Order effects of task inventory design

Natalie Collins, Patricia M. Brown

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookConference contribution

Abstract

Precise job information is a vital resource for managers, with the task inventory approach to Job Analysis/Occupational Analysis being a valuable tool in collecting reliable and valid job information. However, research on the order of tasks in the inventory has been limited, with the alphabetised by verb approach frequently advocated as the most valid and easiest for respondents to complete. The current experimental study was designed to determine whether a different set of responses are produced when the same set of tasks are ordered using scripts, compared to when alphabetised by verb. A between groups design was applied in the current study where participants were matched based on their unit function (for example, participants from training establishments were matched), and assigned to either the script based or alphabetised by verb task inventory. Using a sample of 434 other ranks (ORs) in the Explosive Ordnance specialisation, analysis of variance results indicated that junior ORs in the alphabetised group took significantly less time to complete the task inventory compared to both junior ORs in the script group, and senior ORs in the alphabetised group. It was also found that job incumbents in the script group ticked significantly more tasks than those in the alphabetised group, and that senior ORs ticked significantly more tasks than their junior OR colleagues. Results are discussed with regard to cognitive processing theory, and the subsequent implications of the current findings on the design of task inventories within the Australian Defence Force.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association
Place of PublicationCanada
Publication statusPublished - 2002

Fingerprint

Group
job analysis
analysis of variance
specialization
manager
resources
time

Cite this

Collins, N., & Brown, P. M. (2002). Order effects of task inventory design. In Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association Canada.
Collins, Natalie ; Brown, Patricia M. / Order effects of task inventory design. Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association. Canada, 2002.
@inproceedings{72cce3f30d54460a91935f5ac2db944c,
title = "Order effects of task inventory design",
abstract = "Precise job information is a vital resource for managers, with the task inventory approach to Job Analysis/Occupational Analysis being a valuable tool in collecting reliable and valid job information. However, research on the order of tasks in the inventory has been limited, with the alphabetised by verb approach frequently advocated as the most valid and easiest for respondents to complete. The current experimental study was designed to determine whether a different set of responses are produced when the same set of tasks are ordered using scripts, compared to when alphabetised by verb. A between groups design was applied in the current study where participants were matched based on their unit function (for example, participants from training establishments were matched), and assigned to either the script based or alphabetised by verb task inventory. Using a sample of 434 other ranks (ORs) in the Explosive Ordnance specialisation, analysis of variance results indicated that junior ORs in the alphabetised group took significantly less time to complete the task inventory compared to both junior ORs in the script group, and senior ORs in the alphabetised group. It was also found that job incumbents in the script group ticked significantly more tasks than those in the alphabetised group, and that senior ORs ticked significantly more tasks than their junior OR colleagues. Results are discussed with regard to cognitive processing theory, and the subsequent implications of the current findings on the design of task inventories within the Australian Defence Force.",
author = "Natalie Collins and Brown, {Patricia M.}",
year = "2002",
language = "English",
booktitle = "Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association",

}

Collins, N & Brown, PM 2002, Order effects of task inventory design. in Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association. Canada.

Order effects of task inventory design. / Collins, Natalie; Brown, Patricia M.

Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association. Canada, 2002.

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookConference contribution

TY - GEN

T1 - Order effects of task inventory design

AU - Collins, Natalie

AU - Brown, Patricia M.

PY - 2002

Y1 - 2002

N2 - Precise job information is a vital resource for managers, with the task inventory approach to Job Analysis/Occupational Analysis being a valuable tool in collecting reliable and valid job information. However, research on the order of tasks in the inventory has been limited, with the alphabetised by verb approach frequently advocated as the most valid and easiest for respondents to complete. The current experimental study was designed to determine whether a different set of responses are produced when the same set of tasks are ordered using scripts, compared to when alphabetised by verb. A between groups design was applied in the current study where participants were matched based on their unit function (for example, participants from training establishments were matched), and assigned to either the script based or alphabetised by verb task inventory. Using a sample of 434 other ranks (ORs) in the Explosive Ordnance specialisation, analysis of variance results indicated that junior ORs in the alphabetised group took significantly less time to complete the task inventory compared to both junior ORs in the script group, and senior ORs in the alphabetised group. It was also found that job incumbents in the script group ticked significantly more tasks than those in the alphabetised group, and that senior ORs ticked significantly more tasks than their junior OR colleagues. Results are discussed with regard to cognitive processing theory, and the subsequent implications of the current findings on the design of task inventories within the Australian Defence Force.

AB - Precise job information is a vital resource for managers, with the task inventory approach to Job Analysis/Occupational Analysis being a valuable tool in collecting reliable and valid job information. However, research on the order of tasks in the inventory has been limited, with the alphabetised by verb approach frequently advocated as the most valid and easiest for respondents to complete. The current experimental study was designed to determine whether a different set of responses are produced when the same set of tasks are ordered using scripts, compared to when alphabetised by verb. A between groups design was applied in the current study where participants were matched based on their unit function (for example, participants from training establishments were matched), and assigned to either the script based or alphabetised by verb task inventory. Using a sample of 434 other ranks (ORs) in the Explosive Ordnance specialisation, analysis of variance results indicated that junior ORs in the alphabetised group took significantly less time to complete the task inventory compared to both junior ORs in the script group, and senior ORs in the alphabetised group. It was also found that job incumbents in the script group ticked significantly more tasks than those in the alphabetised group, and that senior ORs ticked significantly more tasks than their junior OR colleagues. Results are discussed with regard to cognitive processing theory, and the subsequent implications of the current findings on the design of task inventories within the Australian Defence Force.

M3 - Conference contribution

BT - Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association

CY - Canada

ER -

Collins N, Brown PM. Order effects of task inventory design. In Proceedings: 44th Annual Conference of the International Military Testing Association. Canada. 2002