Population genetics and dispersal of the flatworm,Polycelis coronata

a test of the habitat stability hypothesis

Russell Rader, Peter UNMACK, Jeffrey Moore

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    3 Citations (Scopus)
    3 Downloads (Pure)

    Abstract

    The habitat stability hypothesis states that species in spring-like habitats have little reason to disperse compared to species in temporary habitats. Planarians commonly inhabit springs around the world and they have long been considered poor dispersers. Recently, however, genetic analyses have shown contradictory results on the dispersal of planarians. Asexual planarians that can establish a new population by colonization of a single individual showed little genetic differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of kilometers, whereas species inhabiting springs showed deep differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of meters. The latter results are consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. We used the cytochrome oxidase subunit I gene from 468 individuals of Polycelis coronata, an asexual species, collected from 50 sites, nested in 26 tributaries, in 4 catchments of the Wasatch Mountains of Utah, USA, to explore the dispersal capabilities of P. coronata. The longest distance between sites was 66 km. Despite this small spatial extent, we found that 77% of the 130 haplotypes were collected from a single site and 89% from a single catchment. FST values between local populations in the same tributary (0.221, 0.266, 0.389) were similar to the average FST values in different catchments for other headwater taxa. Also, variation among individuals accounted for the majority of genetic structuring with little differentiation beyond the scale of a single site. Dispersal is very slow in this species which is consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. However, we suggest that other explanations also warrant consideration. We also identified two potential cryptic species suggesting a high degree of hidden variation at the level of species in this genus
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)179-192
    Number of pages15
    JournalJournal of Freshwater Ecology
    VolumeOnline
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2016

    Fingerprint

    flatworm
    Platyhelminthes
    population genetics
    habitat
    habitats
    testing
    catchment
    tributary
    cytochrome-c oxidase
    haplotypes
    individual variation
    test
    mountains
    genetic differentiation
    headwater
    cytochrome
    genetic variation
    colonization
    mountain
    gene

    Cite this

    @article{46a1611e2a0d4d1eb42175daf2e180a6,
    title = "Population genetics and dispersal of the flatworm,Polycelis coronata: a test of the habitat stability hypothesis",
    abstract = "The habitat stability hypothesis states that species in spring-like habitats have little reason to disperse compared to species in temporary habitats. Planarians commonly inhabit springs around the world and they have long been considered poor dispersers. Recently, however, genetic analyses have shown contradictory results on the dispersal of planarians. Asexual planarians that can establish a new population by colonization of a single individual showed little genetic differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of kilometers, whereas species inhabiting springs showed deep differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of meters. The latter results are consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. We used the cytochrome oxidase subunit I gene from 468 individuals of Polycelis coronata, an asexual species, collected from 50 sites, nested in 26 tributaries, in 4 catchments of the Wasatch Mountains of Utah, USA, to explore the dispersal capabilities of P. coronata. The longest distance between sites was 66 km. Despite this small spatial extent, we found that 77{\%} of the 130 haplotypes were collected from a single site and 89{\%} from a single catchment. FST values between local populations in the same tributary (0.221, 0.266, 0.389) were similar to the average FST values in different catchments for other headwater taxa. Also, variation among individuals accounted for the majority of genetic structuring with little differentiation beyond the scale of a single site. Dispersal is very slow in this species which is consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. However, we suggest that other explanations also warrant consideration. We also identified two potential cryptic species suggesting a high degree of hidden variation at the level of species in this genus",
    author = "Russell Rader and Peter UNMACK and Jeffrey Moore",
    year = "2016",
    doi = "10.1080/02705060.2016.1253624",
    language = "English",
    volume = "Online",
    pages = "179--192",
    journal = "Journal of Freshwater Ecology",
    issn = "0270-5060",
    publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",

    }

    Population genetics and dispersal of the flatworm,Polycelis coronata : a test of the habitat stability hypothesis. / Rader, Russell; UNMACK, Peter; Moore, Jeffrey.

    In: Journal of Freshwater Ecology, Vol. Online, 2016, p. 179-192.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Population genetics and dispersal of the flatworm,Polycelis coronata

    T2 - a test of the habitat stability hypothesis

    AU - Rader, Russell

    AU - UNMACK, Peter

    AU - Moore, Jeffrey

    PY - 2016

    Y1 - 2016

    N2 - The habitat stability hypothesis states that species in spring-like habitats have little reason to disperse compared to species in temporary habitats. Planarians commonly inhabit springs around the world and they have long been considered poor dispersers. Recently, however, genetic analyses have shown contradictory results on the dispersal of planarians. Asexual planarians that can establish a new population by colonization of a single individual showed little genetic differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of kilometers, whereas species inhabiting springs showed deep differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of meters. The latter results are consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. We used the cytochrome oxidase subunit I gene from 468 individuals of Polycelis coronata, an asexual species, collected from 50 sites, nested in 26 tributaries, in 4 catchments of the Wasatch Mountains of Utah, USA, to explore the dispersal capabilities of P. coronata. The longest distance between sites was 66 km. Despite this small spatial extent, we found that 77% of the 130 haplotypes were collected from a single site and 89% from a single catchment. FST values between local populations in the same tributary (0.221, 0.266, 0.389) were similar to the average FST values in different catchments for other headwater taxa. Also, variation among individuals accounted for the majority of genetic structuring with little differentiation beyond the scale of a single site. Dispersal is very slow in this species which is consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. However, we suggest that other explanations also warrant consideration. We also identified two potential cryptic species suggesting a high degree of hidden variation at the level of species in this genus

    AB - The habitat stability hypothesis states that species in spring-like habitats have little reason to disperse compared to species in temporary habitats. Planarians commonly inhabit springs around the world and they have long been considered poor dispersers. Recently, however, genetic analyses have shown contradictory results on the dispersal of planarians. Asexual planarians that can establish a new population by colonization of a single individual showed little genetic differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of kilometers, whereas species inhabiting springs showed deep differentiation between sites separated by hundreds of meters. The latter results are consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. We used the cytochrome oxidase subunit I gene from 468 individuals of Polycelis coronata, an asexual species, collected from 50 sites, nested in 26 tributaries, in 4 catchments of the Wasatch Mountains of Utah, USA, to explore the dispersal capabilities of P. coronata. The longest distance between sites was 66 km. Despite this small spatial extent, we found that 77% of the 130 haplotypes were collected from a single site and 89% from a single catchment. FST values between local populations in the same tributary (0.221, 0.266, 0.389) were similar to the average FST values in different catchments for other headwater taxa. Also, variation among individuals accounted for the majority of genetic structuring with little differentiation beyond the scale of a single site. Dispersal is very slow in this species which is consistent with the habitat stability hypothesis. However, we suggest that other explanations also warrant consideration. We also identified two potential cryptic species suggesting a high degree of hidden variation at the level of species in this genus

    U2 - 10.1080/02705060.2016.1253624

    DO - 10.1080/02705060.2016.1253624

    M3 - Article

    VL - Online

    SP - 179

    EP - 192

    JO - Journal of Freshwater Ecology

    JF - Journal of Freshwater Ecology

    SN - 0270-5060

    ER -