Structuration bridging diffusion of innovations and gender relations theories: a case of paradigmatic pluralism in IS research

Marlei Pozzebon, Dale Mackrell, Sue Nielsen

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    9 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This paper discusses the adoption of a pluralist theoretical framework ¿ one that is also multiparadigmatic ¿ for conducting and publishing information system (IS) research. The discussion is illustrated by a single case study involving the Australian cotton industry. The theoretical framework is informed by three sociological theories, each with its particular paradigmatic assumptions: structuration theory as a meta-theory, and diffusion of innovations and gender relations as lower-level theories from notionally opposing paradigms. Theoretical pluralism helped to produce rich findings, illuminating both the social nature of women farmers' roles, the materiality of the cotton farming context, the characteristics of the decision support systems in use and the recursive way in which human agency and institutional pressures shape each other. Because users of so-called divergent paradigms often face criticism based on the incommensurability issue, one of the main contributions of this paper is to discuss the value of a pluralist and multiparadigmatic theoretical framework in dealing with complex IS social phenomena.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)229-248
    Number of pages20
    JournalInformation Systems Journal
    Volume24
    Issue number3
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 2014

    Fingerprint

    Cotton
    Information systems
    Innovation
    Decision support systems
    Industry

    Cite this

    @article{46ce7f8a11e94cccbbe8edd897c3ed89,
    title = "Structuration bridging diffusion of innovations and gender relations theories: a case of paradigmatic pluralism in IS research",
    abstract = "This paper discusses the adoption of a pluralist theoretical framework ¿ one that is also multiparadigmatic ¿ for conducting and publishing information system (IS) research. The discussion is illustrated by a single case study involving the Australian cotton industry. The theoretical framework is informed by three sociological theories, each with its particular paradigmatic assumptions: structuration theory as a meta-theory, and diffusion of innovations and gender relations as lower-level theories from notionally opposing paradigms. Theoretical pluralism helped to produce rich findings, illuminating both the social nature of women farmers' roles, the materiality of the cotton farming context, the characteristics of the decision support systems in use and the recursive way in which human agency and institutional pressures shape each other. Because users of so-called divergent paradigms often face criticism based on the incommensurability issue, one of the main contributions of this paper is to discuss the value of a pluralist and multiparadigmatic theoretical framework in dealing with complex IS social phenomena.",
    keywords = "structuration theory, diffusion of innovations theory, gender relations theory, multiparadigm, pluralism, technology-in-practice",
    author = "Marlei Pozzebon and Dale Mackrell and Sue Nielsen",
    year = "2014",
    doi = "10.1111/isj.12007",
    language = "English",
    volume = "24",
    pages = "229--248",
    journal = "Information Systems Journal",
    issn = "0959-2954",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "3",

    }

    Structuration bridging diffusion of innovations and gender relations theories: a case of paradigmatic pluralism in IS research. / Pozzebon, Marlei; Mackrell, Dale; Nielsen, Sue.

    In: Information Systems Journal, Vol. 24, No. 3, 2014, p. 229-248.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Structuration bridging diffusion of innovations and gender relations theories: a case of paradigmatic pluralism in IS research

    AU - Pozzebon, Marlei

    AU - Mackrell, Dale

    AU - Nielsen, Sue

    PY - 2014

    Y1 - 2014

    N2 - This paper discusses the adoption of a pluralist theoretical framework ¿ one that is also multiparadigmatic ¿ for conducting and publishing information system (IS) research. The discussion is illustrated by a single case study involving the Australian cotton industry. The theoretical framework is informed by three sociological theories, each with its particular paradigmatic assumptions: structuration theory as a meta-theory, and diffusion of innovations and gender relations as lower-level theories from notionally opposing paradigms. Theoretical pluralism helped to produce rich findings, illuminating both the social nature of women farmers' roles, the materiality of the cotton farming context, the characteristics of the decision support systems in use and the recursive way in which human agency and institutional pressures shape each other. Because users of so-called divergent paradigms often face criticism based on the incommensurability issue, one of the main contributions of this paper is to discuss the value of a pluralist and multiparadigmatic theoretical framework in dealing with complex IS social phenomena.

    AB - This paper discusses the adoption of a pluralist theoretical framework ¿ one that is also multiparadigmatic ¿ for conducting and publishing information system (IS) research. The discussion is illustrated by a single case study involving the Australian cotton industry. The theoretical framework is informed by three sociological theories, each with its particular paradigmatic assumptions: structuration theory as a meta-theory, and diffusion of innovations and gender relations as lower-level theories from notionally opposing paradigms. Theoretical pluralism helped to produce rich findings, illuminating both the social nature of women farmers' roles, the materiality of the cotton farming context, the characteristics of the decision support systems in use and the recursive way in which human agency and institutional pressures shape each other. Because users of so-called divergent paradigms often face criticism based on the incommensurability issue, one of the main contributions of this paper is to discuss the value of a pluralist and multiparadigmatic theoretical framework in dealing with complex IS social phenomena.

    KW - structuration theory

    KW - diffusion of innovations theory

    KW - gender relations theory

    KW - multiparadigm

    KW - pluralism

    KW - technology-in-practice

    U2 - 10.1111/isj.12007

    DO - 10.1111/isj.12007

    M3 - Article

    VL - 24

    SP - 229

    EP - 248

    JO - Information Systems Journal

    JF - Information Systems Journal

    SN - 0959-2954

    IS - 3

    ER -