Global Biodiversity Assessment and Hyper-Cryptic Species Complexes: More Than One Species of Elephant in the Room?

Mark Adams, Tarmo Raadik, Christopher Burridge, Arthur GEORGES

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    69 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Several recent estimates of global biodiversity have concluded that the total number of species on Earth lies near the lower end of the wide range touted in previous decades. However, none of these recent estimates formally explore the real elephant in the room, namely, what proportion of species are taxonomically invisible to conventional assessments, and thus, as undiagnosed cryptic species, remain uncountable until revealed by multi-gene molecular assessments. Here we explore the significance and extent of so-called hyper-cryptic species complexes, using the Australian freshwater fish Galaxias olidus as a proxy for any organism whose taxonomy ought to be largely finalized when compared to those in little-studied or morphologically undifferentiated groups. Our comprehensive allozyme (838 fish for 54 putative loci), mtDNA (557 fish for 605 bp of cytb), and morphological (1963-3389 vouchers for 17-58 characters) assessment of this species across its broad geographic range revealed a 1500% increase in species-level biodiversity, and suggested that additional taxa may remain undiscovered. Importantly, while all 15 candidate species were morphologically diagnosable a posteriori from one another, single-gene DNA barcoding proved largely unsuccessful as an a priori method for species identification. These results lead us to draw two strong inferences of relevance to estimates of global biodiversity. First, hyper-cryptic complexes are likely to be common in many organismal groups. Second, no assessment of species numbers can be considered best practice in the molecular age unless it explicitly includes estimates of the extent of cryptic and hyper-cryptic biodiversity. [Galaxiidae; global estimates; hyper-diverse; mountain galaxias; species counts; species richness.]

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)518-533
    Number of pages16
    JournalSystematic Biology
    Volume63
    Issue number4
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2014

    Fingerprint

    Biodiversity
    species complex
    biodiversity
    Fishes
    Osmeriformes
    Galaxiidae
    DNA barcoding
    Proxy
    Fresh Water
    fish
    Mitochondrial DNA
    Practice Guidelines
    freshwater fish
    allozymes
    Isoenzymes
    Genes
    mitochondrial DNA
    genes
    taxonomy
    species diversity

    Cite this

    @article{cd8c9740674342b28521888dfdc0fc03,
    title = "Global Biodiversity Assessment and Hyper-Cryptic Species Complexes: More Than One Species of Elephant in the Room?",
    abstract = "Several recent estimates of global biodiversity have concluded that the total number of species on Earth lies near the lower end of the wide range touted in previous decades. However, none of these recent estimates formally explore the real elephant in the room, namely, what proportion of species are taxonomically invisible to conventional assessments, and thus, as undiagnosed cryptic species, remain uncountable until revealed by multi-gene molecular assessments. Here we explore the significance and extent of so-called hyper-cryptic species complexes, using the Australian freshwater fish Galaxias olidus as a proxy for any organism whose taxonomy ought to be largely finalized when compared to those in little-studied or morphologically undifferentiated groups. Our comprehensive allozyme (838 fish for 54 putative loci), mtDNA (557 fish for 605 bp of cytb), and morphological (1963-3389 vouchers for 17-58 characters) assessment of this species across its broad geographic range revealed a 1500{\%} increase in species-level biodiversity, and suggested that additional taxa may remain undiscovered. Importantly, while all 15 candidate species were morphologically diagnosable a posteriori from one another, single-gene DNA barcoding proved largely unsuccessful as an a priori method for species identification. These results lead us to draw two strong inferences of relevance to estimates of global biodiversity. First, hyper-cryptic complexes are likely to be common in many organismal groups. Second, no assessment of species numbers can be considered best practice in the molecular age unless it explicitly includes estimates of the extent of cryptic and hyper-cryptic biodiversity. [Galaxiidae; global estimates; hyper-diverse; mountain galaxias; species counts; species richness.]",
    keywords = "Galaxiidae, global estimates, hyper-diverse, mountain galaxias, species counts, species richness.",
    author = "Mark Adams and Tarmo Raadik and Christopher Burridge and Arthur GEORGES",
    year = "2014",
    doi = "10.1093/sysbio/syu017",
    language = "English",
    volume = "63",
    pages = "518--533",
    journal = "Systematic Zoology",
    issn = "1063-5157",
    publisher = "Oxford University Press",
    number = "4",

    }

    Global Biodiversity Assessment and Hyper-Cryptic Species Complexes: More Than One Species of Elephant in the Room? / Adams, Mark; Raadik, Tarmo; Burridge, Christopher; GEORGES, Arthur.

    In: Systematic Biology, Vol. 63, No. 4, 2014, p. 518-533.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Global Biodiversity Assessment and Hyper-Cryptic Species Complexes: More Than One Species of Elephant in the Room?

    AU - Adams, Mark

    AU - Raadik, Tarmo

    AU - Burridge, Christopher

    AU - GEORGES, Arthur

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - Several recent estimates of global biodiversity have concluded that the total number of species on Earth lies near the lower end of the wide range touted in previous decades. However, none of these recent estimates formally explore the real elephant in the room, namely, what proportion of species are taxonomically invisible to conventional assessments, and thus, as undiagnosed cryptic species, remain uncountable until revealed by multi-gene molecular assessments. Here we explore the significance and extent of so-called hyper-cryptic species complexes, using the Australian freshwater fish Galaxias olidus as a proxy for any organism whose taxonomy ought to be largely finalized when compared to those in little-studied or morphologically undifferentiated groups. Our comprehensive allozyme (838 fish for 54 putative loci), mtDNA (557 fish for 605 bp of cytb), and morphological (1963-3389 vouchers for 17-58 characters) assessment of this species across its broad geographic range revealed a 1500% increase in species-level biodiversity, and suggested that additional taxa may remain undiscovered. Importantly, while all 15 candidate species were morphologically diagnosable a posteriori from one another, single-gene DNA barcoding proved largely unsuccessful as an a priori method for species identification. These results lead us to draw two strong inferences of relevance to estimates of global biodiversity. First, hyper-cryptic complexes are likely to be common in many organismal groups. Second, no assessment of species numbers can be considered best practice in the molecular age unless it explicitly includes estimates of the extent of cryptic and hyper-cryptic biodiversity. [Galaxiidae; global estimates; hyper-diverse; mountain galaxias; species counts; species richness.]

    AB - Several recent estimates of global biodiversity have concluded that the total number of species on Earth lies near the lower end of the wide range touted in previous decades. However, none of these recent estimates formally explore the real elephant in the room, namely, what proportion of species are taxonomically invisible to conventional assessments, and thus, as undiagnosed cryptic species, remain uncountable until revealed by multi-gene molecular assessments. Here we explore the significance and extent of so-called hyper-cryptic species complexes, using the Australian freshwater fish Galaxias olidus as a proxy for any organism whose taxonomy ought to be largely finalized when compared to those in little-studied or morphologically undifferentiated groups. Our comprehensive allozyme (838 fish for 54 putative loci), mtDNA (557 fish for 605 bp of cytb), and morphological (1963-3389 vouchers for 17-58 characters) assessment of this species across its broad geographic range revealed a 1500% increase in species-level biodiversity, and suggested that additional taxa may remain undiscovered. Importantly, while all 15 candidate species were morphologically diagnosable a posteriori from one another, single-gene DNA barcoding proved largely unsuccessful as an a priori method for species identification. These results lead us to draw two strong inferences of relevance to estimates of global biodiversity. First, hyper-cryptic complexes are likely to be common in many organismal groups. Second, no assessment of species numbers can be considered best practice in the molecular age unless it explicitly includes estimates of the extent of cryptic and hyper-cryptic biodiversity. [Galaxiidae; global estimates; hyper-diverse; mountain galaxias; species counts; species richness.]

    KW - Galaxiidae

    KW - global estimates

    KW - hyper-diverse

    KW - mountain galaxias

    KW - species counts

    KW - species richness.

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84902531376&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/global-biodiversity-assessment-hypercryptic-species-complexes-more-one-species-elephant-room

    U2 - 10.1093/sysbio/syu017

    DO - 10.1093/sysbio/syu017

    M3 - Article

    VL - 63

    SP - 518

    EP - 533

    JO - Systematic Zoology

    JF - Systematic Zoology

    SN - 1063-5157

    IS - 4

    ER -