Is Japan Ready for Enduring Powers? A Comparative Analysis of Enduring Powers Reform

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)
3 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

This article seeks to understand why the uptake of 'third generation' enduring powers in Japan has been disappointing from the perspective of reformers who introduced the powers in 2000. In addition to questions about optimum design of this particular legal instrument, it is an opportunity to explore deeper questions about regulation and the role of law and the market in ageing, post-industrial societies such as Japan. First, the article explains the form that enduring powers take in Japan. Second, it presents statistics on the uptake of enduring powers. Third, the article presents possible reasons for this low uptake, including unsuitable social norms, a lack of awareness, excessive regulation, unresponsive doctrine, and entrenched judicial values. Finally, the article concludes that while these reasons all have explanatory value and are not easily disaggregated, comparative analysis presents some promising developments in Japan such as the growth in candidates to take on enduring powers who are regulated and organised through legal professions, civil society, local government, and the court system. At a deeper level, the article concludes that the fate of enduring powers turns not only on regulatory and doctrinal levers but also on the relative strengths within Japan?s continuing legal development of divergent views on the imposition of formal legal norms and market mechanisms upon relationships previously regulated by informal social norms or administrative decree.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)241-266
Number of pages26
JournalAsian Journal of Comparative Law
Volume9
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Japan
reform
Social Norms
post-industrial society
regulation
legal norm
legal profession
third generation
market mechanism
statutary order
doctrine
civil society
candidacy
statistics
Law
lack
market
Values

Cite this

@article{c0cedce74f6344ea8589cd13aaff3162,
title = "Is Japan Ready for Enduring Powers? A Comparative Analysis of Enduring Powers Reform",
abstract = "This article seeks to understand why the uptake of 'third generation' enduring powers in Japan has been disappointing from the perspective of reformers who introduced the powers in 2000. In addition to questions about optimum design of this particular legal instrument, it is an opportunity to explore deeper questions about regulation and the role of law and the market in ageing, post-industrial societies such as Japan. First, the article explains the form that enduring powers take in Japan. Second, it presents statistics on the uptake of enduring powers. Third, the article presents possible reasons for this low uptake, including unsuitable social norms, a lack of awareness, excessive regulation, unresponsive doctrine, and entrenched judicial values. Finally, the article concludes that while these reasons all have explanatory value and are not easily disaggregated, comparative analysis presents some promising developments in Japan such as the growth in candidates to take on enduring powers who are regulated and organised through legal professions, civil society, local government, and the court system. At a deeper level, the article concludes that the fate of enduring powers turns not only on regulatory and doctrinal levers but also on the relative strengths within Japan?s continuing legal development of divergent views on the imposition of formal legal norms and market mechanisms upon relationships previously regulated by informal social norms or administrative decree.",
keywords = "Enduring powers, durable powers, lasting powers, ageing, dementia",
author = "RYAN, {Trevor O}",
year = "2014",
doi = "10.1515/asjcl-2013-0048",
language = "English",
volume = "9",
pages = "241--266",
journal = "Asian Journal of Comparative Law",
issn = "1932-0205",
publisher = "Walter de Gruyter GmbH",
number = "1",

}

Is Japan Ready for Enduring Powers? A Comparative Analysis of Enduring Powers Reform. / RYAN, Trevor O.

In: Asian Journal of Comparative Law, Vol. 9, No. 1, 2014, p. 241-266.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Is Japan Ready for Enduring Powers? A Comparative Analysis of Enduring Powers Reform

AU - RYAN, Trevor O

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - This article seeks to understand why the uptake of 'third generation' enduring powers in Japan has been disappointing from the perspective of reformers who introduced the powers in 2000. In addition to questions about optimum design of this particular legal instrument, it is an opportunity to explore deeper questions about regulation and the role of law and the market in ageing, post-industrial societies such as Japan. First, the article explains the form that enduring powers take in Japan. Second, it presents statistics on the uptake of enduring powers. Third, the article presents possible reasons for this low uptake, including unsuitable social norms, a lack of awareness, excessive regulation, unresponsive doctrine, and entrenched judicial values. Finally, the article concludes that while these reasons all have explanatory value and are not easily disaggregated, comparative analysis presents some promising developments in Japan such as the growth in candidates to take on enduring powers who are regulated and organised through legal professions, civil society, local government, and the court system. At a deeper level, the article concludes that the fate of enduring powers turns not only on regulatory and doctrinal levers but also on the relative strengths within Japan?s continuing legal development of divergent views on the imposition of formal legal norms and market mechanisms upon relationships previously regulated by informal social norms or administrative decree.

AB - This article seeks to understand why the uptake of 'third generation' enduring powers in Japan has been disappointing from the perspective of reformers who introduced the powers in 2000. In addition to questions about optimum design of this particular legal instrument, it is an opportunity to explore deeper questions about regulation and the role of law and the market in ageing, post-industrial societies such as Japan. First, the article explains the form that enduring powers take in Japan. Second, it presents statistics on the uptake of enduring powers. Third, the article presents possible reasons for this low uptake, including unsuitable social norms, a lack of awareness, excessive regulation, unresponsive doctrine, and entrenched judicial values. Finally, the article concludes that while these reasons all have explanatory value and are not easily disaggregated, comparative analysis presents some promising developments in Japan such as the growth in candidates to take on enduring powers who are regulated and organised through legal professions, civil society, local government, and the court system. At a deeper level, the article concludes that the fate of enduring powers turns not only on regulatory and doctrinal levers but also on the relative strengths within Japan?s continuing legal development of divergent views on the imposition of formal legal norms and market mechanisms upon relationships previously regulated by informal social norms or administrative decree.

KW - Enduring powers

KW - durable powers

KW - lasting powers

KW - ageing

KW - dementia

U2 - 10.1515/asjcl-2013-0048

DO - 10.1515/asjcl-2013-0048

M3 - Article

VL - 9

SP - 241

EP - 266

JO - Asian Journal of Comparative Law

JF - Asian Journal of Comparative Law

SN - 1932-0205

IS - 1

ER -