Politicians, professionalization and anti‑politics: why we want leaders who act like professionals but are paid like amateurs

Paul FAWCETT, Jack Corbett

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Why are politicians so unpopular? One common explanation blames a professionalized political class that is increasingly detached from ‘ordinary citizens’. But, there is very little empirical investigation of what it is about the professionalization of politics that engenders distrust. This article uses 12 focus groups and 15 interviews with civil servants from the Australian Public Service—‘insiders’ with first-hand knowledge and experience of the political system—to reflect on political professionalization and its impacts. As a group, civil servants’ views on this question remain largely unexplored yet their proximity to the political process gives them a distinct vantage point from which to reflect on current explanations for rising anti-political sentiment. We find both positive and negative attitudes towards professionalization that destabilize prevailing explanations: on the demand side, civil servants share first-hand experience and knowledge of how the political process works but remain cynical about politicians, whilst on the supply side, they value governing competence more than demographic representation yet still want more ‘amateur’ politicians. Our reflections on these findings highlight contradictory expectations: we want politicians who act like professionals, but who are paid like amateurs.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1-22
Number of pages22
JournalPolicy Sciences
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 2018

Fingerprint

political process
amateur
professionalization
politician
civil servant
leader
politics
political elite
experience
Group
supply
citizen
demand
interview
Values
public

Cite this

@article{c3f43c2e49fb4093b532c9de60070f0a,
title = "Politicians, professionalization and anti‑politics: why we want leaders who act like professionals but are paid like amateurs",
abstract = "Why are politicians so unpopular? One common explanation blames a professionalized political class that is increasingly detached from ‘ordinary citizens’. But, there is very little empirical investigation of what it is about the professionalization of politics that engenders distrust. This article uses 12 focus groups and 15 interviews with civil servants from the Australian Public Service—‘insiders’ with first-hand knowledge and experience of the political system—to reflect on political professionalization and its impacts. As a group, civil servants’ views on this question remain largely unexplored yet their proximity to the political process gives them a distinct vantage point from which to reflect on current explanations for rising anti-political sentiment. We find both positive and negative attitudes towards professionalization that destabilize prevailing explanations: on the demand side, civil servants share first-hand experience and knowledge of how the political process works but remain cynical about politicians, whilst on the supply side, they value governing competence more than demographic representation yet still want more ‘amateur’ politicians. Our reflections on these findings highlight contradictory expectations: we want politicians who act like professionals, but who are paid like amateurs.",
keywords = "Politicians, Anti-politics, Professionalization, Civil servants, Australia",
author = "Paul FAWCETT and Jack Corbett",
year = "2018",
doi = "10.1007/s11077-018-9323-7",
language = "English",
pages = "1--22",
journal = "Policy Sciences",
issn = "0032-2687",
publisher = "Springer",

}

Politicians, professionalization and anti‑politics: why we want leaders who act like professionals but are paid like amateurs. / FAWCETT, Paul; Corbett, Jack .

In: Policy Sciences, 2018, p. 1-22.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Politicians, professionalization and anti‑politics: why we want leaders who act like professionals but are paid like amateurs

AU - FAWCETT, Paul

AU - Corbett, Jack

PY - 2018

Y1 - 2018

N2 - Why are politicians so unpopular? One common explanation blames a professionalized political class that is increasingly detached from ‘ordinary citizens’. But, there is very little empirical investigation of what it is about the professionalization of politics that engenders distrust. This article uses 12 focus groups and 15 interviews with civil servants from the Australian Public Service—‘insiders’ with first-hand knowledge and experience of the political system—to reflect on political professionalization and its impacts. As a group, civil servants’ views on this question remain largely unexplored yet their proximity to the political process gives them a distinct vantage point from which to reflect on current explanations for rising anti-political sentiment. We find both positive and negative attitudes towards professionalization that destabilize prevailing explanations: on the demand side, civil servants share first-hand experience and knowledge of how the political process works but remain cynical about politicians, whilst on the supply side, they value governing competence more than demographic representation yet still want more ‘amateur’ politicians. Our reflections on these findings highlight contradictory expectations: we want politicians who act like professionals, but who are paid like amateurs.

AB - Why are politicians so unpopular? One common explanation blames a professionalized political class that is increasingly detached from ‘ordinary citizens’. But, there is very little empirical investigation of what it is about the professionalization of politics that engenders distrust. This article uses 12 focus groups and 15 interviews with civil servants from the Australian Public Service—‘insiders’ with first-hand knowledge and experience of the political system—to reflect on political professionalization and its impacts. As a group, civil servants’ views on this question remain largely unexplored yet their proximity to the political process gives them a distinct vantage point from which to reflect on current explanations for rising anti-political sentiment. We find both positive and negative attitudes towards professionalization that destabilize prevailing explanations: on the demand side, civil servants share first-hand experience and knowledge of how the political process works but remain cynical about politicians, whilst on the supply side, they value governing competence more than demographic representation yet still want more ‘amateur’ politicians. Our reflections on these findings highlight contradictory expectations: we want politicians who act like professionals, but who are paid like amateurs.

KW - Politicians

KW - Anti-politics

KW - Professionalization

KW - Civil servants

KW - Australia

U2 - 10.1007/s11077-018-9323-7

DO - 10.1007/s11077-018-9323-7

M3 - Article

SP - 1

EP - 22

JO - Policy Sciences

JF - Policy Sciences

SN - 0032-2687

ER -