Does the "script" need a rewrite?

Is medication advice in television medical dramas appropriate?

Melissa Cowley, Mark Naunton, Jackson Thomas, Freya Waddington, Gregory M Peterson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

WHAT IS KNOWN AND OBJECTIVE: Television medical dramas depict the healthcare industry and draw considerable interest from the public, while pharmacists play an integral part in providing medication-related advice to the public and other health practitioners in real life. The main objective of this retrospective, observational study was to assess the appropriateness of medication advice given in televised medical dramas and how frequently pharmacists were involved in providing the medication advice.

METHODS: Show selection was based on fictional series with a medical drama theme and having the highest viewership. Approximately 100 randomly selected hours of five medical television dramas (House, Grey's Anatomy, Nurse Jackie, Doc Martin and Royal Pains) were assessed for the appropriateness of advice given based on the medication indicated, number of safety checks performed, and the level of adherence to standard clinical guidelines. The appropriateness of medication advice was assessed as appropriate, mostly appropriate, partially appropriate and inappropriate using a piloted, 0-6 point scale. Other parameters recorded included patient demographics, health professionals involved, and the categories of medicines.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS: Medications were mentioned on 424 occasions (on average four times per hour), including 239 occasions where medication advice was given. A pharmacist was involved in giving medication advice only 16 times (7%). Using the assessment tool, overall, medication advice was deemed to be appropriate 24% of the time, mostly appropriate 34%, partially appropriate 13% and inappropriate 7%. Although the medication advice given was often for the correct indication and the advice somewhat followed clinical guidelines, it frequently omitted adequate safety checks. Doc Martin had the highest mean appropriateness score, whereas House and Grey's Anatomy had the lowest.

WHAT IS NEW AND CONCLUSIONS: Medication was often used for the correct indication in television medical dramas; however, key safety checks were frequently omitted and other medication-related advice, including dose, was less reliable and accurate. Pharmacists were rarely involved in providing medication advice. Viewers should not base medication-related decisions solely on what they see in television medical dramas, and any medication-related advice should be interpreted with extreme caution.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)765-773
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics
Volume42
Issue number6
Early online date17 Aug 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2017

Fingerprint

Drama
Television
Pharmacists
Safety
Anatomy
Guidelines
Health Care Sector
Observational Studies
Retrospective Studies
Public Health
Nurses
Demography
Pain
Health

Cite this

@article{ede1a8f355d04c7aa1fe46b5f0d0d301,
title = "Does the {"}script{"} need a rewrite?: Is medication advice in television medical dramas appropriate?",
abstract = "WHAT IS KNOWN AND OBJECTIVE: Television medical dramas depict the healthcare industry and draw considerable interest from the public, while pharmacists play an integral part in providing medication-related advice to the public and other health practitioners in real life. The main objective of this retrospective, observational study was to assess the appropriateness of medication advice given in televised medical dramas and how frequently pharmacists were involved in providing the medication advice.METHODS: Show selection was based on fictional series with a medical drama theme and having the highest viewership. Approximately 100 randomly selected hours of five medical television dramas (House, Grey's Anatomy, Nurse Jackie, Doc Martin and Royal Pains) were assessed for the appropriateness of advice given based on the medication indicated, number of safety checks performed, and the level of adherence to standard clinical guidelines. The appropriateness of medication advice was assessed as appropriate, mostly appropriate, partially appropriate and inappropriate using a piloted, 0-6 point scale. Other parameters recorded included patient demographics, health professionals involved, and the categories of medicines.RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS: Medications were mentioned on 424 occasions (on average four times per hour), including 239 occasions where medication advice was given. A pharmacist was involved in giving medication advice only 16 times (7{\%}). Using the assessment tool, overall, medication advice was deemed to be appropriate 24{\%} of the time, mostly appropriate 34{\%}, partially appropriate 13{\%} and inappropriate 7{\%}. Although the medication advice given was often for the correct indication and the advice somewhat followed clinical guidelines, it frequently omitted adequate safety checks. Doc Martin had the highest mean appropriateness score, whereas House and Grey's Anatomy had the lowest.WHAT IS NEW AND CONCLUSIONS: Medication was often used for the correct indication in television medical dramas; however, key safety checks were frequently omitted and other medication-related advice, including dose, was less reliable and accurate. Pharmacists were rarely involved in providing medication advice. Viewers should not base medication-related decisions solely on what they see in television medical dramas, and any medication-related advice should be interpreted with extreme caution.",
keywords = "appropriateness, entertainment, media, medical television dramas, medication, medication advice, pharmacist",
author = "Melissa Cowley and Mark Naunton and Jackson Thomas and Freya Waddington and Peterson, {Gregory M}",
note = "{\circledC} 2017 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.",
year = "2017",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/jcpt.12581",
language = "English",
volume = "42",
pages = "765--773",
journal = "Journal of Clinical and Hospital Pharmacy",
issn = "0269-4727",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "6",

}

Does the "script" need a rewrite? Is medication advice in television medical dramas appropriate? / Cowley, Melissa; Naunton, Mark; Thomas, Jackson; Waddington, Freya; Peterson, Gregory M.

In: Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics, Vol. 42, No. 6, 01.12.2017, p. 765-773.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Does the "script" need a rewrite?

T2 - Is medication advice in television medical dramas appropriate?

AU - Cowley, Melissa

AU - Naunton, Mark

AU - Thomas, Jackson

AU - Waddington, Freya

AU - Peterson, Gregory M

N1 - © 2017 John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

PY - 2017/12/1

Y1 - 2017/12/1

N2 - WHAT IS KNOWN AND OBJECTIVE: Television medical dramas depict the healthcare industry and draw considerable interest from the public, while pharmacists play an integral part in providing medication-related advice to the public and other health practitioners in real life. The main objective of this retrospective, observational study was to assess the appropriateness of medication advice given in televised medical dramas and how frequently pharmacists were involved in providing the medication advice.METHODS: Show selection was based on fictional series with a medical drama theme and having the highest viewership. Approximately 100 randomly selected hours of five medical television dramas (House, Grey's Anatomy, Nurse Jackie, Doc Martin and Royal Pains) were assessed for the appropriateness of advice given based on the medication indicated, number of safety checks performed, and the level of adherence to standard clinical guidelines. The appropriateness of medication advice was assessed as appropriate, mostly appropriate, partially appropriate and inappropriate using a piloted, 0-6 point scale. Other parameters recorded included patient demographics, health professionals involved, and the categories of medicines.RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS: Medications were mentioned on 424 occasions (on average four times per hour), including 239 occasions where medication advice was given. A pharmacist was involved in giving medication advice only 16 times (7%). Using the assessment tool, overall, medication advice was deemed to be appropriate 24% of the time, mostly appropriate 34%, partially appropriate 13% and inappropriate 7%. Although the medication advice given was often for the correct indication and the advice somewhat followed clinical guidelines, it frequently omitted adequate safety checks. Doc Martin had the highest mean appropriateness score, whereas House and Grey's Anatomy had the lowest.WHAT IS NEW AND CONCLUSIONS: Medication was often used for the correct indication in television medical dramas; however, key safety checks were frequently omitted and other medication-related advice, including dose, was less reliable and accurate. Pharmacists were rarely involved in providing medication advice. Viewers should not base medication-related decisions solely on what they see in television medical dramas, and any medication-related advice should be interpreted with extreme caution.

AB - WHAT IS KNOWN AND OBJECTIVE: Television medical dramas depict the healthcare industry and draw considerable interest from the public, while pharmacists play an integral part in providing medication-related advice to the public and other health practitioners in real life. The main objective of this retrospective, observational study was to assess the appropriateness of medication advice given in televised medical dramas and how frequently pharmacists were involved in providing the medication advice.METHODS: Show selection was based on fictional series with a medical drama theme and having the highest viewership. Approximately 100 randomly selected hours of five medical television dramas (House, Grey's Anatomy, Nurse Jackie, Doc Martin and Royal Pains) were assessed for the appropriateness of advice given based on the medication indicated, number of safety checks performed, and the level of adherence to standard clinical guidelines. The appropriateness of medication advice was assessed as appropriate, mostly appropriate, partially appropriate and inappropriate using a piloted, 0-6 point scale. Other parameters recorded included patient demographics, health professionals involved, and the categories of medicines.RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS: Medications were mentioned on 424 occasions (on average four times per hour), including 239 occasions where medication advice was given. A pharmacist was involved in giving medication advice only 16 times (7%). Using the assessment tool, overall, medication advice was deemed to be appropriate 24% of the time, mostly appropriate 34%, partially appropriate 13% and inappropriate 7%. Although the medication advice given was often for the correct indication and the advice somewhat followed clinical guidelines, it frequently omitted adequate safety checks. Doc Martin had the highest mean appropriateness score, whereas House and Grey's Anatomy had the lowest.WHAT IS NEW AND CONCLUSIONS: Medication was often used for the correct indication in television medical dramas; however, key safety checks were frequently omitted and other medication-related advice, including dose, was less reliable and accurate. Pharmacists were rarely involved in providing medication advice. Viewers should not base medication-related decisions solely on what they see in television medical dramas, and any medication-related advice should be interpreted with extreme caution.

KW - appropriateness

KW - entertainment

KW - media

KW - medical television dramas

KW - medication

KW - medication advice

KW - pharmacist

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85032832447&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.embase.com/search/results?subaction=viewrecord&from=export&id=L619097792 http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/jcpt.12581 http://rug.on.worldcat.org/atoztitles/link/?sid=EMBASE&issn=13652710&id=doi:10.1111%2Fjcpt.12581&atitle=Does+the+“script”+need+a+rewri

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/script-need-rewrite-medication-advice-television-medical-dramas-appropriate

U2 - 10.1111/jcpt.12581

DO - 10.1111/jcpt.12581

M3 - Article

VL - 42

SP - 765

EP - 773

JO - Journal of Clinical and Hospital Pharmacy

JF - Journal of Clinical and Hospital Pharmacy

SN - 0269-4727

IS - 6

ER -