The influence of residence time and geographic extent on the strength of plant–soil feedbacks for naturalised Trifolium

Kevin J. McGinn, Wim H. van der Putten, Philip E. Hulme, Natasha Shelby, Carolin Weser, Richard P. Duncan

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    4 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Release from natural enemies is considered an important mechanism underlying the success of plants introduced to new regions, but the degree to which alien plant species benefit from enemy release appears highly variable and context-dependent. Such variation could arise if enemy release is a transient phenomenon, whereby alien plant species initially escape but subsequently accumulate enemies in their new regions. To evaluate this hypothesis in terms of soil biota, we used 11 Trifolium (clover) species introduced to New Zealand from Europe to test whether species resident for longer or with a larger geographic extent in New Zealand were more adversely affected by soil communities in the introduced range, as expected if species have accumulated inhibitory soil biota over time. We used plant–soil feedback (PSF) experiments to compare the effect of soil biota on the growth of the Trifolium species in soil from their introduced (New Zealand) and native (Spain and the United Kingdom) ranges. We applied a novel statistical approach aimed at isolating the impact of antagonistic soil biota by accounting for variation in plant growth due to mutualistic rhizobia bacteria. The between-range differences in PSF varied considerably among the Trifolium species: some species were released from inhibitory PSF in the introduced range, but the majority experienced similar PSF in both ranges. Averaged over all 11 Trifolium species, PSF was less inhibitory in the introduced than in the native range, implying some release from soil-borne enemies. However, neither residence time nor geographic extent in the introduced range was significantly correlated with the strength of release from inhibitory PSF. Synthesis. Our multispecies study provides some evidence that alien plants can escape antagonistic soil biota in their introduced range, but highlights how plant–soil feedback responses can be highly variable among congeneric plant species in the same region. Our results do not support the hypothesis that the release from inhibitory plant–soil feedback is transient, questioning the generality of this phenomenon.

    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)207-217
    Number of pages11
    JournalJournal of Ecology
    Volume106
    Issue number1
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2018

    Fingerprint

    Trifolium
    soil biota
    introduced plants
    residence time
    soil
    Rhizobium
    natural enemies
    United Kingdom
    natural enemy
    rhizobacterium
    introduced species
    Spain
    plant growth
    synthesis
    bacteria
    bacterium
    testing
    plant species
    experiment

    Cite this

    McGinn, Kevin J. ; van der Putten, Wim H. ; Hulme, Philip E. ; Shelby, Natasha ; Weser, Carolin ; Duncan, Richard P. / The influence of residence time and geographic extent on the strength of plant–soil feedbacks for naturalised Trifolium. In: Journal of Ecology. 2018 ; Vol. 106, No. 1. pp. 207-217.
    @article{75079dc35c1e402c9ccfeccd1a1c90d6,
    title = "The influence of residence time and geographic extent on the strength of plant–soil feedbacks for naturalised Trifolium",
    abstract = "Release from natural enemies is considered an important mechanism underlying the success of plants introduced to new regions, but the degree to which alien plant species benefit from enemy release appears highly variable and context-dependent. Such variation could arise if enemy release is a transient phenomenon, whereby alien plant species initially escape but subsequently accumulate enemies in their new regions. To evaluate this hypothesis in terms of soil biota, we used 11 Trifolium (clover) species introduced to New Zealand from Europe to test whether species resident for longer or with a larger geographic extent in New Zealand were more adversely affected by soil communities in the introduced range, as expected if species have accumulated inhibitory soil biota over time. We used plant–soil feedback (PSF) experiments to compare the effect of soil biota on the growth of the Trifolium species in soil from their introduced (New Zealand) and native (Spain and the United Kingdom) ranges. We applied a novel statistical approach aimed at isolating the impact of antagonistic soil biota by accounting for variation in plant growth due to mutualistic rhizobia bacteria. The between-range differences in PSF varied considerably among the Trifolium species: some species were released from inhibitory PSF in the introduced range, but the majority experienced similar PSF in both ranges. Averaged over all 11 Trifolium species, PSF was less inhibitory in the introduced than in the native range, implying some release from soil-borne enemies. However, neither residence time nor geographic extent in the introduced range was significantly correlated with the strength of release from inhibitory PSF. Synthesis. Our multispecies study provides some evidence that alien plants can escape antagonistic soil biota in their introduced range, but highlights how plant–soil feedback responses can be highly variable among congeneric plant species in the same region. Our results do not support the hypothesis that the release from inhibitory plant–soil feedback is transient, questioning the generality of this phenomenon.",
    keywords = "alien, biological invasion, enemy release, exotic, invasion ecology, naturalisation, plant–soil (below-ground) interactions, soil biota, weed",
    author = "McGinn, {Kevin J.} and {van der Putten}, {Wim H.} and Hulme, {Philip E.} and Natasha Shelby and Carolin Weser and Duncan, {Richard P.}",
    year = "2018",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1111/1365-2745.12864",
    language = "English",
    volume = "106",
    pages = "207--217",
    journal = "Journal of Ecology",
    issn = "0022-0477",
    publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
    number = "1",

    }

    The influence of residence time and geographic extent on the strength of plant–soil feedbacks for naturalised Trifolium. / McGinn, Kevin J.; van der Putten, Wim H.; Hulme, Philip E.; Shelby, Natasha; Weser, Carolin; Duncan, Richard P.

    In: Journal of Ecology, Vol. 106, No. 1, 01.01.2018, p. 207-217.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - The influence of residence time and geographic extent on the strength of plant–soil feedbacks for naturalised Trifolium

    AU - McGinn, Kevin J.

    AU - van der Putten, Wim H.

    AU - Hulme, Philip E.

    AU - Shelby, Natasha

    AU - Weser, Carolin

    AU - Duncan, Richard P.

    PY - 2018/1/1

    Y1 - 2018/1/1

    N2 - Release from natural enemies is considered an important mechanism underlying the success of plants introduced to new regions, but the degree to which alien plant species benefit from enemy release appears highly variable and context-dependent. Such variation could arise if enemy release is a transient phenomenon, whereby alien plant species initially escape but subsequently accumulate enemies in their new regions. To evaluate this hypothesis in terms of soil biota, we used 11 Trifolium (clover) species introduced to New Zealand from Europe to test whether species resident for longer or with a larger geographic extent in New Zealand were more adversely affected by soil communities in the introduced range, as expected if species have accumulated inhibitory soil biota over time. We used plant–soil feedback (PSF) experiments to compare the effect of soil biota on the growth of the Trifolium species in soil from their introduced (New Zealand) and native (Spain and the United Kingdom) ranges. We applied a novel statistical approach aimed at isolating the impact of antagonistic soil biota by accounting for variation in plant growth due to mutualistic rhizobia bacteria. The between-range differences in PSF varied considerably among the Trifolium species: some species were released from inhibitory PSF in the introduced range, but the majority experienced similar PSF in both ranges. Averaged over all 11 Trifolium species, PSF was less inhibitory in the introduced than in the native range, implying some release from soil-borne enemies. However, neither residence time nor geographic extent in the introduced range was significantly correlated with the strength of release from inhibitory PSF. Synthesis. Our multispecies study provides some evidence that alien plants can escape antagonistic soil biota in their introduced range, but highlights how plant–soil feedback responses can be highly variable among congeneric plant species in the same region. Our results do not support the hypothesis that the release from inhibitory plant–soil feedback is transient, questioning the generality of this phenomenon.

    AB - Release from natural enemies is considered an important mechanism underlying the success of plants introduced to new regions, but the degree to which alien plant species benefit from enemy release appears highly variable and context-dependent. Such variation could arise if enemy release is a transient phenomenon, whereby alien plant species initially escape but subsequently accumulate enemies in their new regions. To evaluate this hypothesis in terms of soil biota, we used 11 Trifolium (clover) species introduced to New Zealand from Europe to test whether species resident for longer or with a larger geographic extent in New Zealand were more adversely affected by soil communities in the introduced range, as expected if species have accumulated inhibitory soil biota over time. We used plant–soil feedback (PSF) experiments to compare the effect of soil biota on the growth of the Trifolium species in soil from their introduced (New Zealand) and native (Spain and the United Kingdom) ranges. We applied a novel statistical approach aimed at isolating the impact of antagonistic soil biota by accounting for variation in plant growth due to mutualistic rhizobia bacteria. The between-range differences in PSF varied considerably among the Trifolium species: some species were released from inhibitory PSF in the introduced range, but the majority experienced similar PSF in both ranges. Averaged over all 11 Trifolium species, PSF was less inhibitory in the introduced than in the native range, implying some release from soil-borne enemies. However, neither residence time nor geographic extent in the introduced range was significantly correlated with the strength of release from inhibitory PSF. Synthesis. Our multispecies study provides some evidence that alien plants can escape antagonistic soil biota in their introduced range, but highlights how plant–soil feedback responses can be highly variable among congeneric plant species in the same region. Our results do not support the hypothesis that the release from inhibitory plant–soil feedback is transient, questioning the generality of this phenomenon.

    KW - alien

    KW - biological invasion

    KW - enemy release

    KW - exotic

    KW - invasion ecology

    KW - naturalisation

    KW - plant–soil (below-ground) interactions

    KW - soil biota

    KW - weed

    UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85037973902&partnerID=8YFLogxK

    U2 - 10.1111/1365-2745.12864

    DO - 10.1111/1365-2745.12864

    M3 - Article

    VL - 106

    SP - 207

    EP - 217

    JO - Journal of Ecology

    JF - Journal of Ecology

    SN - 0022-0477

    IS - 1

    ER -