Drought alters the functional stability of stream invertebrate communities through time

Catherine Leigh, Thomas W.H. Aspin, Thomas J. Matthews, Robert J. Rolls, Mark E. Ledger

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Aim: In fresh waters, most biogeographical understanding of how extreme events such as drought modify biodiversity and ecosystem functioning derives from static, spatial comparisons of ecological communities, between intact and disturbed sites or along stress gradients. Impacts of drought on the development of ecological communities over time remain poorly resolved, with information on parallel trends in community structure and function particularly scarce. In theory, drought could progressively eliminate both species and functional traits, rendering communities increasingly taxonomically and functionally nested subsets of their pre-existing counterparts. Alternatively, drought could create new niche opportunities, producing a continuous turnover of species and traits, or simply constrain natural community succession. Location: Dorset, UK. Taxon: Aquatic invertebrates. Methods: We studied temporal changes in community structure and function in artificial streams over 2 years, comparing drought (frequent drying) with control (constant flow) conditions. Temporal beta diversity was partitioned into turnover and nestedness components, calculated using both presence–absence and abundance data, and analysed using time-lag and null modelling approaches. Results: Community development was comparable taxonomically under control and drought conditions, driven primarily by temporal turnover of species. Under control conditions, corresponding trends in functional composition were not apparent, and species turnover was characterized by the progressive replacement of some species by others of equivalent abundance. By contrast, species turnover in disturbed communities was accompanied by both functional turnover and greater loss of individuals, indicating that new colonists were not equivalent, either functionally or numerically, to those they replaced. Furthermore, functional dissimilarities between time points were greatest under drought, and more similar in magnitude to taxonomic dissimilarities, implying that drying reduced the stability and redundancy of functional attributes. Main conclusion: A shift to drier climate could disrupt the natural development of stream community structure, and undermine functional stability, at local and biogeographical scales, with potentially significant consequences for ecosystem services provisioning in fresh waters.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-13
Number of pages13
JournalJournal of Biogeography
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 7 Jun 2019

Fingerprint

invertebrate
drought
invertebrates
turnover
community structure
drying
nestedness
aquatic invertebrates
community development
rendering
extreme event
ecosystem service
ecosystem services
niche
niches
replacement
biodiversity
climate
water
ecosystems

Cite this

Leigh, Catherine ; Aspin, Thomas W.H. ; Matthews, Thomas J. ; Rolls, Robert J. ; Ledger, Mark E. / Drought alters the functional stability of stream invertebrate communities through time. In: Journal of Biogeography. 2019 ; pp. 1-13.
@article{225077d17b23444ea38f8c832404b5ac,
title = "Drought alters the functional stability of stream invertebrate communities through time",
abstract = "Aim: In fresh waters, most biogeographical understanding of how extreme events such as drought modify biodiversity and ecosystem functioning derives from static, spatial comparisons of ecological communities, between intact and disturbed sites or along stress gradients. Impacts of drought on the development of ecological communities over time remain poorly resolved, with information on parallel trends in community structure and function particularly scarce. In theory, drought could progressively eliminate both species and functional traits, rendering communities increasingly taxonomically and functionally nested subsets of their pre-existing counterparts. Alternatively, drought could create new niche opportunities, producing a continuous turnover of species and traits, or simply constrain natural community succession. Location: Dorset, UK. Taxon: Aquatic invertebrates. Methods: We studied temporal changes in community structure and function in artificial streams over 2 years, comparing drought (frequent drying) with control (constant flow) conditions. Temporal beta diversity was partitioned into turnover and nestedness components, calculated using both presence–absence and abundance data, and analysed using time-lag and null modelling approaches. Results: Community development was comparable taxonomically under control and drought conditions, driven primarily by temporal turnover of species. Under control conditions, corresponding trends in functional composition were not apparent, and species turnover was characterized by the progressive replacement of some species by others of equivalent abundance. By contrast, species turnover in disturbed communities was accompanied by both functional turnover and greater loss of individuals, indicating that new colonists were not equivalent, either functionally or numerically, to those they replaced. Furthermore, functional dissimilarities between time points were greatest under drought, and more similar in magnitude to taxonomic dissimilarities, implying that drying reduced the stability and redundancy of functional attributes. Main conclusion: A shift to drier climate could disrupt the natural development of stream community structure, and undermine functional stability, at local and biogeographical scales, with potentially significant consequences for ecosystem services provisioning in fresh waters.",
keywords = "aquatic invertebrates, climate change, community development, disturbance, drought, functional traits, nestedness, streams and rivers, temporal beta diversity, turnover",
author = "Catherine Leigh and Aspin, {Thomas W.H.} and Matthews, {Thomas J.} and Rolls, {Robert J.} and Ledger, {Mark E.}",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1111/jbi.13638",
language = "English",
pages = "1--13",
journal = "Journal of Biogeography",
issn = "0305-0270",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",

}

Drought alters the functional stability of stream invertebrate communities through time. / Leigh, Catherine; Aspin, Thomas W.H.; Matthews, Thomas J.; Rolls, Robert J.; Ledger, Mark E.

In: Journal of Biogeography, 07.06.2019, p. 1-13.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Drought alters the functional stability of stream invertebrate communities through time

AU - Leigh, Catherine

AU - Aspin, Thomas W.H.

AU - Matthews, Thomas J.

AU - Rolls, Robert J.

AU - Ledger, Mark E.

PY - 2019/6/7

Y1 - 2019/6/7

N2 - Aim: In fresh waters, most biogeographical understanding of how extreme events such as drought modify biodiversity and ecosystem functioning derives from static, spatial comparisons of ecological communities, between intact and disturbed sites or along stress gradients. Impacts of drought on the development of ecological communities over time remain poorly resolved, with information on parallel trends in community structure and function particularly scarce. In theory, drought could progressively eliminate both species and functional traits, rendering communities increasingly taxonomically and functionally nested subsets of their pre-existing counterparts. Alternatively, drought could create new niche opportunities, producing a continuous turnover of species and traits, or simply constrain natural community succession. Location: Dorset, UK. Taxon: Aquatic invertebrates. Methods: We studied temporal changes in community structure and function in artificial streams over 2 years, comparing drought (frequent drying) with control (constant flow) conditions. Temporal beta diversity was partitioned into turnover and nestedness components, calculated using both presence–absence and abundance data, and analysed using time-lag and null modelling approaches. Results: Community development was comparable taxonomically under control and drought conditions, driven primarily by temporal turnover of species. Under control conditions, corresponding trends in functional composition were not apparent, and species turnover was characterized by the progressive replacement of some species by others of equivalent abundance. By contrast, species turnover in disturbed communities was accompanied by both functional turnover and greater loss of individuals, indicating that new colonists were not equivalent, either functionally or numerically, to those they replaced. Furthermore, functional dissimilarities between time points were greatest under drought, and more similar in magnitude to taxonomic dissimilarities, implying that drying reduced the stability and redundancy of functional attributes. Main conclusion: A shift to drier climate could disrupt the natural development of stream community structure, and undermine functional stability, at local and biogeographical scales, with potentially significant consequences for ecosystem services provisioning in fresh waters.

AB - Aim: In fresh waters, most biogeographical understanding of how extreme events such as drought modify biodiversity and ecosystem functioning derives from static, spatial comparisons of ecological communities, between intact and disturbed sites or along stress gradients. Impacts of drought on the development of ecological communities over time remain poorly resolved, with information on parallel trends in community structure and function particularly scarce. In theory, drought could progressively eliminate both species and functional traits, rendering communities increasingly taxonomically and functionally nested subsets of their pre-existing counterparts. Alternatively, drought could create new niche opportunities, producing a continuous turnover of species and traits, or simply constrain natural community succession. Location: Dorset, UK. Taxon: Aquatic invertebrates. Methods: We studied temporal changes in community structure and function in artificial streams over 2 years, comparing drought (frequent drying) with control (constant flow) conditions. Temporal beta diversity was partitioned into turnover and nestedness components, calculated using both presence–absence and abundance data, and analysed using time-lag and null modelling approaches. Results: Community development was comparable taxonomically under control and drought conditions, driven primarily by temporal turnover of species. Under control conditions, corresponding trends in functional composition were not apparent, and species turnover was characterized by the progressive replacement of some species by others of equivalent abundance. By contrast, species turnover in disturbed communities was accompanied by both functional turnover and greater loss of individuals, indicating that new colonists were not equivalent, either functionally or numerically, to those they replaced. Furthermore, functional dissimilarities between time points were greatest under drought, and more similar in magnitude to taxonomic dissimilarities, implying that drying reduced the stability and redundancy of functional attributes. Main conclusion: A shift to drier climate could disrupt the natural development of stream community structure, and undermine functional stability, at local and biogeographical scales, with potentially significant consequences for ecosystem services provisioning in fresh waters.

KW - aquatic invertebrates

KW - climate change

KW - community development

KW - disturbance

KW - drought

KW - functional traits

KW - nestedness

KW - streams and rivers

KW - temporal beta diversity

KW - turnover

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85067355751&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/jbi.13638

DO - 10.1111/jbi.13638

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 13

JO - Journal of Biogeography

JF - Journal of Biogeography

SN - 0305-0270

ER -