Heart-rate variability threshold as an alternative for spiro-ergometry testing

A validation study

Robert T. Mankowski, Scott Michael, Robert Rozenberg, Sebastiaan Stokla, Henk J. Stam, Stephan F.E. Praet

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Although spiro-ergometry is the established "gold standard" for determination of the second ventilatory threshold (VT2), it is a costly and rather time-consuming method. Previous studies suggest that assessing the second anaerobic threshold (AT2) on the basis of heart rate variability (HRV) during exercise may be a more cost-effective and noninvasive manner. However, appropriate validation studies, are still lacking. Eleven healthy, moderately trained subjects underwent 3 incremental exercise tests. Ventilation, oxygen uptake (Vo2), CO2 production (Vco2), and HRV were measured continuously. Exercise testing was performed in 3 oxygen (FiO2) conditions of inspired air (14, 21, and 35% of oxygen). Participants and assessors were blinded to the FiO2 conditions. Two research teams assessed VT2s and HRVT2s independently from each other. Mean workloads corresponding to VT2 and HRVT2 in hypoxia were, respectively, 19 ± 17% (p = 0.01) and 15 ± 15% (p = 0.1) lower in comparison with hyperoxic conditions. Bland-Altman analysis showed low estimation bias (2.2%) and acceptably precise 95% limits of agreement for workload -15.7% to 20.1% for all FiO2 conditions. Bias was the lowest under normoxic conditions (1.1%) in comparison with hypoxia (3.7%) and hyperoxia (4.7%). Heart rate variability-based AT2 assessment had a most acceptable agreement with VT2 under normoxic conditions. This simple HRVT2 assessment may have potential applications for exercise monitoring in commercial fitness settings.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)474-479
Number of pages6
JournalJournal of Strength and Conditioning Research
Volume31
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Feb 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Ergometry
Validation Studies
Heart Rate
Oxygen
Workload
Anaerobic Threshold
Hyperoxia
Exercise Test
Ventilation
Air
Costs and Cost Analysis
Research
Hypoxia

Cite this

Mankowski, Robert T. ; Michael, Scott ; Rozenberg, Robert ; Stokla, Sebastiaan ; Stam, Henk J. ; Praet, Stephan F.E. / Heart-rate variability threshold as an alternative for spiro-ergometry testing : A validation study. In: Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. 2017 ; Vol. 31, No. 2. pp. 474-479.
@article{35217f21d2724d19a3b80130a46a9e4d,
title = "Heart-rate variability threshold as an alternative for spiro-ergometry testing: A validation study",
abstract = "Although spiro-ergometry is the established {"}gold standard{"} for determination of the second ventilatory threshold (VT2), it is a costly and rather time-consuming method. Previous studies suggest that assessing the second anaerobic threshold (AT2) on the basis of heart rate variability (HRV) during exercise may be a more cost-effective and noninvasive manner. However, appropriate validation studies, are still lacking. Eleven healthy, moderately trained subjects underwent 3 incremental exercise tests. Ventilation, oxygen uptake (Vo2), CO2 production (Vco2), and HRV were measured continuously. Exercise testing was performed in 3 oxygen (FiO2) conditions of inspired air (14, 21, and 35{\%} of oxygen). Participants and assessors were blinded to the FiO2 conditions. Two research teams assessed VT2s and HRVT2s independently from each other. Mean workloads corresponding to VT2 and HRVT2 in hypoxia were, respectively, 19 ± 17{\%} (p = 0.01) and 15 ± 15{\%} (p = 0.1) lower in comparison with hyperoxic conditions. Bland-Altman analysis showed low estimation bias (2.2{\%}) and acceptably precise 95{\%} limits of agreement for workload -15.7{\%} to 20.1{\%} for all FiO2 conditions. Bias was the lowest under normoxic conditions (1.1{\%}) in comparison with hypoxia (3.7{\%}) and hyperoxia (4.7{\%}). Heart rate variability-based AT2 assessment had a most acceptable agreement with VT2 under normoxic conditions. This simple HRVT2 assessment may have potential applications for exercise monitoring in commercial fitness settings.",
keywords = "cost-effective, exercise, healthy subjects, hyperoxia, hypoxia, maximal testing",
author = "Mankowski, {Robert T.} and Scott Michael and Robert Rozenberg and Sebastiaan Stokla and Stam, {Henk J.} and Praet, {Stephan F.E.}",
year = "2017",
month = "2",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1519/JSC.0000000000001502.",
language = "English",
volume = "31",
pages = "474--479",
journal = "Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research",
issn = "1064-8011",
publisher = "NSCA National Strength and Conditioning Association",
number = "2",

}

Heart-rate variability threshold as an alternative for spiro-ergometry testing : A validation study. / Mankowski, Robert T.; Michael, Scott; Rozenberg, Robert; Stokla, Sebastiaan; Stam, Henk J.; Praet, Stephan F.E.

In: Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, Vol. 31, No. 2, 01.02.2017, p. 474-479.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Heart-rate variability threshold as an alternative for spiro-ergometry testing

T2 - A validation study

AU - Mankowski, Robert T.

AU - Michael, Scott

AU - Rozenberg, Robert

AU - Stokla, Sebastiaan

AU - Stam, Henk J.

AU - Praet, Stephan F.E.

PY - 2017/2/1

Y1 - 2017/2/1

N2 - Although spiro-ergometry is the established "gold standard" for determination of the second ventilatory threshold (VT2), it is a costly and rather time-consuming method. Previous studies suggest that assessing the second anaerobic threshold (AT2) on the basis of heart rate variability (HRV) during exercise may be a more cost-effective and noninvasive manner. However, appropriate validation studies, are still lacking. Eleven healthy, moderately trained subjects underwent 3 incremental exercise tests. Ventilation, oxygen uptake (Vo2), CO2 production (Vco2), and HRV were measured continuously. Exercise testing was performed in 3 oxygen (FiO2) conditions of inspired air (14, 21, and 35% of oxygen). Participants and assessors were blinded to the FiO2 conditions. Two research teams assessed VT2s and HRVT2s independently from each other. Mean workloads corresponding to VT2 and HRVT2 in hypoxia were, respectively, 19 ± 17% (p = 0.01) and 15 ± 15% (p = 0.1) lower in comparison with hyperoxic conditions. Bland-Altman analysis showed low estimation bias (2.2%) and acceptably precise 95% limits of agreement for workload -15.7% to 20.1% for all FiO2 conditions. Bias was the lowest under normoxic conditions (1.1%) in comparison with hypoxia (3.7%) and hyperoxia (4.7%). Heart rate variability-based AT2 assessment had a most acceptable agreement with VT2 under normoxic conditions. This simple HRVT2 assessment may have potential applications for exercise monitoring in commercial fitness settings.

AB - Although spiro-ergometry is the established "gold standard" for determination of the second ventilatory threshold (VT2), it is a costly and rather time-consuming method. Previous studies suggest that assessing the second anaerobic threshold (AT2) on the basis of heart rate variability (HRV) during exercise may be a more cost-effective and noninvasive manner. However, appropriate validation studies, are still lacking. Eleven healthy, moderately trained subjects underwent 3 incremental exercise tests. Ventilation, oxygen uptake (Vo2), CO2 production (Vco2), and HRV were measured continuously. Exercise testing was performed in 3 oxygen (FiO2) conditions of inspired air (14, 21, and 35% of oxygen). Participants and assessors were blinded to the FiO2 conditions. Two research teams assessed VT2s and HRVT2s independently from each other. Mean workloads corresponding to VT2 and HRVT2 in hypoxia were, respectively, 19 ± 17% (p = 0.01) and 15 ± 15% (p = 0.1) lower in comparison with hyperoxic conditions. Bland-Altman analysis showed low estimation bias (2.2%) and acceptably precise 95% limits of agreement for workload -15.7% to 20.1% for all FiO2 conditions. Bias was the lowest under normoxic conditions (1.1%) in comparison with hypoxia (3.7%) and hyperoxia (4.7%). Heart rate variability-based AT2 assessment had a most acceptable agreement with VT2 under normoxic conditions. This simple HRVT2 assessment may have potential applications for exercise monitoring in commercial fitness settings.

KW - cost-effective

KW - exercise

KW - healthy subjects

KW - hyperoxia

KW - hypoxia

KW - maximal testing

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85011655146&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/heartrate-variability-threshold-alternative-spiroergometry-testing-validation-study

U2 - 10.1519/JSC.0000000000001502.

DO - 10.1519/JSC.0000000000001502.

M3 - Article

VL - 31

SP - 474

EP - 479

JO - Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

JF - Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research

SN - 1064-8011

IS - 2

ER -