Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs

Paul D. Meek, Stuart C. Brown, Jason Wishart, Heath Milne, Paul Aylett, Simon Humphrys, Guy Ballard, Peter Fleming

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Context: Wildlife and pest managers and stakeholders should constantly aim to improve animal-welfare outcomes when foot-hold trapping pest animals. To minimise stress and trauma to trapped animals, traps should be checked at least once every 24 h, normally as soon after sunrise as possible. If distance, time, environmental or geographical constraints prevent this, toxins such as strychnine can be fitted to trap jaws to induce euthanasia. However, strychnine is considered to have undesirable animal-welfare outcomes because animals are conscious while clinical signs of intoxication are present. A toxin considered more humane, para-aminopropiophenone (PAPP), is available to induce euthanasia in trapped animals but is untested for presentation and efficacy. Aim: We tested the efficacy of two types of lethal trap device (LTD's), each using a paste formulation of PAPP as the active toxin to replace the use of strychnine on foot-hold jaw traps. Methods: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP-cloths were fitted to jaw traps set to capture wild dogs (Canis familiaris). Camera-trap data was used to record animal behaviours after capture and to determine the efficacy of both modalities. Key results: Every trapped wild dog (n = 117) gnawed at the elastomer LTD's or PAPP-cloth attached to the trap jaws that restrained them; one dog failed to liberate the toxin. From the dogs caught in the main trial (n = 56), a mortality rate of 84% and 87% was reported respectively. The mean time from trap-to-death for elastomer LTDs was 64 min and 68 min for PAPP-cloths. Conclusions: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP cloths combined caused the mortality of 85% of captured dogs. This efficacy could be improved by adopting the recommendations discussed in the present study for deploying PAPP-based LTDs during trap deployment. Implications: PAPP-based LTDs offer an alternative option to the use of strychnine and improve the welfare outcomes for trapped predators, especially where traps are not checked within the recommended 24-h period.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)89-95
Number of pages7
JournalWildlife Research
Volume46
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2019
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

traps
toxin
dogs
animal welfare
strychnine
animal
jaws
toxins
mortality
euthanasia
trapping
stakeholder
dog
predator
vertebrate pests
animals
animal behavior
cameras
stakeholders
poisoning

Cite this

Meek, P. D., Brown, S. C., Wishart, J., Milne, H., Aylett, P., Humphrys, S., ... Fleming, P. (2019). Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs. Wildlife Research, 46(1), 89-95. https://doi.org/10.1071/WR18129
Meek, Paul D. ; Brown, Stuart C. ; Wishart, Jason ; Milne, Heath ; Aylett, Paul ; Humphrys, Simon ; Ballard, Guy ; Fleming, Peter. / Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs. In: Wildlife Research. 2019 ; Vol. 46, No. 1. pp. 89-95.
@article{2b1c04a976a748d59570475b0d3307a7,
title = "Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs",
abstract = "Context: Wildlife and pest managers and stakeholders should constantly aim to improve animal-welfare outcomes when foot-hold trapping pest animals. To minimise stress and trauma to trapped animals, traps should be checked at least once every 24 h, normally as soon after sunrise as possible. If distance, time, environmental or geographical constraints prevent this, toxins such as strychnine can be fitted to trap jaws to induce euthanasia. However, strychnine is considered to have undesirable animal-welfare outcomes because animals are conscious while clinical signs of intoxication are present. A toxin considered more humane, para-aminopropiophenone (PAPP), is available to induce euthanasia in trapped animals but is untested for presentation and efficacy. Aim: We tested the efficacy of two types of lethal trap device (LTD's), each using a paste formulation of PAPP as the active toxin to replace the use of strychnine on foot-hold jaw traps. Methods: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP-cloths were fitted to jaw traps set to capture wild dogs (Canis familiaris). Camera-trap data was used to record animal behaviours after capture and to determine the efficacy of both modalities. Key results: Every trapped wild dog (n = 117) gnawed at the elastomer LTD's or PAPP-cloth attached to the trap jaws that restrained them; one dog failed to liberate the toxin. From the dogs caught in the main trial (n = 56), a mortality rate of 84{\%} and 87{\%} was reported respectively. The mean time from trap-to-death for elastomer LTDs was 64 min and 68 min for PAPP-cloths. Conclusions: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP cloths combined caused the mortality of 85{\%} of captured dogs. This efficacy could be improved by adopting the recommendations discussed in the present study for deploying PAPP-based LTDs during trap deployment. Implications: PAPP-based LTDs offer an alternative option to the use of strychnine and improve the welfare outcomes for trapped predators, especially where traps are not checked within the recommended 24-h period.",
keywords = "canids, control, humaneness, LTD, pest management, predator, trapping",
author = "Meek, {Paul D.} and Brown, {Stuart C.} and Jason Wishart and Heath Milne and Paul Aylett and Simon Humphrys and Guy Ballard and Peter Fleming",
year = "2019",
doi = "10.1071/WR18129",
language = "English",
volume = "46",
pages = "89--95",
journal = "Australian Wildlife Research",
issn = "1035-3712",
publisher = "CSIRO",
number = "1",

}

Meek, PD, Brown, SC, Wishart, J, Milne, H, Aylett, P, Humphrys, S, Ballard, G & Fleming, P 2019, 'Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs', Wildlife Research, vol. 46, no. 1, pp. 89-95. https://doi.org/10.1071/WR18129

Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs. / Meek, Paul D.; Brown, Stuart C.; Wishart, Jason; Milne, Heath; Aylett, Paul; Humphrys, Simon; Ballard, Guy; Fleming, Peter.

In: Wildlife Research, Vol. 46, No. 1, 2019, p. 89-95.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs

AU - Meek, Paul D.

AU - Brown, Stuart C.

AU - Wishart, Jason

AU - Milne, Heath

AU - Aylett, Paul

AU - Humphrys, Simon

AU - Ballard, Guy

AU - Fleming, Peter

PY - 2019

Y1 - 2019

N2 - Context: Wildlife and pest managers and stakeholders should constantly aim to improve animal-welfare outcomes when foot-hold trapping pest animals. To minimise stress and trauma to trapped animals, traps should be checked at least once every 24 h, normally as soon after sunrise as possible. If distance, time, environmental or geographical constraints prevent this, toxins such as strychnine can be fitted to trap jaws to induce euthanasia. However, strychnine is considered to have undesirable animal-welfare outcomes because animals are conscious while clinical signs of intoxication are present. A toxin considered more humane, para-aminopropiophenone (PAPP), is available to induce euthanasia in trapped animals but is untested for presentation and efficacy. Aim: We tested the efficacy of two types of lethal trap device (LTD's), each using a paste formulation of PAPP as the active toxin to replace the use of strychnine on foot-hold jaw traps. Methods: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP-cloths were fitted to jaw traps set to capture wild dogs (Canis familiaris). Camera-trap data was used to record animal behaviours after capture and to determine the efficacy of both modalities. Key results: Every trapped wild dog (n = 117) gnawed at the elastomer LTD's or PAPP-cloth attached to the trap jaws that restrained them; one dog failed to liberate the toxin. From the dogs caught in the main trial (n = 56), a mortality rate of 84% and 87% was reported respectively. The mean time from trap-to-death for elastomer LTDs was 64 min and 68 min for PAPP-cloths. Conclusions: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP cloths combined caused the mortality of 85% of captured dogs. This efficacy could be improved by adopting the recommendations discussed in the present study for deploying PAPP-based LTDs during trap deployment. Implications: PAPP-based LTDs offer an alternative option to the use of strychnine and improve the welfare outcomes for trapped predators, especially where traps are not checked within the recommended 24-h period.

AB - Context: Wildlife and pest managers and stakeholders should constantly aim to improve animal-welfare outcomes when foot-hold trapping pest animals. To minimise stress and trauma to trapped animals, traps should be checked at least once every 24 h, normally as soon after sunrise as possible. If distance, time, environmental or geographical constraints prevent this, toxins such as strychnine can be fitted to trap jaws to induce euthanasia. However, strychnine is considered to have undesirable animal-welfare outcomes because animals are conscious while clinical signs of intoxication are present. A toxin considered more humane, para-aminopropiophenone (PAPP), is available to induce euthanasia in trapped animals but is untested for presentation and efficacy. Aim: We tested the efficacy of two types of lethal trap device (LTD's), each using a paste formulation of PAPP as the active toxin to replace the use of strychnine on foot-hold jaw traps. Methods: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP-cloths were fitted to jaw traps set to capture wild dogs (Canis familiaris). Camera-trap data was used to record animal behaviours after capture and to determine the efficacy of both modalities. Key results: Every trapped wild dog (n = 117) gnawed at the elastomer LTD's or PAPP-cloth attached to the trap jaws that restrained them; one dog failed to liberate the toxin. From the dogs caught in the main trial (n = 56), a mortality rate of 84% and 87% was reported respectively. The mean time from trap-to-death for elastomer LTDs was 64 min and 68 min for PAPP-cloths. Conclusions: Elastomer LTDs and PAPP cloths combined caused the mortality of 85% of captured dogs. This efficacy could be improved by adopting the recommendations discussed in the present study for deploying PAPP-based LTDs during trap deployment. Implications: PAPP-based LTDs offer an alternative option to the use of strychnine and improve the welfare outcomes for trapped predators, especially where traps are not checked within the recommended 24-h period.

KW - canids

KW - control

KW - humaneness

KW - LTD

KW - pest management

KW - predator

KW - trapping

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85061703589&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1071/WR18129

DO - 10.1071/WR18129

M3 - Article

VL - 46

SP - 89

EP - 95

JO - Australian Wildlife Research

JF - Australian Wildlife Research

SN - 1035-3712

IS - 1

ER -

Meek PD, Brown SC, Wishart J, Milne H, Aylett P, Humphrys S et al. Efficacy of lethal-trap devices to improve the welfare of trapped wild dogs. Wildlife Research. 2019;46(1):89-95. https://doi.org/10.1071/WR18129