Iterative Design of Impact-Damping Gloves for Safer Boxing

Paul Perkins, Alex Jamieson, Geordie Ferguson, Wayne Spratford, Allan Hahn

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Design methods were employed over a 5-year period to develop boxing gloves capable of substantially buffering impact forces delivered to an opponent, thereby permitting safer boxing. Multiple concepts were explored, with sophistication of prototypes gradually increasing. The protypes underwent both quantitative laboratory testing and qualitative evaluation in the field. The laboratory testing methods were evolved over time to enhance test reliability and ecological validity. Feedback from the laboratory and field trials was highly instrumental in guiding the process of glove development. It was eventually found that, compared to standard boxing gloves, pneumatic gloves with sealed bladders were effective in reducing peak impact forces and peak rates of force development when impact magnitudes were low to moderate but not when they were high. By contrast, pneumatic gloves incorporating a bladder enabling air exchange with the external environment were protective across the entire range of impact magnitudes likely to be encountered in boxing. These gloves are configured differently from standard gloves in terms of the positioning of the fist relative to the glove padding, but now have close visual resemblance to standard gloves. The aesthetics of the gloves have proven critical to their acceptance. Wearer comfort is also vital and, although we extensively pursued the concept of thumbless gloves, we finally deemed it necessary to include separate thumb compartments to accommodate user advice. There is scope for further glove refinement, but recent experience indicates that the latest version is currently sufficient for use in modified boxing programs that emphasise safety, with such targeted contextual sufficiency realising a fundamental aim commonly associated with projects employing the design approach. Small batches of the gloves have recently been manufactured to cater for modified boxing programs.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)49-97
Number of pages49
JournalOpen Journal of Safety Science and Technology
Volume8
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2018

Fingerprint

Boxing
Air Sacs
Thumb
Esthetics
Reproducibility of Results
Urinary Bladder
Safety

Cite this

Perkins, Paul ; Jamieson, Alex ; Ferguson, Geordie ; Spratford, Wayne ; Hahn, Allan. / Iterative Design of Impact-Damping Gloves for Safer Boxing. In: Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology. 2018 ; Vol. 8, No. 3. pp. 49-97.
@article{758dbac8639649b7ad2ae023a8bb1f39,
title = "Iterative Design of Impact-Damping Gloves for Safer Boxing",
abstract = "Design methods were employed over a 5-year period to develop boxing gloves capable of substantially buffering impact forces delivered to an opponent, thereby permitting safer boxing. Multiple concepts were explored, with sophistication of prototypes gradually increasing. The protypes underwent both quantitative laboratory testing and qualitative evaluation in the field. The laboratory testing methods were evolved over time to enhance test reliability and ecological validity. Feedback from the laboratory and field trials was highly instrumental in guiding the process of glove development. It was eventually found that, compared to standard boxing gloves, pneumatic gloves with sealed bladders were effective in reducing peak impact forces and peak rates of force development when impact magnitudes were low to moderate but not when they were high. By contrast, pneumatic gloves incorporating a bladder enabling air exchange with the external environment were protective across the entire range of impact magnitudes likely to be encountered in boxing. These gloves are configured differently from standard gloves in terms of the positioning of the fist relative to the glove padding, but now have close visual resemblance to standard gloves. The aesthetics of the gloves have proven critical to their acceptance. Wearer comfort is also vital and, although we extensively pursued the concept of thumbless gloves, we finally deemed it necessary to include separate thumb compartments to accommodate user advice. There is scope for further glove refinement, but recent experience indicates that the latest version is currently sufficient for use in modified boxing programs that emphasise safety, with such targeted contextual sufficiency realising a fundamental aim commonly associated with projects employing the design approach. Small batches of the gloves have recently been manufactured to cater for modified boxing programs.",
keywords = "Boxing Safety, Modified Boxing, Pneumatic Boxing Gloves, Protective Equipment for Boxing, Sport Design",
author = "Paul Perkins and Alex Jamieson and Geordie Ferguson and Wayne Spratford and Allan Hahn",
year = "2018",
month = "9",
doi = "10.4236/ojsst.2018.83005",
language = "English",
volume = "8",
pages = "49--97",
journal = "Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology",
issn = "2162-5999",
number = "3",

}

Iterative Design of Impact-Damping Gloves for Safer Boxing. / Perkins, Paul; Jamieson, Alex; Ferguson, Geordie; Spratford, Wayne; Hahn, Allan.

In: Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology, Vol. 8, No. 3, 09.2018, p. 49-97.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Iterative Design of Impact-Damping Gloves for Safer Boxing

AU - Perkins, Paul

AU - Jamieson, Alex

AU - Ferguson, Geordie

AU - Spratford, Wayne

AU - Hahn, Allan

PY - 2018/9

Y1 - 2018/9

N2 - Design methods were employed over a 5-year period to develop boxing gloves capable of substantially buffering impact forces delivered to an opponent, thereby permitting safer boxing. Multiple concepts were explored, with sophistication of prototypes gradually increasing. The protypes underwent both quantitative laboratory testing and qualitative evaluation in the field. The laboratory testing methods were evolved over time to enhance test reliability and ecological validity. Feedback from the laboratory and field trials was highly instrumental in guiding the process of glove development. It was eventually found that, compared to standard boxing gloves, pneumatic gloves with sealed bladders were effective in reducing peak impact forces and peak rates of force development when impact magnitudes were low to moderate but not when they were high. By contrast, pneumatic gloves incorporating a bladder enabling air exchange with the external environment were protective across the entire range of impact magnitudes likely to be encountered in boxing. These gloves are configured differently from standard gloves in terms of the positioning of the fist relative to the glove padding, but now have close visual resemblance to standard gloves. The aesthetics of the gloves have proven critical to their acceptance. Wearer comfort is also vital and, although we extensively pursued the concept of thumbless gloves, we finally deemed it necessary to include separate thumb compartments to accommodate user advice. There is scope for further glove refinement, but recent experience indicates that the latest version is currently sufficient for use in modified boxing programs that emphasise safety, with such targeted contextual sufficiency realising a fundamental aim commonly associated with projects employing the design approach. Small batches of the gloves have recently been manufactured to cater for modified boxing programs.

AB - Design methods were employed over a 5-year period to develop boxing gloves capable of substantially buffering impact forces delivered to an opponent, thereby permitting safer boxing. Multiple concepts were explored, with sophistication of prototypes gradually increasing. The protypes underwent both quantitative laboratory testing and qualitative evaluation in the field. The laboratory testing methods were evolved over time to enhance test reliability and ecological validity. Feedback from the laboratory and field trials was highly instrumental in guiding the process of glove development. It was eventually found that, compared to standard boxing gloves, pneumatic gloves with sealed bladders were effective in reducing peak impact forces and peak rates of force development when impact magnitudes were low to moderate but not when they were high. By contrast, pneumatic gloves incorporating a bladder enabling air exchange with the external environment were protective across the entire range of impact magnitudes likely to be encountered in boxing. These gloves are configured differently from standard gloves in terms of the positioning of the fist relative to the glove padding, but now have close visual resemblance to standard gloves. The aesthetics of the gloves have proven critical to their acceptance. Wearer comfort is also vital and, although we extensively pursued the concept of thumbless gloves, we finally deemed it necessary to include separate thumb compartments to accommodate user advice. There is scope for further glove refinement, but recent experience indicates that the latest version is currently sufficient for use in modified boxing programs that emphasise safety, with such targeted contextual sufficiency realising a fundamental aim commonly associated with projects employing the design approach. Small batches of the gloves have recently been manufactured to cater for modified boxing programs.

KW - Boxing Safety

KW - Modified Boxing

KW - Pneumatic Boxing Gloves

KW - Protective Equipment for Boxing

KW - Sport Design

U2 - 10.4236/ojsst.2018.83005

DO - 10.4236/ojsst.2018.83005

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 49

EP - 97

JO - Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology

JF - Open Journal of Safety Science and Technology

SN - 2162-5999

IS - 3

ER -