Preventing black swans

Incident reporting systems as collective knowledge management

Sarah MASLEN, Jan Hayes

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In hazardous industries, disasters are mercifully rare and yet the potential is ever present. For this reason, companies and industries as a whole put substantial effort into gathering information about past small failures and their causes in an attempt to learn how to prevent more serious events. Despite these efforts, recent research has captured how organizations can ‘fail’ to learn. Disastrous events can become ‘black swans’ and remain unpredicted despite the existence of information warning of them. This article engages with this challenge by analyzing incident-reporting systems as a tool for collective knowledge. Drawing together the literatures on organizational knowledge management and incident reporting, we examine incident-reporting systems as used and as structured. We explore the potential use of incident-reporting systems for mediation and synchronization of knowledge within and across groups of professionals and organizations. We also address the social practices that translate information in databases into collective knowledge. Building on the work of Hecker, we argue that research concerned with incident reporting and organizational learning would benefit from using ‘knowledge’ and specifically ‘collective knowledge’ as its reference point. We show that conceptualizing this problem in terms of ‘reporting’ and ‘learning’ distracts attention from the knowledge needs for people to learn. We argue that we must ask: What do people need to know to play their part in major accident prevention? And how is that knowledge effectively shared? We conclude with an empirical research agenda in light of this investigation.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1246-1260
Number of pages15
JournalJournal of Risk Research
Volume19
Issue number10
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2016

Fingerprint

collective knowledge
reporting system
Knowledge management
knowledge management
incident
Industry
Disasters
Synchronization
accident prevention
industry
event
learning organization
mediation
empirical research
disaster
Incidents
cause
learning
Group

Cite this

@article{43f42674be9d4d0589be38fd6d00eebd,
title = "Preventing black swans: Incident reporting systems as collective knowledge management",
abstract = "In hazardous industries, disasters are mercifully rare and yet the potential is ever present. For this reason, companies and industries as a whole put substantial effort into gathering information about past small failures and their causes in an attempt to learn how to prevent more serious events. Despite these efforts, recent research has captured how organizations can ‘fail’ to learn. Disastrous events can become ‘black swans’ and remain unpredicted despite the existence of information warning of them. This article engages with this challenge by analyzing incident-reporting systems as a tool for collective knowledge. Drawing together the literatures on organizational knowledge management and incident reporting, we examine incident-reporting systems as used and as structured. We explore the potential use of incident-reporting systems for mediation and synchronization of knowledge within and across groups of professionals and organizations. We also address the social practices that translate information in databases into collective knowledge. Building on the work of Hecker, we argue that research concerned with incident reporting and organizational learning would benefit from using ‘knowledge’ and specifically ‘collective knowledge’ as its reference point. We show that conceptualizing this problem in terms of ‘reporting’ and ‘learning’ distracts attention from the knowledge needs for people to learn. We argue that we must ask: What do people need to know to play their part in major accident prevention? And how is that knowledge effectively shared? We conclude with an empirical research agenda in light of this investigation.",
keywords = "collective knowledge, disasters, incident reporting, learning, risk management",
author = "Sarah MASLEN and Jan Hayes",
year = "2016",
doi = "10.1080/13669877.2015.1057204",
language = "English",
volume = "19",
pages = "1246--1260",
journal = "Journal of Risk Research",
issn = "1366-9877",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "10",

}

Preventing black swans : Incident reporting systems as collective knowledge management. / MASLEN, Sarah; Hayes, Jan.

In: Journal of Risk Research, Vol. 19, No. 10, 2016, p. 1246-1260.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Preventing black swans

T2 - Incident reporting systems as collective knowledge management

AU - MASLEN, Sarah

AU - Hayes, Jan

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - In hazardous industries, disasters are mercifully rare and yet the potential is ever present. For this reason, companies and industries as a whole put substantial effort into gathering information about past small failures and their causes in an attempt to learn how to prevent more serious events. Despite these efforts, recent research has captured how organizations can ‘fail’ to learn. Disastrous events can become ‘black swans’ and remain unpredicted despite the existence of information warning of them. This article engages with this challenge by analyzing incident-reporting systems as a tool for collective knowledge. Drawing together the literatures on organizational knowledge management and incident reporting, we examine incident-reporting systems as used and as structured. We explore the potential use of incident-reporting systems for mediation and synchronization of knowledge within and across groups of professionals and organizations. We also address the social practices that translate information in databases into collective knowledge. Building on the work of Hecker, we argue that research concerned with incident reporting and organizational learning would benefit from using ‘knowledge’ and specifically ‘collective knowledge’ as its reference point. We show that conceptualizing this problem in terms of ‘reporting’ and ‘learning’ distracts attention from the knowledge needs for people to learn. We argue that we must ask: What do people need to know to play their part in major accident prevention? And how is that knowledge effectively shared? We conclude with an empirical research agenda in light of this investigation.

AB - In hazardous industries, disasters are mercifully rare and yet the potential is ever present. For this reason, companies and industries as a whole put substantial effort into gathering information about past small failures and their causes in an attempt to learn how to prevent more serious events. Despite these efforts, recent research has captured how organizations can ‘fail’ to learn. Disastrous events can become ‘black swans’ and remain unpredicted despite the existence of information warning of them. This article engages with this challenge by analyzing incident-reporting systems as a tool for collective knowledge. Drawing together the literatures on organizational knowledge management and incident reporting, we examine incident-reporting systems as used and as structured. We explore the potential use of incident-reporting systems for mediation and synchronization of knowledge within and across groups of professionals and organizations. We also address the social practices that translate information in databases into collective knowledge. Building on the work of Hecker, we argue that research concerned with incident reporting and organizational learning would benefit from using ‘knowledge’ and specifically ‘collective knowledge’ as its reference point. We show that conceptualizing this problem in terms of ‘reporting’ and ‘learning’ distracts attention from the knowledge needs for people to learn. We argue that we must ask: What do people need to know to play their part in major accident prevention? And how is that knowledge effectively shared? We conclude with an empirical research agenda in light of this investigation.

KW - collective knowledge

KW - disasters

KW - incident reporting

KW - learning

KW - risk management

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84933056366&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/preventing-black-swans-incident-reporting-systems-collective-knowledge-management

U2 - 10.1080/13669877.2015.1057204

DO - 10.1080/13669877.2015.1057204

M3 - Article

VL - 19

SP - 1246

EP - 1260

JO - Journal of Risk Research

JF - Journal of Risk Research

SN - 1366-9877

IS - 10

ER -