Place-based Development: A Comparative Study of Gender Empowerment and Community Collaboration in Small Farming Households in Punjab, Pakistan

Sajida TAJ, Sandra HEANEY-MUSTAFA, Barbara CHAMBERS, Robert FITZGERALD

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Since the independence of Pakistan, the agriculture and rural development have been part of the national development plans. The agricultural and rural development department has adopted several approaches and strategies, but most can be considered unsuccessful mainly because of the low level of community participation, the lack of focus on community needs and their failure to be gender inclusive. This research examines and seeks to understand the place-based agricultural value chain development that engages farming communities in rural Punjab. The research looks into the contribution of the participatory/multidisciplinary value chain development to gender inclusion, collaboration, and empowerment in the small farming households in rural Punjab. Based on the pragmatism paradigm, this uses mixed methods. A comparative pre and post analysis of place-based development approach and commodity focused approach is carried out using survey and focused group discussions data. In addition to comparing the different value chain development approaches, analysis of a control site was also added to compare the changes without any intervention. It was found that gender inclusion and participation enhanced the collective action in decisions making at inter and the intra-household level. The level of intrahousehold collaboration at the pilot place-based site was higher as compared to the commodity approach site and control site implying that the place-based community engagement leads to higher level of gender collaboration.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)26-32
Number of pages7
JournalAsian Studies International Journal
Volume1
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2018

Fingerprint

Pakistan
empowerment
value chain
gender
rural development
community
commodity
inclusion
participation
agricultural development
national development
pragmatism
collective behavior
group discussion
agriculture
paradigm
decision making
lack

Cite this

@article{af5fc05b39084b5c816362f0fd7d90b1,
title = "Place-based Development: A Comparative Study of Gender Empowerment and Community Collaboration in Small Farming Households in Punjab, Pakistan",
abstract = "Since the independence of Pakistan, the agriculture and rural development have been part of the national development plans. The agricultural and rural development department has adopted several approaches and strategies, but most can be considered unsuccessful mainly because of the low level of community participation, the lack of focus on community needs and their failure to be gender inclusive. This research examines and seeks to understand the place-based agricultural value chain development that engages farming communities in rural Punjab. The research looks into the contribution of the participatory/multidisciplinary value chain development to gender inclusion, collaboration, and empowerment in the small farming households in rural Punjab. Based on the pragmatism paradigm, this uses mixed methods. A comparative pre and post analysis of place-based development approach and commodity focused approach is carried out using survey and focused group discussions data. In addition to comparing the different value chain development approaches, analysis of a control site was also added to compare the changes without any intervention. It was found that gender inclusion and participation enhanced the collective action in decisions making at inter and the intra-household level. The level of intrahousehold collaboration at the pilot place-based site was higher as compared to the commodity approach site and control site implying that the place-based community engagement leads to higher level of gender collaboration.",
keywords = "Place-based development, gender inclusion, collaboration, empowerment",
author = "Sajida TAJ and Sandra HEANEY-MUSTAFA and Barbara CHAMBERS and Robert FITZGERALD",
year = "2018",
month = "12",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "26--32",
journal = "Asian Studies International Journal",
issn = "2279-1949",
number = "1",

}

Place-based Development: A Comparative Study of Gender Empowerment and Community Collaboration in Small Farming Households in Punjab, Pakistan. / TAJ, Sajida; HEANEY-MUSTAFA, Sandra; CHAMBERS, Barbara; FITZGERALD, Robert.

In: Asian Studies International Journal, Vol. 1, No. 1, 01.12.2018, p. 26-32.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Place-based Development: A Comparative Study of Gender Empowerment and Community Collaboration in Small Farming Households in Punjab, Pakistan

AU - TAJ, Sajida

AU - HEANEY-MUSTAFA, Sandra

AU - CHAMBERS, Barbara

AU - FITZGERALD, Robert

PY - 2018/12/1

Y1 - 2018/12/1

N2 - Since the independence of Pakistan, the agriculture and rural development have been part of the national development plans. The agricultural and rural development department has adopted several approaches and strategies, but most can be considered unsuccessful mainly because of the low level of community participation, the lack of focus on community needs and their failure to be gender inclusive. This research examines and seeks to understand the place-based agricultural value chain development that engages farming communities in rural Punjab. The research looks into the contribution of the participatory/multidisciplinary value chain development to gender inclusion, collaboration, and empowerment in the small farming households in rural Punjab. Based on the pragmatism paradigm, this uses mixed methods. A comparative pre and post analysis of place-based development approach and commodity focused approach is carried out using survey and focused group discussions data. In addition to comparing the different value chain development approaches, analysis of a control site was also added to compare the changes without any intervention. It was found that gender inclusion and participation enhanced the collective action in decisions making at inter and the intra-household level. The level of intrahousehold collaboration at the pilot place-based site was higher as compared to the commodity approach site and control site implying that the place-based community engagement leads to higher level of gender collaboration.

AB - Since the independence of Pakistan, the agriculture and rural development have been part of the national development plans. The agricultural and rural development department has adopted several approaches and strategies, but most can be considered unsuccessful mainly because of the low level of community participation, the lack of focus on community needs and their failure to be gender inclusive. This research examines and seeks to understand the place-based agricultural value chain development that engages farming communities in rural Punjab. The research looks into the contribution of the participatory/multidisciplinary value chain development to gender inclusion, collaboration, and empowerment in the small farming households in rural Punjab. Based on the pragmatism paradigm, this uses mixed methods. A comparative pre and post analysis of place-based development approach and commodity focused approach is carried out using survey and focused group discussions data. In addition to comparing the different value chain development approaches, analysis of a control site was also added to compare the changes without any intervention. It was found that gender inclusion and participation enhanced the collective action in decisions making at inter and the intra-household level. The level of intrahousehold collaboration at the pilot place-based site was higher as compared to the commodity approach site and control site implying that the place-based community engagement leads to higher level of gender collaboration.

KW - Place-based development

KW - gender inclusion

KW - collaboration

KW - empowerment

M3 - Article

VL - 1

SP - 26

EP - 32

JO - Asian Studies International Journal

JF - Asian Studies International Journal

SN - 2279-1949

IS - 1

ER -