'Our girth is plain to see': An analysis of newspaper coverage of Australia's Future 'Fat Bomb'

Kate Holland, Warwick Blood, Samantha Thomas, Sophie Lewis, Paul Komesaroff, David Castle

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

34 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The news media plays an important role in making visible and shaping public understandings of health and health risks. In relation to overweight and obesity, it has been suggested that the media is more likely to engage in alarmist reporting in a climate in which it is taken for granted that obesity is an ‘epidemic’. This study analyses Australian media coverage of a report on overweight and obesity, Australia's Future ‘Fat Bomb’: a report on the long-term consequences of Australia's expanding waistline on cardiovascular disease, by one of Australia’s leading health and medical research institutes. Our study found that the report was consistently framed across media outlets as showing that Australia is the ‘fattest nation’ in the world, having overtaken the Americans. This is despite the fact that the Fat Bomb study did not include international comparisons and was based only on data from middle-aged Australians. Because reports of increasing rates of obesity had already been widely covered in the media, the press needed to find a new way of signifying the problem, which was provided by comments made by its lead author in publicising the report. Consistent with previous research, there was a notable absence of critical commentary on the study and a failure to test the claims of its lead author. We conclude that this reporting could have contributed to a policy environment in which the perceived threat of obesity is deemed to be so great that efforts to contain it may be subjected to less scrutiny than they warrant.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)31-46
Number of pages16
JournalHealth, Risk and Society
Volume13
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Fingerprint

Bombs
Newspapers
Obesity
Fats
Health
Climate
Biomedical Research
Cardiovascular Diseases
Public Health
Research

Cite this

Holland, Kate ; Blood, Warwick ; Thomas, Samantha ; Lewis, Sophie ; Komesaroff, Paul ; Castle, David. / 'Our girth is plain to see': An analysis of newspaper coverage of Australia's Future 'Fat Bomb'. In: Health, Risk and Society. 2011 ; Vol. 13, No. 1. pp. 31-46.
@article{029b921d989c490b85df5ba68064d58d,
title = "'Our girth is plain to see': An analysis of newspaper coverage of Australia's Future 'Fat Bomb'",
abstract = "The news media plays an important role in making visible and shaping public understandings of health and health risks. In relation to overweight and obesity, it has been suggested that the media is more likely to engage in alarmist reporting in a climate in which it is taken for granted that obesity is an ‘epidemic’. This study analyses Australian media coverage of a report on overweight and obesity, Australia's Future ‘Fat Bomb’: a report on the long-term consequences of Australia's expanding waistline on cardiovascular disease, by one of Australia’s leading health and medical research institutes. Our study found that the report was consistently framed across media outlets as showing that Australia is the ‘fattest nation’ in the world, having overtaken the Americans. This is despite the fact that the Fat Bomb study did not include international comparisons and was based only on data from middle-aged Australians. Because reports of increasing rates of obesity had already been widely covered in the media, the press needed to find a new way of signifying the problem, which was provided by comments made by its lead author in publicising the report. Consistent with previous research, there was a notable absence of critical commentary on the study and a failure to test the claims of its lead author. We conclude that this reporting could have contributed to a policy environment in which the perceived threat of obesity is deemed to be so great that efforts to contain it may be subjected to less scrutiny than they warrant.",
keywords = "risk communication, media representation, obesity research",
author = "Kate Holland and Warwick Blood and Samantha Thomas and Sophie Lewis and Paul Komesaroff and David Castle",
year = "2011",
doi = "10.1080/13698575.2010.540648",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "31--46",
journal = "Health, Risk and Society",
issn = "1369-8575",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "1",

}

'Our girth is plain to see': An analysis of newspaper coverage of Australia's Future 'Fat Bomb'. / Holland, Kate; Blood, Warwick; Thomas, Samantha; Lewis, Sophie; Komesaroff, Paul; Castle, David.

In: Health, Risk and Society, Vol. 13, No. 1, 2011, p. 31-46.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'Our girth is plain to see': An analysis of newspaper coverage of Australia's Future 'Fat Bomb'

AU - Holland, Kate

AU - Blood, Warwick

AU - Thomas, Samantha

AU - Lewis, Sophie

AU - Komesaroff, Paul

AU - Castle, David

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - The news media plays an important role in making visible and shaping public understandings of health and health risks. In relation to overweight and obesity, it has been suggested that the media is more likely to engage in alarmist reporting in a climate in which it is taken for granted that obesity is an ‘epidemic’. This study analyses Australian media coverage of a report on overweight and obesity, Australia's Future ‘Fat Bomb’: a report on the long-term consequences of Australia's expanding waistline on cardiovascular disease, by one of Australia’s leading health and medical research institutes. Our study found that the report was consistently framed across media outlets as showing that Australia is the ‘fattest nation’ in the world, having overtaken the Americans. This is despite the fact that the Fat Bomb study did not include international comparisons and was based only on data from middle-aged Australians. Because reports of increasing rates of obesity had already been widely covered in the media, the press needed to find a new way of signifying the problem, which was provided by comments made by its lead author in publicising the report. Consistent with previous research, there was a notable absence of critical commentary on the study and a failure to test the claims of its lead author. We conclude that this reporting could have contributed to a policy environment in which the perceived threat of obesity is deemed to be so great that efforts to contain it may be subjected to less scrutiny than they warrant.

AB - The news media plays an important role in making visible and shaping public understandings of health and health risks. In relation to overweight and obesity, it has been suggested that the media is more likely to engage in alarmist reporting in a climate in which it is taken for granted that obesity is an ‘epidemic’. This study analyses Australian media coverage of a report on overweight and obesity, Australia's Future ‘Fat Bomb’: a report on the long-term consequences of Australia's expanding waistline on cardiovascular disease, by one of Australia’s leading health and medical research institutes. Our study found that the report was consistently framed across media outlets as showing that Australia is the ‘fattest nation’ in the world, having overtaken the Americans. This is despite the fact that the Fat Bomb study did not include international comparisons and was based only on data from middle-aged Australians. Because reports of increasing rates of obesity had already been widely covered in the media, the press needed to find a new way of signifying the problem, which was provided by comments made by its lead author in publicising the report. Consistent with previous research, there was a notable absence of critical commentary on the study and a failure to test the claims of its lead author. We conclude that this reporting could have contributed to a policy environment in which the perceived threat of obesity is deemed to be so great that efforts to contain it may be subjected to less scrutiny than they warrant.

KW - risk communication

KW - media representation

KW - obesity research

U2 - 10.1080/13698575.2010.540648

DO - 10.1080/13698575.2010.540648

M3 - Article

VL - 13

SP - 31

EP - 46

JO - Health, Risk and Society

JF - Health, Risk and Society

SN - 1369-8575

IS - 1

ER -