Pilates: Effective for developing core stability, but limited sessions have limited global benefits

Kate PUMPA, Karen Dzialdowski, Mark Stiffle, Lanette Gavran

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Introduction: The National Physical Activity Guidelines for Australians recommend a minimum of 30 minutes of physical activity most days of the week to maintain good health. The American College of Sports Medicine suggests Pilates may be an effective mode of physical activity, however there is limited evidence to support the efficacy of Pilates for a range of its commercially claimed benefits. Methods: In this observational cohort study, healthy adults (4 males and 14 females), who had not participated in Pilates exercise prior to the study, completed 12 weeks of studio and/or mat based Pilates classes once per week and were compared to age matched controls. Before and after the 12 week intervention, participants completed a dual energy X-Ray absorptometry scan to assess body composition and bone mineral density; completed the 5 stage Sahrmann Core Stability assessment; were assessed for joint mobility at the shoulder, cervical and lumbar spine, hip and ankle using a goniometer; had their lower limb strength assessed through heel raises and isokinetic dynamometry; and their energy expenditure and energy intake monitored utilising the SenseWear™ Armband Mini and a five day food record. Results: There were no significant differences identified between the groups (Pilates and control) at baseline in relation to demographics (age, weight, height) and all aforementioned physiological characteristics, with the exception of cervical neck flexion. After the 12 week intervention, positive changes in core stability as identified through the Sahrmann core stability test among Pilates participants was evident though not statistically significant. Pilates group mean change 0.78 ±1.30AU, control group mean change -0.33 ± 1.11AU (p = 0.070). No other meaningful differences were identified. Conclusions: Though 12 weeks of Pilates completed once per week may be effective for enhancing core stability, it did not appear to elicit positive outcomes for range of motion, body composition and foot strength.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)34-42
    Number of pages9
    JournalJournal of Fitness Research
    Volume4
    Issue number2
    Publication statusPublished - 2015

    Fingerprint

    Exercise
    Control Groups
    Heel
    Articular Range of Motion
    Body Composition
    Ankle
    Bone Density
    Energy Metabolism
    Observational Studies
    Hip
    Spine
    Cohort Studies
    Neck
    X-Rays
    Demography
    Guidelines
    Weights and Measures
    Food
    Health

    Cite this

    PUMPA, Kate ; Dzialdowski, Karen ; Stiffle, Mark ; Gavran, Lanette. / Pilates: Effective for developing core stability, but limited sessions have limited global benefits. In: Journal of Fitness Research. 2015 ; Vol. 4, No. 2. pp. 34-42.
    @article{ef2466285f604676a53a8dabb8aab88b,
    title = "Pilates: Effective for developing core stability, but limited sessions have limited global benefits",
    abstract = "Introduction: The National Physical Activity Guidelines for Australians recommend a minimum of 30 minutes of physical activity most days of the week to maintain good health. The American College of Sports Medicine suggests Pilates may be an effective mode of physical activity, however there is limited evidence to support the efficacy of Pilates for a range of its commercially claimed benefits. Methods: In this observational cohort study, healthy adults (4 males and 14 females), who had not participated in Pilates exercise prior to the study, completed 12 weeks of studio and/or mat based Pilates classes once per week and were compared to age matched controls. Before and after the 12 week intervention, participants completed a dual energy X-Ray absorptometry scan to assess body composition and bone mineral density; completed the 5 stage Sahrmann Core Stability assessment; were assessed for joint mobility at the shoulder, cervical and lumbar spine, hip and ankle using a goniometer; had their lower limb strength assessed through heel raises and isokinetic dynamometry; and their energy expenditure and energy intake monitored utilising the SenseWear™ Armband Mini and a five day food record. Results: There were no significant differences identified between the groups (Pilates and control) at baseline in relation to demographics (age, weight, height) and all aforementioned physiological characteristics, with the exception of cervical neck flexion. After the 12 week intervention, positive changes in core stability as identified through the Sahrmann core stability test among Pilates participants was evident though not statistically significant. Pilates group mean change 0.78 ±1.30AU, control group mean change -0.33 ± 1.11AU (p = 0.070). No other meaningful differences were identified. Conclusions: Though 12 weeks of Pilates completed once per week may be effective for enhancing core stability, it did not appear to elicit positive outcomes for range of motion, body composition and foot strength.",
    keywords = "pilates training, body composition, range of motion, exercise, muscle strength",
    author = "Kate PUMPA and Karen Dzialdowski and Mark Stiffle and Lanette Gavran",
    year = "2015",
    language = "English",
    volume = "4",
    pages = "34--42",
    journal = "Journal of Fitness Research",
    issn = "2201-5655",
    number = "2",

    }

    Pilates: Effective for developing core stability, but limited sessions have limited global benefits. / PUMPA, Kate; Dzialdowski, Karen; Stiffle, Mark; Gavran, Lanette.

    In: Journal of Fitness Research, Vol. 4, No. 2, 2015, p. 34-42.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Pilates: Effective for developing core stability, but limited sessions have limited global benefits

    AU - PUMPA, Kate

    AU - Dzialdowski, Karen

    AU - Stiffle, Mark

    AU - Gavran, Lanette

    PY - 2015

    Y1 - 2015

    N2 - Introduction: The National Physical Activity Guidelines for Australians recommend a minimum of 30 minutes of physical activity most days of the week to maintain good health. The American College of Sports Medicine suggests Pilates may be an effective mode of physical activity, however there is limited evidence to support the efficacy of Pilates for a range of its commercially claimed benefits. Methods: In this observational cohort study, healthy adults (4 males and 14 females), who had not participated in Pilates exercise prior to the study, completed 12 weeks of studio and/or mat based Pilates classes once per week and were compared to age matched controls. Before and after the 12 week intervention, participants completed a dual energy X-Ray absorptometry scan to assess body composition and bone mineral density; completed the 5 stage Sahrmann Core Stability assessment; were assessed for joint mobility at the shoulder, cervical and lumbar spine, hip and ankle using a goniometer; had their lower limb strength assessed through heel raises and isokinetic dynamometry; and their energy expenditure and energy intake monitored utilising the SenseWear™ Armband Mini and a five day food record. Results: There were no significant differences identified between the groups (Pilates and control) at baseline in relation to demographics (age, weight, height) and all aforementioned physiological characteristics, with the exception of cervical neck flexion. After the 12 week intervention, positive changes in core stability as identified through the Sahrmann core stability test among Pilates participants was evident though not statistically significant. Pilates group mean change 0.78 ±1.30AU, control group mean change -0.33 ± 1.11AU (p = 0.070). No other meaningful differences were identified. Conclusions: Though 12 weeks of Pilates completed once per week may be effective for enhancing core stability, it did not appear to elicit positive outcomes for range of motion, body composition and foot strength.

    AB - Introduction: The National Physical Activity Guidelines for Australians recommend a minimum of 30 minutes of physical activity most days of the week to maintain good health. The American College of Sports Medicine suggests Pilates may be an effective mode of physical activity, however there is limited evidence to support the efficacy of Pilates for a range of its commercially claimed benefits. Methods: In this observational cohort study, healthy adults (4 males and 14 females), who had not participated in Pilates exercise prior to the study, completed 12 weeks of studio and/or mat based Pilates classes once per week and were compared to age matched controls. Before and after the 12 week intervention, participants completed a dual energy X-Ray absorptometry scan to assess body composition and bone mineral density; completed the 5 stage Sahrmann Core Stability assessment; were assessed for joint mobility at the shoulder, cervical and lumbar spine, hip and ankle using a goniometer; had their lower limb strength assessed through heel raises and isokinetic dynamometry; and their energy expenditure and energy intake monitored utilising the SenseWear™ Armband Mini and a five day food record. Results: There were no significant differences identified between the groups (Pilates and control) at baseline in relation to demographics (age, weight, height) and all aforementioned physiological characteristics, with the exception of cervical neck flexion. After the 12 week intervention, positive changes in core stability as identified through the Sahrmann core stability test among Pilates participants was evident though not statistically significant. Pilates group mean change 0.78 ±1.30AU, control group mean change -0.33 ± 1.11AU (p = 0.070). No other meaningful differences were identified. Conclusions: Though 12 weeks of Pilates completed once per week may be effective for enhancing core stability, it did not appear to elicit positive outcomes for range of motion, body composition and foot strength.

    KW - pilates training

    KW - body composition

    KW - range of motion

    KW - exercise

    KW - muscle strength

    M3 - Article

    VL - 4

    SP - 34

    EP - 42

    JO - Journal of Fitness Research

    JF - Journal of Fitness Research

    SN - 2201-5655

    IS - 2

    ER -