Exploring the intervention-context interface: A case from a school-based nutrition intervention

Sherri Bisset, Mark Daniel, Louise Potvin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

15 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

It has been acknowledged for several decades that programs interact with context. The nature of this interactivity, and how it defines a program, has not been adequately addressed. We view this lacuna as a function of the dominant theoretical perspectives guiding knowledge of program operations. We propose the actor-network theory (ANT) and its conceptual apparatus, the sociotechnical network, as suitable for guiding the acquisition of general knowledge on program operations. We tested this proposition with an instrumental case study of health professional practices during the implementation of a nutrition program into an elementary school setting. Data collection and analysis were guided by the ANT. Data were derived from semistructured interviews completed with six health professionals (nutritionists). Analysis procedures focused on the nutritionists' collective representation of the microprocesses by which they aimed to build a sociotechnical network of alliances with educational stakeholders. Findings identified nutritionists as preoccupied with three overarching goals during the implementation of the nutrition program, whereby goals were found to take form interactively with the interests of the program participants (primarily students) and stakeholders (primarily teachers). Nutritionists strategically translated program components as a means of negotiating with participants and stakeholders. The findings of this study support the theoretical proposition that program implementation is a process of expanding a sociotechnical network. Beyond simply reaffirming that programs do indeed adapt to context, we interpret this adaptation through the lens of a social theory that suggests why and how adaptation is an inevitable component of program implementation.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)554-571
Number of pages18
JournalAmerican Journal of Evaluation
Volume30
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2009
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Nutritionists
nutrition
nutritionist
school
Professional Practice
Negotiating
Health
Lenses
actor-network-theory
stakeholder
Theoretical Models
Interviews
Students
health professionals
Nutrition
analysis procedure
interactive media
elementary school
data analysis

Cite this

@article{a31039224e904652b3bc75ac81564c7b,
title = "Exploring the intervention-context interface: A case from a school-based nutrition intervention",
abstract = "It has been acknowledged for several decades that programs interact with context. The nature of this interactivity, and how it defines a program, has not been adequately addressed. We view this lacuna as a function of the dominant theoretical perspectives guiding knowledge of program operations. We propose the actor-network theory (ANT) and its conceptual apparatus, the sociotechnical network, as suitable for guiding the acquisition of general knowledge on program operations. We tested this proposition with an instrumental case study of health professional practices during the implementation of a nutrition program into an elementary school setting. Data collection and analysis were guided by the ANT. Data were derived from semistructured interviews completed with six health professionals (nutritionists). Analysis procedures focused on the nutritionists' collective representation of the microprocesses by which they aimed to build a sociotechnical network of alliances with educational stakeholders. Findings identified nutritionists as preoccupied with three overarching goals during the implementation of the nutrition program, whereby goals were found to take form interactively with the interests of the program participants (primarily students) and stakeholders (primarily teachers). Nutritionists strategically translated program components as a means of negotiating with participants and stakeholders. The findings of this study support the theoretical proposition that program implementation is a process of expanding a sociotechnical network. Beyond simply reaffirming that programs do indeed adapt to context, we interpret this adaptation through the lens of a social theory that suggests why and how adaptation is an inevitable component of program implementation.",
keywords = "Community health promotion, Program evaluation, Program implementation, School-based nutrition intervention",
author = "Sherri Bisset and Mark Daniel and Louise Potvin",
year = "2009",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1177/1098214009349792",
language = "English",
volume = "30",
pages = "554--571",
journal = "Evaluation Practice",
issn = "1098-2140",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Ltd",
number = "4",

}

Exploring the intervention-context interface: A case from a school-based nutrition intervention. / Bisset, Sherri; Daniel, Mark; Potvin, Louise.

In: American Journal of Evaluation, Vol. 30, No. 4, 01.12.2009, p. 554-571.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Exploring the intervention-context interface: A case from a school-based nutrition intervention

AU - Bisset, Sherri

AU - Daniel, Mark

AU - Potvin, Louise

PY - 2009/12/1

Y1 - 2009/12/1

N2 - It has been acknowledged for several decades that programs interact with context. The nature of this interactivity, and how it defines a program, has not been adequately addressed. We view this lacuna as a function of the dominant theoretical perspectives guiding knowledge of program operations. We propose the actor-network theory (ANT) and its conceptual apparatus, the sociotechnical network, as suitable for guiding the acquisition of general knowledge on program operations. We tested this proposition with an instrumental case study of health professional practices during the implementation of a nutrition program into an elementary school setting. Data collection and analysis were guided by the ANT. Data were derived from semistructured interviews completed with six health professionals (nutritionists). Analysis procedures focused on the nutritionists' collective representation of the microprocesses by which they aimed to build a sociotechnical network of alliances with educational stakeholders. Findings identified nutritionists as preoccupied with three overarching goals during the implementation of the nutrition program, whereby goals were found to take form interactively with the interests of the program participants (primarily students) and stakeholders (primarily teachers). Nutritionists strategically translated program components as a means of negotiating with participants and stakeholders. The findings of this study support the theoretical proposition that program implementation is a process of expanding a sociotechnical network. Beyond simply reaffirming that programs do indeed adapt to context, we interpret this adaptation through the lens of a social theory that suggests why and how adaptation is an inevitable component of program implementation.

AB - It has been acknowledged for several decades that programs interact with context. The nature of this interactivity, and how it defines a program, has not been adequately addressed. We view this lacuna as a function of the dominant theoretical perspectives guiding knowledge of program operations. We propose the actor-network theory (ANT) and its conceptual apparatus, the sociotechnical network, as suitable for guiding the acquisition of general knowledge on program operations. We tested this proposition with an instrumental case study of health professional practices during the implementation of a nutrition program into an elementary school setting. Data collection and analysis were guided by the ANT. Data were derived from semistructured interviews completed with six health professionals (nutritionists). Analysis procedures focused on the nutritionists' collective representation of the microprocesses by which they aimed to build a sociotechnical network of alliances with educational stakeholders. Findings identified nutritionists as preoccupied with three overarching goals during the implementation of the nutrition program, whereby goals were found to take form interactively with the interests of the program participants (primarily students) and stakeholders (primarily teachers). Nutritionists strategically translated program components as a means of negotiating with participants and stakeholders. The findings of this study support the theoretical proposition that program implementation is a process of expanding a sociotechnical network. Beyond simply reaffirming that programs do indeed adapt to context, we interpret this adaptation through the lens of a social theory that suggests why and how adaptation is an inevitable component of program implementation.

KW - Community health promotion

KW - Program evaluation

KW - Program implementation

KW - School-based nutrition intervention

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=70449629108&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1177/1098214009349792

DO - 10.1177/1098214009349792

M3 - Article

VL - 30

SP - 554

EP - 571

JO - Evaluation Practice

JF - Evaluation Practice

SN - 1098-2140

IS - 4

ER -