Stressor dominance and sensitivity-dependent antagonism

Disentangling the freshwater effects of an insecticide among co-occurring agricultural stressors

Jon P. Bray, Sue J. Nichols, Alexandra Keely-Smith, Ross Thompson, Saurav Bhattacharyya, Susmita Gupta, Abhik Gupta, Jianfa Gao, Xianyu Wang, Sarit Kaserzon, Jochen F. Mueller, Audrey Chou, Ben J. Kefford

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Pesticide concentrations are correlated with regional declines in stream invertebrate diversity. Experimental studies have identified that pesticides can have strong and persistent negative effects on aquatic ecosystems. These effects may occur at concentrations orders of magnitude lower than laboratory toxicity studies predict. Synergism among stressors is one explanation for observed laboratory–field differences. However, the true effect of pesticides on stream invertebrates remains uncertain, given interactions between stressors and natural environmental conditions. We experimentally examined multiple-stressor effects on stream invertebrate assemblages and leaf litter breakdown using 24 independent ~900 L re-circulating outdoor mesocosms in a semi-orthogonal design. Two pulses of the pesticide malathion (C10H19O6PS2) were delivered at low and high concentrations (Pulse 1: low at 0.1 and high at 1 µg/L; Pulse 2: at 2.5 and 25 µg/L). These were crossed with a treatment combining stressors commonly associated with agricultural development; nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment (kaolinite). Malathion degradation was rapid (<24 hr half-life) in all treatments, likely because of photolysis, hydrolysis, the presence of biofilms and sorptive processes. There were significant differences in invertebrate assemblages between treatments, where malathion contributed to 48% and 87% of deviance during Pulse 1 and 2 respectively. Malathion had strong negative effects during Pulse 2, with declines occurring between control and high pesticide treatments in Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera abundances (Cohen's d = 3.08), invertebrate richness (d = 3.57) and total abundance (d = 3.31). Despite the dominant effects of malathion on invertebrates, agricultural stressors inhibited rates of leaf litter breakdown (p < 0.05), and weakly mitigated malathion toxicity in mesocosms (e.g. PERMANOVA, P ≈ 0.1). Malathion breakdown analysis indicated sediment addition reduced malathion concentrations through alkaline hydrolysis and sorption. Experimental assays on common taxa supported sediment-malathion interactions resulted in antagonism. Synthesis and applications. Pesticide effects were not synergistic with the stressors tested here. Indeed, sensitivity-dependent stressor antagonisms were observed, reinforcing a mechanistic understanding of stressor effects and interactions is important. Among aquatic stressors examined, malathion had dominant effects on invertebrate assemblages, despite rapid degradation. Our results suggest that pesticide effects may be underestimated within ecosystems, where pesticides can have severe community-wide effects, but rapid pesticide breakdown and sorptive processes may conceal causal links.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)2020-2033
Number of pages14
JournalJournal of Applied Ecology
Volume56
Issue number8
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2019

Fingerprint

antagonism
malathion
insecticide
pesticide
invertebrate
hydrolysis
effect
sediment analysis
toxicity
degradation
synergism
agricultural development
photolysis
leaf litter
half life
aquatic ecosystem
sediment
kaolinite
biofilm
experimental study

Cite this

Bray, Jon P. ; Nichols, Sue J. ; Keely-Smith, Alexandra ; Thompson, Ross ; Bhattacharyya, Saurav ; Gupta, Susmita ; Gupta, Abhik ; Gao, Jianfa ; Wang, Xianyu ; Kaserzon, Sarit ; Mueller, Jochen F. ; Chou, Audrey ; Kefford, Ben J. / Stressor dominance and sensitivity-dependent antagonism : Disentangling the freshwater effects of an insecticide among co-occurring agricultural stressors. In: Journal of Applied Ecology. 2019 ; Vol. 56, No. 8. pp. 2020-2033.
@article{6498c3f3046c4dceabdece166e2f7758,
title = "Stressor dominance and sensitivity-dependent antagonism: Disentangling the freshwater effects of an insecticide among co-occurring agricultural stressors",
abstract = "Pesticide concentrations are correlated with regional declines in stream invertebrate diversity. Experimental studies have identified that pesticides can have strong and persistent negative effects on aquatic ecosystems. These effects may occur at concentrations orders of magnitude lower than laboratory toxicity studies predict. Synergism among stressors is one explanation for observed laboratory–field differences. However, the true effect of pesticides on stream invertebrates remains uncertain, given interactions between stressors and natural environmental conditions. We experimentally examined multiple-stressor effects on stream invertebrate assemblages and leaf litter breakdown using 24 independent ~900 L re-circulating outdoor mesocosms in a semi-orthogonal design. Two pulses of the pesticide malathion (C10H19O6PS2) were delivered at low and high concentrations (Pulse 1: low at 0.1 and high at 1 µg/L; Pulse 2: at 2.5 and 25 µg/L). These were crossed with a treatment combining stressors commonly associated with agricultural development; nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment (kaolinite). Malathion degradation was rapid (<24 hr half-life) in all treatments, likely because of photolysis, hydrolysis, the presence of biofilms and sorptive processes. There were significant differences in invertebrate assemblages between treatments, where malathion contributed to 48{\%} and 87{\%} of deviance during Pulse 1 and 2 respectively. Malathion had strong negative effects during Pulse 2, with declines occurring between control and high pesticide treatments in Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera abundances (Cohen's d = 3.08), invertebrate richness (d = 3.57) and total abundance (d = 3.31). Despite the dominant effects of malathion on invertebrates, agricultural stressors inhibited rates of leaf litter breakdown (p < 0.05), and weakly mitigated malathion toxicity in mesocosms (e.g. PERMANOVA, P ≈ 0.1). Malathion breakdown analysis indicated sediment addition reduced malathion concentrations through alkaline hydrolysis and sorption. Experimental assays on common taxa supported sediment-malathion interactions resulted in antagonism. Synthesis and applications. Pesticide effects were not synergistic with the stressors tested here. Indeed, sensitivity-dependent stressor antagonisms were observed, reinforcing a mechanistic understanding of stressor effects and interactions is important. Among aquatic stressors examined, malathion had dominant effects on invertebrate assemblages, despite rapid degradation. Our results suggest that pesticide effects may be underestimated within ecosystems, where pesticides can have severe community-wide effects, but rapid pesticide breakdown and sorptive processes may conceal causal links.",
keywords = "antagonism, aquatic invertebrates, malathion, multiple stressors, pesticides, sediment",
author = "Bray, {Jon P.} and Nichols, {Sue J.} and Alexandra Keely-Smith and Ross Thompson and Saurav Bhattacharyya and Susmita Gupta and Abhik Gupta and Jianfa Gao and Xianyu Wang and Sarit Kaserzon and Mueller, {Jochen F.} and Audrey Chou and Kefford, {Ben J.}",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1111/1365-2664.13430",
language = "English",
volume = "56",
pages = "2020--2033",
journal = "Journal of Applied Ecology",
issn = "0021-8901",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
number = "8",

}

Stressor dominance and sensitivity-dependent antagonism : Disentangling the freshwater effects of an insecticide among co-occurring agricultural stressors. / Bray, Jon P.; Nichols, Sue J.; Keely-Smith, Alexandra; Thompson, Ross; Bhattacharyya, Saurav; Gupta, Susmita; Gupta, Abhik; Gao, Jianfa; Wang, Xianyu; Kaserzon, Sarit; Mueller, Jochen F.; Chou, Audrey; Kefford, Ben J.

In: Journal of Applied Ecology, Vol. 56, No. 8, 08.2019, p. 2020-2033.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Stressor dominance and sensitivity-dependent antagonism

T2 - Disentangling the freshwater effects of an insecticide among co-occurring agricultural stressors

AU - Bray, Jon P.

AU - Nichols, Sue J.

AU - Keely-Smith, Alexandra

AU - Thompson, Ross

AU - Bhattacharyya, Saurav

AU - Gupta, Susmita

AU - Gupta, Abhik

AU - Gao, Jianfa

AU - Wang, Xianyu

AU - Kaserzon, Sarit

AU - Mueller, Jochen F.

AU - Chou, Audrey

AU - Kefford, Ben J.

PY - 2019/8

Y1 - 2019/8

N2 - Pesticide concentrations are correlated with regional declines in stream invertebrate diversity. Experimental studies have identified that pesticides can have strong and persistent negative effects on aquatic ecosystems. These effects may occur at concentrations orders of magnitude lower than laboratory toxicity studies predict. Synergism among stressors is one explanation for observed laboratory–field differences. However, the true effect of pesticides on stream invertebrates remains uncertain, given interactions between stressors and natural environmental conditions. We experimentally examined multiple-stressor effects on stream invertebrate assemblages and leaf litter breakdown using 24 independent ~900 L re-circulating outdoor mesocosms in a semi-orthogonal design. Two pulses of the pesticide malathion (C10H19O6PS2) were delivered at low and high concentrations (Pulse 1: low at 0.1 and high at 1 µg/L; Pulse 2: at 2.5 and 25 µg/L). These were crossed with a treatment combining stressors commonly associated with agricultural development; nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment (kaolinite). Malathion degradation was rapid (<24 hr half-life) in all treatments, likely because of photolysis, hydrolysis, the presence of biofilms and sorptive processes. There were significant differences in invertebrate assemblages between treatments, where malathion contributed to 48% and 87% of deviance during Pulse 1 and 2 respectively. Malathion had strong negative effects during Pulse 2, with declines occurring between control and high pesticide treatments in Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera abundances (Cohen's d = 3.08), invertebrate richness (d = 3.57) and total abundance (d = 3.31). Despite the dominant effects of malathion on invertebrates, agricultural stressors inhibited rates of leaf litter breakdown (p < 0.05), and weakly mitigated malathion toxicity in mesocosms (e.g. PERMANOVA, P ≈ 0.1). Malathion breakdown analysis indicated sediment addition reduced malathion concentrations through alkaline hydrolysis and sorption. Experimental assays on common taxa supported sediment-malathion interactions resulted in antagonism. Synthesis and applications. Pesticide effects were not synergistic with the stressors tested here. Indeed, sensitivity-dependent stressor antagonisms were observed, reinforcing a mechanistic understanding of stressor effects and interactions is important. Among aquatic stressors examined, malathion had dominant effects on invertebrate assemblages, despite rapid degradation. Our results suggest that pesticide effects may be underestimated within ecosystems, where pesticides can have severe community-wide effects, but rapid pesticide breakdown and sorptive processes may conceal causal links.

AB - Pesticide concentrations are correlated with regional declines in stream invertebrate diversity. Experimental studies have identified that pesticides can have strong and persistent negative effects on aquatic ecosystems. These effects may occur at concentrations orders of magnitude lower than laboratory toxicity studies predict. Synergism among stressors is one explanation for observed laboratory–field differences. However, the true effect of pesticides on stream invertebrates remains uncertain, given interactions between stressors and natural environmental conditions. We experimentally examined multiple-stressor effects on stream invertebrate assemblages and leaf litter breakdown using 24 independent ~900 L re-circulating outdoor mesocosms in a semi-orthogonal design. Two pulses of the pesticide malathion (C10H19O6PS2) were delivered at low and high concentrations (Pulse 1: low at 0.1 and high at 1 µg/L; Pulse 2: at 2.5 and 25 µg/L). These were crossed with a treatment combining stressors commonly associated with agricultural development; nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment (kaolinite). Malathion degradation was rapid (<24 hr half-life) in all treatments, likely because of photolysis, hydrolysis, the presence of biofilms and sorptive processes. There were significant differences in invertebrate assemblages between treatments, where malathion contributed to 48% and 87% of deviance during Pulse 1 and 2 respectively. Malathion had strong negative effects during Pulse 2, with declines occurring between control and high pesticide treatments in Ephemeroptera, Plecoptera and Trichoptera abundances (Cohen's d = 3.08), invertebrate richness (d = 3.57) and total abundance (d = 3.31). Despite the dominant effects of malathion on invertebrates, agricultural stressors inhibited rates of leaf litter breakdown (p < 0.05), and weakly mitigated malathion toxicity in mesocosms (e.g. PERMANOVA, P ≈ 0.1). Malathion breakdown analysis indicated sediment addition reduced malathion concentrations through alkaline hydrolysis and sorption. Experimental assays on common taxa supported sediment-malathion interactions resulted in antagonism. Synthesis and applications. Pesticide effects were not synergistic with the stressors tested here. Indeed, sensitivity-dependent stressor antagonisms were observed, reinforcing a mechanistic understanding of stressor effects and interactions is important. Among aquatic stressors examined, malathion had dominant effects on invertebrate assemblages, despite rapid degradation. Our results suggest that pesticide effects may be underestimated within ecosystems, where pesticides can have severe community-wide effects, but rapid pesticide breakdown and sorptive processes may conceal causal links.

KW - antagonism

KW - aquatic invertebrates

KW - malathion

KW - multiple stressors

KW - pesticides

KW - sediment

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85067884368&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.mendeley.com/research/stressor-dominance-sensitivitydependent-antagonism-disentangling-freshwater-effects-insecticide-amon

U2 - 10.1111/1365-2664.13430

DO - 10.1111/1365-2664.13430

M3 - Article

VL - 56

SP - 2020

EP - 2033

JO - Journal of Applied Ecology

JF - Journal of Applied Ecology

SN - 0021-8901

IS - 8

ER -