"Getting it right the first time"

Critical issues at the crime scene

Roberta Julian, Sally Kelty, James Robertson

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    4 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    This article examines a number of critical issues associated with the collection of forensic evidence at the crime scene. It argues that the crime scene is one of the most crucial aspects of an investigation and that the scene of the crime is where good forensic science begins. The article begins by demonstrating that high quality and useful evidence leading to accurate and fair criminal justice outcomes can only occur if the scene is processed effectively and professionally. Reducing risk of unjust outcomes is especially important in serious matters, such as homicide and sexual assault, for two reasons. First, the more serious the matter, the more likely that evidence mishandling can lead to wrongful imprisonment. Second, the more serious the matter, the more personnel will be involved, and the more likely that these personnel will be multidisciplinary (law enforcement, medicine, law, forensic science) and multi-organisational (health, justice, private legal/medical, police). Many of these personnel will have divergent work practices and divergent views about what their role is, or should be, during investigations and court trials. Drawing on empirical data from interviews with crime scene examiners, police, forensic scientists, lawyers and judges in a number of Australian jurisdictions, the article discusses the management of the crime scene as a critical issue in the justice process
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)25-37
    Number of pages13
    JournalCurrent Issues in Criminal Justice
    Volume24
    Issue number1
    Publication statusPublished - 2012

    Fingerprint

    offense
    personnel
    justice
    police
    evidence
    examiner
    imprisonment
    assault
    science
    law enforcement
    lawyer
    homicide
    jurisdiction
    medicine
    Law
    interview
    health
    management

    Cite this

    @article{49f5813d3b554c48819afd2a27cc9b46,
    title = "{"}Getting it right the first time{"}: Critical issues at the crime scene",
    abstract = "This article examines a number of critical issues associated with the collection of forensic evidence at the crime scene. It argues that the crime scene is one of the most crucial aspects of an investigation and that the scene of the crime is where good forensic science begins. The article begins by demonstrating that high quality and useful evidence leading to accurate and fair criminal justice outcomes can only occur if the scene is processed effectively and professionally. Reducing risk of unjust outcomes is especially important in serious matters, such as homicide and sexual assault, for two reasons. First, the more serious the matter, the more likely that evidence mishandling can lead to wrongful imprisonment. Second, the more serious the matter, the more personnel will be involved, and the more likely that these personnel will be multidisciplinary (law enforcement, medicine, law, forensic science) and multi-organisational (health, justice, private legal/medical, police). Many of these personnel will have divergent work practices and divergent views about what their role is, or should be, during investigations and court trials. Drawing on empirical data from interviews with crime scene examiners, police, forensic scientists, lawyers and judges in a number of Australian jurisdictions, the article discusses the management of the crime scene as a critical issue in the justice process",
    keywords = "crime scene, justice, investigation",
    author = "Roberta Julian and Sally Kelty and James Robertson",
    year = "2012",
    language = "English",
    volume = "24",
    pages = "25--37",
    journal = "Current Issues in Criminal Justice",
    issn = "1034-5329",
    number = "1",

    }

    "Getting it right the first time" : Critical issues at the crime scene. / Julian, Roberta; Kelty, Sally; Robertson, James.

    In: Current Issues in Criminal Justice, Vol. 24, No. 1, 2012, p. 25-37.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - "Getting it right the first time"

    T2 - Critical issues at the crime scene

    AU - Julian, Roberta

    AU - Kelty, Sally

    AU - Robertson, James

    PY - 2012

    Y1 - 2012

    N2 - This article examines a number of critical issues associated with the collection of forensic evidence at the crime scene. It argues that the crime scene is one of the most crucial aspects of an investigation and that the scene of the crime is where good forensic science begins. The article begins by demonstrating that high quality and useful evidence leading to accurate and fair criminal justice outcomes can only occur if the scene is processed effectively and professionally. Reducing risk of unjust outcomes is especially important in serious matters, such as homicide and sexual assault, for two reasons. First, the more serious the matter, the more likely that evidence mishandling can lead to wrongful imprisonment. Second, the more serious the matter, the more personnel will be involved, and the more likely that these personnel will be multidisciplinary (law enforcement, medicine, law, forensic science) and multi-organisational (health, justice, private legal/medical, police). Many of these personnel will have divergent work practices and divergent views about what their role is, or should be, during investigations and court trials. Drawing on empirical data from interviews with crime scene examiners, police, forensic scientists, lawyers and judges in a number of Australian jurisdictions, the article discusses the management of the crime scene as a critical issue in the justice process

    AB - This article examines a number of critical issues associated with the collection of forensic evidence at the crime scene. It argues that the crime scene is one of the most crucial aspects of an investigation and that the scene of the crime is where good forensic science begins. The article begins by demonstrating that high quality and useful evidence leading to accurate and fair criminal justice outcomes can only occur if the scene is processed effectively and professionally. Reducing risk of unjust outcomes is especially important in serious matters, such as homicide and sexual assault, for two reasons. First, the more serious the matter, the more likely that evidence mishandling can lead to wrongful imprisonment. Second, the more serious the matter, the more personnel will be involved, and the more likely that these personnel will be multidisciplinary (law enforcement, medicine, law, forensic science) and multi-organisational (health, justice, private legal/medical, police). Many of these personnel will have divergent work practices and divergent views about what their role is, or should be, during investigations and court trials. Drawing on empirical data from interviews with crime scene examiners, police, forensic scientists, lawyers and judges in a number of Australian jurisdictions, the article discusses the management of the crime scene as a critical issue in the justice process

    KW - crime scene

    KW - justice

    KW - investigation

    M3 - Article

    VL - 24

    SP - 25

    EP - 37

    JO - Current Issues in Criminal Justice

    JF - Current Issues in Criminal Justice

    SN - 1034-5329

    IS - 1

    ER -