL, Barclay, C, Campbell, CD, Dewar, E, MacDonald, AJ, Modave, E, Quasim, S & Sarre, SD 2018, 'Detecting rare carnivores using scats: Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania', Ecology and Evolution, vol. 8, no. 1, pp. 732-743. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.3694

Detecting rare carnivores using scats : Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania. / Ramsey, David S L; Barclay, Candida; Campbell, Catriona D; Dewar, Elise; MacDonald, Anna J; Modave, Elodie; Quasim, Sumaiya; Sarre, Stephen D.

In: Ecology and Evolution, Vol. 8, No. 1, 01.2018, p. 732-743.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Detecting rare carnivores using scats

T2 - Ecology and Evolution

AU - Ramsey, David S L

AU - Barclay, Candida

AU - Campbell, Catriona D

AU - Dewar, Elise

AU - MacDonald, Anna J

AU - Modave, Elodie

AU - Quasim, Sumaiya

AU - Sarre, Stephen D

PY - 2018/1

Y1 - 2018/1

N2 - The ability to detect the incursion of an invasive species or destroy the last individuals during an eradication program are some of the most difficult aspects of invasive species management. The presence of foxes in Tasmania is a contentious issue with recent structured monitoring efforts, involving collection of carnivore scats and testing for fox DNA, failing to detect any evidence of foxes. Understanding the likelihood that monitoring efforts would detect fox presence, given at least one is present, is therefore critical for understanding the role of scat monitoring for informing the response to an incursion. We undertook trials to estimate the probability of fox scat detection through monitoring by scat-detector dogs and person searches and used this information to critically evaluate the power of scat monitoring efforts for detecting foxes in the Tasmanian landscape. The probability of detecting a single scat present in a 1-km2 survey unit was highest for scat-detector dogs searches (0.053) compared with person searches (x¯≅0.015) for each 10 km of search effort. Simulation of the power of recent scat monitoring efforts undertaken in Tasmania from 2011 to 2015 suggested that single foxes would have to be present in at least 20 different locations or fox breeding groups present in at least six different locations, in order to be detected with a high level of confidence (>0.80). We have shown that highly structured detection trials can provide managers with the quantitative tools needed to make judgments about the power of large-scale scat monitoring programs. Results suggest that a fox population, if present in Tasmania, could remain undetected by a large-scale, structured scat monitoring program. Therefore, it is likely that other forms of surveillance, in conjunction with scat monitoring, will be necessary to demonstrate that foxes are absent from Tasmania with high confidence.

AB - The ability to detect the incursion of an invasive species or destroy the last individuals during an eradication program are some of the most difficult aspects of invasive species management. The presence of foxes in Tasmania is a contentious issue with recent structured monitoring efforts, involving collection of carnivore scats and testing for fox DNA, failing to detect any evidence of foxes. Understanding the likelihood that monitoring efforts would detect fox presence, given at least one is present, is therefore critical for understanding the role of scat monitoring for informing the response to an incursion. We undertook trials to estimate the probability of fox scat detection through monitoring by scat-detector dogs and person searches and used this information to critically evaluate the power of scat monitoring efforts for detecting foxes in the Tasmanian landscape. The probability of detecting a single scat present in a 1-km2 survey unit was highest for scat-detector dogs searches (0.053) compared with person searches (x¯≅0.015) for each 10 km of search effort. Simulation of the power of recent scat monitoring efforts undertaken in Tasmania from 2011 to 2015 suggested that single foxes would have to be present in at least 20 different locations or fox breeding groups present in at least six different locations, in order to be detected with a high level of confidence (>0.80). We have shown that highly structured detection trials can provide managers with the quantitative tools needed to make judgments about the power of large-scale scat monitoring programs. Results suggest that a fox population, if present in Tasmania, could remain undetected by a large-scale, structured scat monitoring program. Therefore, it is likely that other forms of surveillance, in conjunction with scat monitoring, will be necessary to demonstrate that foxes are absent from Tasmania with high confidence.

KW - Journal Article

U2 - 10.1002/ece3.3694

DO - 10.1002/ece3.3694

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 732

EP - 743

JO - Ecology and Evolution

JF - Ecology and Evolution

SN - 2045-7758

IS - 1

ER -

Ramsey DSL, Barclay C, Campbell CD, Dewar E, MacDonald AJ, Modave E et al. Detecting rare carnivores using scats: Implications for monitoring a fox incursion into Tasmania. Ecology and Evolution. 2018 Jan;8(1):732-743. https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.3694