Self-thinning and tree competition in savannas

William Sea, N Hanan

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    15 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This paper examines the feasibility of applying self�thinning concepts to savannas and how competition with herbaceous vegetation may modify self�thinning patterns among woody plants in these ecosystems. Competition among woody plants has seldom been invoked as a major explanation for the persistence of herbaceous vegetation in mixed tree⿿grass ecosystems. On the contrary, the primary resourcebased explanations for tree⿿grass coexistence are based on tree⿿grass competition (niche�separation) that assumes that trees are inferior competitors unless deeper rooting depths provide them exclusive access to water. Alternative nonresource�based hypotheses postulate that trees are the better competitors, but that tree populations are suppressed by mortality related to fire, herbivores, and other disturbances. If self�thinning of woody plants can be detected in savannas, stronger evidence for resource�limitation and competitive interactions among woody plants would suggest that the primary models of savannas need to be adjusted. We present data from savanna sites in South Africa to suggest that self�thinning among woody plants can be detected in low�disturbance situations, while also showing signs that juvenile trees, more so than adults, are suppressed when growing with herbaceous vegetation in these ecosystems. This finding we suggest is evidence for size�asymmetric competition in savannas.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)189-196
    Number of pages8
    JournalBiotropica
    Volume44
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2011

    Fingerprint

    self thinning
    woody plant
    woody plants
    thinning (plants)
    savanna
    savannas
    vegetation
    ecosystems
    ecosystem
    rooting
    coexistence
    herbivore
    herbivores
    South Africa
    persistence
    disturbance
    mortality
    water

    Cite this

    Sea, William ; Hanan, N. / Self-thinning and tree competition in savannas. In: Biotropica. 2011 ; Vol. 44, No. 2. pp. 189-196.
    @article{20eda14aac3c4918bdc7826470f72e9b,
    title = "Self-thinning and tree competition in savannas",
    abstract = "This paper examines the feasibility of applying self{\^a}¿�thinning concepts to savannas and how competition with herbaceous vegetation may modify self{\^a}¿�thinning patterns among woody plants in these ecosystems. Competition among woody plants has seldom been invoked as a major explanation for the persistence of herbaceous vegetation in mixed tree{\^a}¿¿grass ecosystems. On the contrary, the primary resourcebased explanations for tree{\^a}¿¿grass coexistence are based on tree{\^a}¿¿grass competition (niche{\^a}¿�separation) that assumes that trees are inferior competitors unless deeper rooting depths provide them exclusive access to water. Alternative nonresource{\^a}¿�based hypotheses postulate that trees are the better competitors, but that tree populations are suppressed by mortality related to fire, herbivores, and other disturbances. If self{\^a}¿�thinning of woody plants can be detected in savannas, stronger evidence for resource{\^a}¿�limitation and competitive interactions among woody plants would suggest that the primary models of savannas need to be adjusted. We present data from savanna sites in South Africa to suggest that self{\^a}¿�thinning among woody plants can be detected in low{\^a}¿�disturbance situations, while also showing signs that juvenile trees, more so than adults, are suppressed when growing with herbaceous vegetation in these ecosystems. This finding we suggest is evidence for size{\^a}¿�asymmetric competition in savannas.",
    keywords = "ecological scaling, fire, intraspecific competition, resource limitation, size{\^A}]asymmetry, South Africa.",
    author = "William Sea and N Hanan",
    year = "2011",
    doi = "10.1111/j.1744-7429.2011.00789.x",
    language = "English",
    volume = "44",
    pages = "189--196",
    journal = "Biotropica",
    issn = "0006-3606",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "2",

    }

    Self-thinning and tree competition in savannas. / Sea, William; Hanan, N.

    In: Biotropica, Vol. 44, No. 2, 2011, p. 189-196.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Self-thinning and tree competition in savannas

    AU - Sea, William

    AU - Hanan, N

    PY - 2011

    Y1 - 2011

    N2 - This paper examines the feasibility of applying self�thinning concepts to savannas and how competition with herbaceous vegetation may modify self�thinning patterns among woody plants in these ecosystems. Competition among woody plants has seldom been invoked as a major explanation for the persistence of herbaceous vegetation in mixed tree⿿grass ecosystems. On the contrary, the primary resourcebased explanations for tree⿿grass coexistence are based on tree⿿grass competition (niche�separation) that assumes that trees are inferior competitors unless deeper rooting depths provide them exclusive access to water. Alternative nonresource�based hypotheses postulate that trees are the better competitors, but that tree populations are suppressed by mortality related to fire, herbivores, and other disturbances. If self�thinning of woody plants can be detected in savannas, stronger evidence for resource�limitation and competitive interactions among woody plants would suggest that the primary models of savannas need to be adjusted. We present data from savanna sites in South Africa to suggest that self�thinning among woody plants can be detected in low�disturbance situations, while also showing signs that juvenile trees, more so than adults, are suppressed when growing with herbaceous vegetation in these ecosystems. This finding we suggest is evidence for size�asymmetric competition in savannas.

    AB - This paper examines the feasibility of applying self�thinning concepts to savannas and how competition with herbaceous vegetation may modify self�thinning patterns among woody plants in these ecosystems. Competition among woody plants has seldom been invoked as a major explanation for the persistence of herbaceous vegetation in mixed tree⿿grass ecosystems. On the contrary, the primary resourcebased explanations for tree⿿grass coexistence are based on tree⿿grass competition (niche�separation) that assumes that trees are inferior competitors unless deeper rooting depths provide them exclusive access to water. Alternative nonresource�based hypotheses postulate that trees are the better competitors, but that tree populations are suppressed by mortality related to fire, herbivores, and other disturbances. If self�thinning of woody plants can be detected in savannas, stronger evidence for resource�limitation and competitive interactions among woody plants would suggest that the primary models of savannas need to be adjusted. We present data from savanna sites in South Africa to suggest that self�thinning among woody plants can be detected in low�disturbance situations, while also showing signs that juvenile trees, more so than adults, are suppressed when growing with herbaceous vegetation in these ecosystems. This finding we suggest is evidence for size�asymmetric competition in savannas.

    KW - ecological scaling

    KW - fire

    KW - intraspecific competition

    KW - resource limitation

    KW - size]asymmetry

    KW - South Africa.

    U2 - 10.1111/j.1744-7429.2011.00789.x

    DO - 10.1111/j.1744-7429.2011.00789.x

    M3 - Article

    VL - 44

    SP - 189

    EP - 196

    JO - Biotropica

    JF - Biotropica

    SN - 0006-3606

    IS - 2

    ER -