Influence of temporal scale of sampling on detection of relationships between invasive plants and the diversity patterns of plants and butterflies

R. Mac Nally, Erica Fleishman, Danielle Murphy

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    15 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Monitoring is a major component of restoration efforts and adaptive management. But monitoring is often neglected because it can be expensive and time-consuming. Accordingly, it is valuable to determine whether the temporal extent of sampling alters the validity of inferences about the response of diversity measures to environmental variables affected by restoration actions. Non-native species alter ecosystems in undesirable ways, frequently homogenizing flora and fauna and extirpating local populations of native species. In the Mojave Desert, invasion of salt-cedar (Tamarix ramosissima Ledeb.) and human efforts to eradicate salt-cedar have altered vegetation structure, vegetation composition, and some measures of faunal diversity. We examined whether similar inferences about relationships between plants and butterflies in the Muddy River drainage (Nevada, U.S.A.) could have been obtained by sampling less intensively (fewer visits per site over the same period of time) or less extensively (equal frequency of visits but over a more limited period of time). We also tested whether rank order of butterfly species with respect to occurrence rate (proportion of sites occupied) would be reflected accurately in temporal subsamples. Temporal subsampling did not lead to erroneous inferences about the relative importance of six vegetation-based predictor variables on the species richness of butterflies. Regardless of the temporal scale of sampling, the species composition of butterflies was more similar in sites with similar species composition of plants. The rank order of occurrence of butterfly species in the temporal subsamples was highly correlated with the rank order of species occurrence in the full data set. Thus, similar inferences about associations between vegetation and butterflies and about relative occurrence rates of individual species of butterflies could be obtained by less intensive or extensive temporal sampling. If compromises between temporal intensity and extent of sampling must be made, our results suggest that maximizing temporal extent will better capture variation in biotic interactions and species occurrence.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)1525-1532
    Number of pages8
    JournalConservation Biology
    Volume18
    Issue number6
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2004

    Fingerprint

    butterfly
    butterflies
    sampling
    Tamarix
    species occurrence
    species diversity
    vegetation
    Tamarix ramosissima
    salt
    Mojave Desert
    monitoring
    adaptive management
    vegetation structure
    detection
    native species
    drainage
    indigenous species
    flora
    desert
    species richness

    Cite this

    @article{87fcc169b3e543c8a96800d2a5ba5673,
    title = "Influence of temporal scale of sampling on detection of relationships between invasive plants and the diversity patterns of plants and butterflies",
    abstract = "Monitoring is a major component of restoration efforts and adaptive management. But monitoring is often neglected because it can be expensive and time-consuming. Accordingly, it is valuable to determine whether the temporal extent of sampling alters the validity of inferences about the response of diversity measures to environmental variables affected by restoration actions. Non-native species alter ecosystems in undesirable ways, frequently homogenizing flora and fauna and extirpating local populations of native species. In the Mojave Desert, invasion of salt-cedar (Tamarix ramosissima Ledeb.) and human efforts to eradicate salt-cedar have altered vegetation structure, vegetation composition, and some measures of faunal diversity. We examined whether similar inferences about relationships between plants and butterflies in the Muddy River drainage (Nevada, U.S.A.) could have been obtained by sampling less intensively (fewer visits per site over the same period of time) or less extensively (equal frequency of visits but over a more limited period of time). We also tested whether rank order of butterfly species with respect to occurrence rate (proportion of sites occupied) would be reflected accurately in temporal subsamples. Temporal subsampling did not lead to erroneous inferences about the relative importance of six vegetation-based predictor variables on the species richness of butterflies. Regardless of the temporal scale of sampling, the species composition of butterflies was more similar in sites with similar species composition of plants. The rank order of occurrence of butterfly species in the temporal subsamples was highly correlated with the rank order of species occurrence in the full data set. Thus, similar inferences about associations between vegetation and butterflies and about relative occurrence rates of individual species of butterflies could be obtained by less intensive or extensive temporal sampling. If compromises between temporal intensity and extent of sampling must be made, our results suggest that maximizing temporal extent will better capture variation in biotic interactions and species occurrence.",
    author = "{Mac Nally}, R. and Erica Fleishman and Danielle Murphy",
    note = "Cited By :10 Export Date: 6 June 2017",
    year = "2004",
    doi = "10.1111/j.1523-1739.2004.00399.x",
    language = "English",
    volume = "18",
    pages = "1525--1532",
    journal = "Conservation Biology",
    issn = "0888-8892",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "6",

    }

    Influence of temporal scale of sampling on detection of relationships between invasive plants and the diversity patterns of plants and butterflies. / Mac Nally, R.; Fleishman, Erica; Murphy, Danielle.

    In: Conservation Biology, Vol. 18, No. 6, 2004, p. 1525-1532.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Influence of temporal scale of sampling on detection of relationships between invasive plants and the diversity patterns of plants and butterflies

    AU - Mac Nally, R.

    AU - Fleishman, Erica

    AU - Murphy, Danielle

    N1 - Cited By :10 Export Date: 6 June 2017

    PY - 2004

    Y1 - 2004

    N2 - Monitoring is a major component of restoration efforts and adaptive management. But monitoring is often neglected because it can be expensive and time-consuming. Accordingly, it is valuable to determine whether the temporal extent of sampling alters the validity of inferences about the response of diversity measures to environmental variables affected by restoration actions. Non-native species alter ecosystems in undesirable ways, frequently homogenizing flora and fauna and extirpating local populations of native species. In the Mojave Desert, invasion of salt-cedar (Tamarix ramosissima Ledeb.) and human efforts to eradicate salt-cedar have altered vegetation structure, vegetation composition, and some measures of faunal diversity. We examined whether similar inferences about relationships between plants and butterflies in the Muddy River drainage (Nevada, U.S.A.) could have been obtained by sampling less intensively (fewer visits per site over the same period of time) or less extensively (equal frequency of visits but over a more limited period of time). We also tested whether rank order of butterfly species with respect to occurrence rate (proportion of sites occupied) would be reflected accurately in temporal subsamples. Temporal subsampling did not lead to erroneous inferences about the relative importance of six vegetation-based predictor variables on the species richness of butterflies. Regardless of the temporal scale of sampling, the species composition of butterflies was more similar in sites with similar species composition of plants. The rank order of occurrence of butterfly species in the temporal subsamples was highly correlated with the rank order of species occurrence in the full data set. Thus, similar inferences about associations between vegetation and butterflies and about relative occurrence rates of individual species of butterflies could be obtained by less intensive or extensive temporal sampling. If compromises between temporal intensity and extent of sampling must be made, our results suggest that maximizing temporal extent will better capture variation in biotic interactions and species occurrence.

    AB - Monitoring is a major component of restoration efforts and adaptive management. But monitoring is often neglected because it can be expensive and time-consuming. Accordingly, it is valuable to determine whether the temporal extent of sampling alters the validity of inferences about the response of diversity measures to environmental variables affected by restoration actions. Non-native species alter ecosystems in undesirable ways, frequently homogenizing flora and fauna and extirpating local populations of native species. In the Mojave Desert, invasion of salt-cedar (Tamarix ramosissima Ledeb.) and human efforts to eradicate salt-cedar have altered vegetation structure, vegetation composition, and some measures of faunal diversity. We examined whether similar inferences about relationships between plants and butterflies in the Muddy River drainage (Nevada, U.S.A.) could have been obtained by sampling less intensively (fewer visits per site over the same period of time) or less extensively (equal frequency of visits but over a more limited period of time). We also tested whether rank order of butterfly species with respect to occurrence rate (proportion of sites occupied) would be reflected accurately in temporal subsamples. Temporal subsampling did not lead to erroneous inferences about the relative importance of six vegetation-based predictor variables on the species richness of butterflies. Regardless of the temporal scale of sampling, the species composition of butterflies was more similar in sites with similar species composition of plants. The rank order of occurrence of butterfly species in the temporal subsamples was highly correlated with the rank order of species occurrence in the full data set. Thus, similar inferences about associations between vegetation and butterflies and about relative occurrence rates of individual species of butterflies could be obtained by less intensive or extensive temporal sampling. If compromises between temporal intensity and extent of sampling must be made, our results suggest that maximizing temporal extent will better capture variation in biotic interactions and species occurrence.

    U2 - 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2004.00399.x

    DO - 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2004.00399.x

    M3 - Article

    VL - 18

    SP - 1525

    EP - 1532

    JO - Conservation Biology

    JF - Conservation Biology

    SN - 0888-8892

    IS - 6

    ER -