Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience?

Rhonda Daniels, Cameron Gordon, Corinne Mulley, Nick Stevens

    Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookConference contribution

    Abstract

    The New South Wales (NSW) government created the Sydney Metro Authority to design, build and operate a completely separate underground Metro rail system to supplement the existing public transport network in Sydney. By the time the NSW government abruptly cancelled the entire Metro project in early 2010, the Authority had conceived and designed a contract that was proceeding to procurement. This paper examines the nature of the proposed Sydney Metro contract in relation to its performance framework and compares this to the frameworks in current contracts for bus, rail and ferry public transport in NSW. Against this background, the paper examines the extent to which the Sydney Metro approach has had an impact on subsequent public transport contracts in the context of the literature on optimal contracting and optimal incentives. The paper concludes that little has been implemented, although the other mode contracts now enable more performance measurement and incentivisation. In particular, the decision to award contracts to existing (and mostly public sector) operators appears to have acted as a brake on developing these performance elements.
    Original languageEnglish
    Title of host publicationAustralian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings
    Place of PublicationAdelaide
    PublisherUniversity of South Australia
    Pages1-19
    Number of pages19
    Publication statusPublished - 2011
    EventAustralian Transport Forum 2011 - Adelaide, Australia
    Duration: 28 Sep 201130 Sep 2011

    Conference

    ConferenceAustralian Transport Forum 2011
    CountryAustralia
    CityAdelaide
    Period28/09/1130/09/11

    Fingerprint

    public transport
    incentive
    experience
    transport network
    performance measurement
    supplement
    performance
    public sector

    Cite this

    Daniels, R., Gordon, C., Mulley, C., & Stevens, N. (2011). Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience? In Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings (pp. 1-19). Adelaide: University of South Australia.
    Daniels, Rhonda ; Gordon, Cameron ; Mulley, Corinne ; Stevens, Nick. / Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience?. Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings. Adelaide : University of South Australia, 2011. pp. 1-19
    @inproceedings{df91f635a4fb4a1fb3bb7204945f332d,
    title = "Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience?",
    abstract = "The New South Wales (NSW) government created the Sydney Metro Authority to design, build and operate a completely separate underground Metro rail system to supplement the existing public transport network in Sydney. By the time the NSW government abruptly cancelled the entire Metro project in early 2010, the Authority had conceived and designed a contract that was proceeding to procurement. This paper examines the nature of the proposed Sydney Metro contract in relation to its performance framework and compares this to the frameworks in current contracts for bus, rail and ferry public transport in NSW. Against this background, the paper examines the extent to which the Sydney Metro approach has had an impact on subsequent public transport contracts in the context of the literature on optimal contracting and optimal incentives. The paper concludes that little has been implemented, although the other mode contracts now enable more performance measurement and incentivisation. In particular, the decision to award contracts to existing (and mostly public sector) operators appears to have acted as a brake on developing these performance elements.",
    keywords = "Transport",
    author = "Rhonda Daniels and Cameron Gordon and Corinne Mulley and Nick Stevens",
    year = "2011",
    language = "English",
    pages = "1--19",
    booktitle = "Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings",
    publisher = "University of South Australia",
    address = "Australia",

    }

    Daniels, R, Gordon, C, Mulley, C & Stevens, N 2011, Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience? in Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings. University of South Australia, Adelaide, pp. 1-19, Australian Transport Forum 2011, Adelaide, Australia, 28/09/11.

    Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience? / Daniels, Rhonda; Gordon, Cameron; Mulley, Corinne; Stevens, Nick.

    Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings. Adelaide : University of South Australia, 2011. p. 1-19.

    Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookConference contribution

    TY - GEN

    T1 - Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience?

    AU - Daniels, Rhonda

    AU - Gordon, Cameron

    AU - Mulley, Corinne

    AU - Stevens, Nick

    PY - 2011

    Y1 - 2011

    N2 - The New South Wales (NSW) government created the Sydney Metro Authority to design, build and operate a completely separate underground Metro rail system to supplement the existing public transport network in Sydney. By the time the NSW government abruptly cancelled the entire Metro project in early 2010, the Authority had conceived and designed a contract that was proceeding to procurement. This paper examines the nature of the proposed Sydney Metro contract in relation to its performance framework and compares this to the frameworks in current contracts for bus, rail and ferry public transport in NSW. Against this background, the paper examines the extent to which the Sydney Metro approach has had an impact on subsequent public transport contracts in the context of the literature on optimal contracting and optimal incentives. The paper concludes that little has been implemented, although the other mode contracts now enable more performance measurement and incentivisation. In particular, the decision to award contracts to existing (and mostly public sector) operators appears to have acted as a brake on developing these performance elements.

    AB - The New South Wales (NSW) government created the Sydney Metro Authority to design, build and operate a completely separate underground Metro rail system to supplement the existing public transport network in Sydney. By the time the NSW government abruptly cancelled the entire Metro project in early 2010, the Authority had conceived and designed a contract that was proceeding to procurement. This paper examines the nature of the proposed Sydney Metro contract in relation to its performance framework and compares this to the frameworks in current contracts for bus, rail and ferry public transport in NSW. Against this background, the paper examines the extent to which the Sydney Metro approach has had an impact on subsequent public transport contracts in the context of the literature on optimal contracting and optimal incentives. The paper concludes that little has been implemented, although the other mode contracts now enable more performance measurement and incentivisation. In particular, the decision to award contracts to existing (and mostly public sector) operators appears to have acted as a brake on developing these performance elements.

    KW - Transport

    M3 - Conference contribution

    SP - 1

    EP - 19

    BT - Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings

    PB - University of South Australia

    CY - Adelaide

    ER -

    Daniels R, Gordon C, Mulley C, Stevens N. Optimal Contracting and Incentives for Public Transport on Sydney: What has been learned from the Sydney Metro experience? In Australian Transport Research Forum 2011 Proceedings. Adelaide: University of South Australia. 2011. p. 1-19