Making the hidden seen

A narrative analysis of the experiences of Assumption of Care at birth

Christine A. Marsh, Jenny Browne, Jan Taylor, Deborah Davis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: Being involved in any child protection system is complex and multifaceted and none more so than in non-voluntary Assumption of Care which occurs in New South Wales when, for child protection concerns, the Department of Family and Community Services removes a newborn baby from her/his mother. Objective: This research studied childbearing women's and professionals’ experiences of Assumption of Care at birth to increase understanding of individual participants’ stories, how they made sense of meanings and how these experiences framed their lives. Method: A narrative inquiry framework guided interviews with four groups: childbearing women, midwives, social workers and Family and Community Services case managers. Holistic form was used for reading, interpreting and analysing the narratives. Findings: This research found unwanted emotional (isolation, shame, guilt, loss, disenfranchised grief) and physical consequences (depression, substance abuse complications) for women experiencing an Assumption of Care at the time of birth. There were also conflicting ethical and moral positions for the professionals involved. The use/abuse of power, concealment of facts and disenfranchised grief were identified as intertwined plots that caused or increased tensions. Discussion: Both the women and the professionals felt pressure from trying to achieve competing and overlapping roles. The unwanted effects of Assumption of Care are exacerbated by the current child protection and maternity care systems. Conclusion: To address the tensions raised in this study, we suggest a two-fold change to maternity care for women at risk of an Assumption of Care: a therapeutic justice model of maternity care and continuity of midwifery care with a dedicated midwife. Introducing these changes could increase women's and children's safety and wellbeing.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-11
Number of pages11
JournalWomen and Birth
Volume32
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2019

Fingerprint

Parturition
Midwifery
Grief
Social Welfare
Shame
New South Wales
Continuity of Patient Care
Guilt
Social Justice
Research
Substance-Related Disorders
Reading
Mothers
Newborn Infant
Interviews
Depression
Safety
Pressure
Therapeutics

Cite this

Marsh, Christine A. ; Browne, Jenny ; Taylor, Jan ; Davis, Deborah. / Making the hidden seen : A narrative analysis of the experiences of Assumption of Care at birth. In: Women and Birth. 2019 ; Vol. 32, No. 1. pp. 1-11.
@article{38fb652c568b48f19f150503f4ce8680,
title = "Making the hidden seen: A narrative analysis of the experiences of Assumption of Care at birth",
abstract = "Background: Being involved in any child protection system is complex and multifaceted and none more so than in non-voluntary Assumption of Care which occurs in New South Wales when, for child protection concerns, the Department of Family and Community Services removes a newborn baby from her/his mother. Objective: This research studied childbearing women's and professionals’ experiences of Assumption of Care at birth to increase understanding of individual participants’ stories, how they made sense of meanings and how these experiences framed their lives. Method: A narrative inquiry framework guided interviews with four groups: childbearing women, midwives, social workers and Family and Community Services case managers. Holistic form was used for reading, interpreting and analysing the narratives. Findings: This research found unwanted emotional (isolation, shame, guilt, loss, disenfranchised grief) and physical consequences (depression, substance abuse complications) for women experiencing an Assumption of Care at the time of birth. There were also conflicting ethical and moral positions for the professionals involved. The use/abuse of power, concealment of facts and disenfranchised grief were identified as intertwined plots that caused or increased tensions. Discussion: Both the women and the professionals felt pressure from trying to achieve competing and overlapping roles. The unwanted effects of Assumption of Care are exacerbated by the current child protection and maternity care systems. Conclusion: To address the tensions raised in this study, we suggest a two-fold change to maternity care for women at risk of an Assumption of Care: a therapeutic justice model of maternity care and continuity of midwifery care with a dedicated midwife. Introducing these changes could increase women's and children's safety and wellbeing.",
keywords = "Birth, Child protection, Child welfare, Newborn, Vulnerable populations",
author = "Marsh, {Christine A.} and Jenny Browne and Jan Taylor and Deborah Davis",
year = "2019",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1016/j.wombi.2018.04.009",
language = "English",
volume = "32",
pages = "1--11",
journal = "Australian journal of midwifery : professional journal of the Australian College of Midwives Incorporated",
issn = "1871-5192",
publisher = "Elsevier",
number = "1",

}

Making the hidden seen : A narrative analysis of the experiences of Assumption of Care at birth. / Marsh, Christine A.; Browne, Jenny; Taylor, Jan; Davis, Deborah.

In: Women and Birth, Vol. 32, No. 1, 02.2019, p. 1-11.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Making the hidden seen

T2 - A narrative analysis of the experiences of Assumption of Care at birth

AU - Marsh, Christine A.

AU - Browne, Jenny

AU - Taylor, Jan

AU - Davis, Deborah

PY - 2019/2

Y1 - 2019/2

N2 - Background: Being involved in any child protection system is complex and multifaceted and none more so than in non-voluntary Assumption of Care which occurs in New South Wales when, for child protection concerns, the Department of Family and Community Services removes a newborn baby from her/his mother. Objective: This research studied childbearing women's and professionals’ experiences of Assumption of Care at birth to increase understanding of individual participants’ stories, how they made sense of meanings and how these experiences framed their lives. Method: A narrative inquiry framework guided interviews with four groups: childbearing women, midwives, social workers and Family and Community Services case managers. Holistic form was used for reading, interpreting and analysing the narratives. Findings: This research found unwanted emotional (isolation, shame, guilt, loss, disenfranchised grief) and physical consequences (depression, substance abuse complications) for women experiencing an Assumption of Care at the time of birth. There were also conflicting ethical and moral positions for the professionals involved. The use/abuse of power, concealment of facts and disenfranchised grief were identified as intertwined plots that caused or increased tensions. Discussion: Both the women and the professionals felt pressure from trying to achieve competing and overlapping roles. The unwanted effects of Assumption of Care are exacerbated by the current child protection and maternity care systems. Conclusion: To address the tensions raised in this study, we suggest a two-fold change to maternity care for women at risk of an Assumption of Care: a therapeutic justice model of maternity care and continuity of midwifery care with a dedicated midwife. Introducing these changes could increase women's and children's safety and wellbeing.

AB - Background: Being involved in any child protection system is complex and multifaceted and none more so than in non-voluntary Assumption of Care which occurs in New South Wales when, for child protection concerns, the Department of Family and Community Services removes a newborn baby from her/his mother. Objective: This research studied childbearing women's and professionals’ experiences of Assumption of Care at birth to increase understanding of individual participants’ stories, how they made sense of meanings and how these experiences framed their lives. Method: A narrative inquiry framework guided interviews with four groups: childbearing women, midwives, social workers and Family and Community Services case managers. Holistic form was used for reading, interpreting and analysing the narratives. Findings: This research found unwanted emotional (isolation, shame, guilt, loss, disenfranchised grief) and physical consequences (depression, substance abuse complications) for women experiencing an Assumption of Care at the time of birth. There were also conflicting ethical and moral positions for the professionals involved. The use/abuse of power, concealment of facts and disenfranchised grief were identified as intertwined plots that caused or increased tensions. Discussion: Both the women and the professionals felt pressure from trying to achieve competing and overlapping roles. The unwanted effects of Assumption of Care are exacerbated by the current child protection and maternity care systems. Conclusion: To address the tensions raised in this study, we suggest a two-fold change to maternity care for women at risk of an Assumption of Care: a therapeutic justice model of maternity care and continuity of midwifery care with a dedicated midwife. Introducing these changes could increase women's and children's safety and wellbeing.

KW - Birth

KW - Child protection

KW - Child welfare

KW - Newborn

KW - Vulnerable populations

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85046163286&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.wombi.2018.04.009

DO - 10.1016/j.wombi.2018.04.009

M3 - Article

VL - 32

SP - 1

EP - 11

JO - Australian journal of midwifery : professional journal of the Australian College of Midwives Incorporated

JF - Australian journal of midwifery : professional journal of the Australian College of Midwives Incorporated

SN - 1871-5192

IS - 1

ER -