Spatial correspondence between the specialist galling insect genus Kladothrips (Thysanoptera

Tubulifera: Phlaeothripidae) and its Acacia host: ecological and evolutionary constraints on host use

Michael J. McLeish, Carlos E. González-Orozco, Joe T. Miller

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    Abstract

    Specialised insect–plant associations, and the presence of other organisms that specifically target this interaction, represent relatively ancient ecological interactions. These types of associations are characterised by non-random geographical range correspondence, especially in the presence of narrow resource use. However, empirical studies rarely investigate how spatial relationships between insects and their host plants contribute to phenotypic interactions resulting from host shifting. This is important because geographic range discontinuities highlight biotic or abiotic conditions that might interfere with ecological interactions and how species diversify. In this study, we test the null hypothesis that the geographic range of the galling genus Kladothrips corresponds with their Acacia hosts. We then evaluate whether ecological characteristics of Acacia are related to evolutionary constraints on Kladothrips host use. The results indicated discontinuities between spatial distribution models of Acacia and the hosts that support Kladothrips. Temperature, precipitation and edaphic variables contributed strongly to these differences and reveal Kladothrips gall Acacia hosts present in harsh, arid environments. However, Acacia are distributed throughout all Australia's diverse biomes including mesic, arid and monsoonal regions. Discontinuities in spatial correspondence between Acacia and Kladothrips suggest biotic and abiotic pressures limiting ecological interactions are present in mesic and hydric climates. Acacia hosts observed to support Kladothrips share strong spatial model equivalency, but not necessarily close phylogenetic relatedness. Co-phylogenetic analyses indicated contrasting host use conservatism between Acacia sections. The results of this study support the hypothesis that specialised associations between insects and plants are a function of varying climatic and evolutionary constraints over the geographic range of the host lineage. These findings agree with the premise that ecological constraints underlie evolutionary patterns of host use.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)412-423
    Number of pages12
    JournalAustral Entomology
    Volume56
    Issue number4
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2017

    Fingerprint

    Phlaeothripidae
    host use
    Acacia
    Thysanoptera
    insect
    insects
    discontinuity
    phylogenetics
    gall
    arid environment
    biome
    resource use
    relatedness
    host plant
    phylogeny
    dry environmental conditions
    galls
    host range
    spatial distribution
    host plants

    Cite this

    @article{8ed500108462401797593fc0e0f6ae53,
    title = "Spatial correspondence between the specialist galling insect genus Kladothrips (Thysanoptera: Tubulifera: Phlaeothripidae) and its Acacia host: ecological and evolutionary constraints on host use",
    abstract = "Specialised insect–plant associations, and the presence of other organisms that specifically target this interaction, represent relatively ancient ecological interactions. These types of associations are characterised by non-random geographical range correspondence, especially in the presence of narrow resource use. However, empirical studies rarely investigate how spatial relationships between insects and their host plants contribute to phenotypic interactions resulting from host shifting. This is important because geographic range discontinuities highlight biotic or abiotic conditions that might interfere with ecological interactions and how species diversify. In this study, we test the null hypothesis that the geographic range of the galling genus Kladothrips corresponds with their Acacia hosts. We then evaluate whether ecological characteristics of Acacia are related to evolutionary constraints on Kladothrips host use. The results indicated discontinuities between spatial distribution models of Acacia and the hosts that support Kladothrips. Temperature, precipitation and edaphic variables contributed strongly to these differences and reveal Kladothrips gall Acacia hosts present in harsh, arid environments. However, Acacia are distributed throughout all Australia's diverse biomes including mesic, arid and monsoonal regions. Discontinuities in spatial correspondence between Acacia and Kladothrips suggest biotic and abiotic pressures limiting ecological interactions are present in mesic and hydric climates. Acacia hosts observed to support Kladothrips share strong spatial model equivalency, but not necessarily close phylogenetic relatedness. Co-phylogenetic analyses indicated contrasting host use conservatism between Acacia sections. The results of this study support the hypothesis that specialised associations between insects and plants are a function of varying climatic and evolutionary constraints over the geographic range of the host lineage. These findings agree with the premise that ecological constraints underlie evolutionary patterns of host use.",
    keywords = "arid biome, biogeography, climate, co-diversification, geographic range, host shift",
    author = "McLeish, {Michael J.} and Gonz{\'a}lez-Orozco, {Carlos E.} and Miller, {Joe T.}",
    year = "2017",
    month = "11",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1111/aen.12256",
    language = "English",
    volume = "56",
    pages = "412--423",
    journal = "Austral Entomology",
    issn = "0004-9050",
    publisher = "John Wiley & Sons",
    number = "4",

    }

    Spatial correspondence between the specialist galling insect genus Kladothrips (Thysanoptera : Tubulifera: Phlaeothripidae) and its Acacia host: ecological and evolutionary constraints on host use. / McLeish, Michael J.; González-Orozco, Carlos E.; Miller, Joe T.

    In: Austral Entomology, Vol. 56, No. 4, 01.11.2017, p. 412-423.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Spatial correspondence between the specialist galling insect genus Kladothrips (Thysanoptera

    T2 - Tubulifera: Phlaeothripidae) and its Acacia host: ecological and evolutionary constraints on host use

    AU - McLeish, Michael J.

    AU - González-Orozco, Carlos E.

    AU - Miller, Joe T.

    PY - 2017/11/1

    Y1 - 2017/11/1

    N2 - Specialised insect–plant associations, and the presence of other organisms that specifically target this interaction, represent relatively ancient ecological interactions. These types of associations are characterised by non-random geographical range correspondence, especially in the presence of narrow resource use. However, empirical studies rarely investigate how spatial relationships between insects and their host plants contribute to phenotypic interactions resulting from host shifting. This is important because geographic range discontinuities highlight biotic or abiotic conditions that might interfere with ecological interactions and how species diversify. In this study, we test the null hypothesis that the geographic range of the galling genus Kladothrips corresponds with their Acacia hosts. We then evaluate whether ecological characteristics of Acacia are related to evolutionary constraints on Kladothrips host use. The results indicated discontinuities between spatial distribution models of Acacia and the hosts that support Kladothrips. Temperature, precipitation and edaphic variables contributed strongly to these differences and reveal Kladothrips gall Acacia hosts present in harsh, arid environments. However, Acacia are distributed throughout all Australia's diverse biomes including mesic, arid and monsoonal regions. Discontinuities in spatial correspondence between Acacia and Kladothrips suggest biotic and abiotic pressures limiting ecological interactions are present in mesic and hydric climates. Acacia hosts observed to support Kladothrips share strong spatial model equivalency, but not necessarily close phylogenetic relatedness. Co-phylogenetic analyses indicated contrasting host use conservatism between Acacia sections. The results of this study support the hypothesis that specialised associations between insects and plants are a function of varying climatic and evolutionary constraints over the geographic range of the host lineage. These findings agree with the premise that ecological constraints underlie evolutionary patterns of host use.

    AB - Specialised insect–plant associations, and the presence of other organisms that specifically target this interaction, represent relatively ancient ecological interactions. These types of associations are characterised by non-random geographical range correspondence, especially in the presence of narrow resource use. However, empirical studies rarely investigate how spatial relationships between insects and their host plants contribute to phenotypic interactions resulting from host shifting. This is important because geographic range discontinuities highlight biotic or abiotic conditions that might interfere with ecological interactions and how species diversify. In this study, we test the null hypothesis that the geographic range of the galling genus Kladothrips corresponds with their Acacia hosts. We then evaluate whether ecological characteristics of Acacia are related to evolutionary constraints on Kladothrips host use. The results indicated discontinuities between spatial distribution models of Acacia and the hosts that support Kladothrips. Temperature, precipitation and edaphic variables contributed strongly to these differences and reveal Kladothrips gall Acacia hosts present in harsh, arid environments. However, Acacia are distributed throughout all Australia's diverse biomes including mesic, arid and monsoonal regions. Discontinuities in spatial correspondence between Acacia and Kladothrips suggest biotic and abiotic pressures limiting ecological interactions are present in mesic and hydric climates. Acacia hosts observed to support Kladothrips share strong spatial model equivalency, but not necessarily close phylogenetic relatedness. Co-phylogenetic analyses indicated contrasting host use conservatism between Acacia sections. The results of this study support the hypothesis that specialised associations between insects and plants are a function of varying climatic and evolutionary constraints over the geographic range of the host lineage. These findings agree with the premise that ecological constraints underlie evolutionary patterns of host use.

    KW - arid biome

    KW - biogeography

    KW - climate

    KW - co-diversification

    KW - geographic range

    KW - host shift

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85008263087&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1111/aen.12256

    DO - 10.1111/aen.12256

    M3 - Article

    VL - 56

    SP - 412

    EP - 423

    JO - Austral Entomology

    JF - Austral Entomology

    SN - 0004-9050

    IS - 4

    ER -