Local community's preferences for accepting a forestry partnership contract to grow pulpwood in Indonesia

A choice experiment study

Dwiko B. Permadi, Michael Burton, Ram Pandit, Digby Race, Iain Walker

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Forestry partnership schemes have been deployed to integrate industrial plantations' and local communities' interests in forest resource management. However, the unsatisfactory impacts of the scheme lead to both parties reassessing the value of the partnership schemes. This article explores local communities' willingness to remain in or opt-out of the partnership schemes designed to grow pulpwood in Indonesia, and investigates their preferences for accepting the modified contract attributes. The contract attributes include contract length, labor participation, insurance, training, road improvement and income. A choice experiment approach was used to estimate preferences of 287 smallholders, of which half were participating with the timber industry under Company-Community Partnership schemes. The results show that a bundle of the contract attributes that could increase local communities' utility are provision of road improvement, higher expected income, and higher timber production insurance. Greater incentives are required to compensate smallholders' loss of utility due to longer contract length and monitoring planted areas. The preferences vary significantly depending on smallholders' participation status in the scheme but not land tenure status. The continuity of the partnership schemes is challenged by a significant number of respondents always rejecting the contract option. The implication of the findings is that designing a bundle of contract attributes focusing on a promotive social safeguard approach likely keeps the participating smallholders in the schemes
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)73-83
Number of pages11
JournalForest Policy and Economics
Volume91
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2018

Fingerprint

pulpwood
insurance
forestry
Indonesia
roads
options trading
income
land tenure
smallholder
resource management
experiment
forest resources
timber production
community
labor
plantations
industry
monitoring
labor participation
road

Cite this

@article{8c21e9f4924048b69a3e97771faeb4a7,
title = "Local community's preferences for accepting a forestry partnership contract to grow pulpwood in Indonesia: A choice experiment study",
abstract = "Forestry partnership schemes have been deployed to integrate industrial plantations' and local communities' interests in forest resource management. However, the unsatisfactory impacts of the scheme lead to both parties reassessing the value of the partnership schemes. This article explores local communities' willingness to remain in or opt-out of the partnership schemes designed to grow pulpwood in Indonesia, and investigates their preferences for accepting the modified contract attributes. The contract attributes include contract length, labor participation, insurance, training, road improvement and income. A choice experiment approach was used to estimate preferences of 287 smallholders, of which half were participating with the timber industry under Company-Community Partnership schemes. The results show that a bundle of the contract attributes that could increase local communities' utility are provision of road improvement, higher expected income, and higher timber production insurance. Greater incentives are required to compensate smallholders' loss of utility due to longer contract length and monitoring planted areas. The preferences vary significantly depending on smallholders' participation status in the scheme but not land tenure status. The continuity of the partnership schemes is challenged by a significant number of respondents always rejecting the contract option. The implication of the findings is that designing a bundle of contract attributes focusing on a promotive social safeguard approach likely keeps the participating smallholders in the schemes",
keywords = "Choice Experiment, Community forestry, Contract attributes, Industrial plantations, Social safeguards, Socio-economic factors",
author = "Permadi, {Dwiko B.} and Michael Burton and Ram Pandit and Digby Race and Iain Walker",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1016/j.forpol.2017.11.008",
language = "English",
volume = "91",
pages = "73--83",
journal = "Forest Policy and Economics",
issn = "1389-9341",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Local community's preferences for accepting a forestry partnership contract to grow pulpwood in Indonesia : A choice experiment study. / Permadi, Dwiko B.; Burton, Michael; Pandit, Ram; Race, Digby; Walker, Iain.

In: Forest Policy and Economics, Vol. 91, 06.2018, p. 73-83.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Local community's preferences for accepting a forestry partnership contract to grow pulpwood in Indonesia

T2 - A choice experiment study

AU - Permadi, Dwiko B.

AU - Burton, Michael

AU - Pandit, Ram

AU - Race, Digby

AU - Walker, Iain

PY - 2018/6

Y1 - 2018/6

N2 - Forestry partnership schemes have been deployed to integrate industrial plantations' and local communities' interests in forest resource management. However, the unsatisfactory impacts of the scheme lead to both parties reassessing the value of the partnership schemes. This article explores local communities' willingness to remain in or opt-out of the partnership schemes designed to grow pulpwood in Indonesia, and investigates their preferences for accepting the modified contract attributes. The contract attributes include contract length, labor participation, insurance, training, road improvement and income. A choice experiment approach was used to estimate preferences of 287 smallholders, of which half were participating with the timber industry under Company-Community Partnership schemes. The results show that a bundle of the contract attributes that could increase local communities' utility are provision of road improvement, higher expected income, and higher timber production insurance. Greater incentives are required to compensate smallholders' loss of utility due to longer contract length and monitoring planted areas. The preferences vary significantly depending on smallholders' participation status in the scheme but not land tenure status. The continuity of the partnership schemes is challenged by a significant number of respondents always rejecting the contract option. The implication of the findings is that designing a bundle of contract attributes focusing on a promotive social safeguard approach likely keeps the participating smallholders in the schemes

AB - Forestry partnership schemes have been deployed to integrate industrial plantations' and local communities' interests in forest resource management. However, the unsatisfactory impacts of the scheme lead to both parties reassessing the value of the partnership schemes. This article explores local communities' willingness to remain in or opt-out of the partnership schemes designed to grow pulpwood in Indonesia, and investigates their preferences for accepting the modified contract attributes. The contract attributes include contract length, labor participation, insurance, training, road improvement and income. A choice experiment approach was used to estimate preferences of 287 smallholders, of which half were participating with the timber industry under Company-Community Partnership schemes. The results show that a bundle of the contract attributes that could increase local communities' utility are provision of road improvement, higher expected income, and higher timber production insurance. Greater incentives are required to compensate smallholders' loss of utility due to longer contract length and monitoring planted areas. The preferences vary significantly depending on smallholders' participation status in the scheme but not land tenure status. The continuity of the partnership schemes is challenged by a significant number of respondents always rejecting the contract option. The implication of the findings is that designing a bundle of contract attributes focusing on a promotive social safeguard approach likely keeps the participating smallholders in the schemes

KW - Choice Experiment

KW - Community forestry

KW - Contract attributes

KW - Industrial plantations

KW - Social safeguards

KW - Socio-economic factors

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85037029709&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.forpol.2017.11.008

DO - 10.1016/j.forpol.2017.11.008

M3 - Article

VL - 91

SP - 73

EP - 83

JO - Forest Policy and Economics

JF - Forest Policy and Economics

SN - 1389-9341

ER -