The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality

David CARTER, Marion Tauschek

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

7 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Accounting is in crisis. It is a crisis of legitimacy. If the leaders of Enron perceived themselves to be “the smartest guys in the room” (McLean Elkind, 2004), the problem for accounting is that it is the enabler of these crises that attack the fundamental core of what is accounting itself. In part, this is because there is no answer to this question; there is no fundamental core to the thing itself. Rhetorically, it is an open book that is free to be authored in any direction that the authors (the accountants) want to take the discussion. This is the enabler of crisis. Sadly, but unsurprisingly, the first decade of the twenty-first Century is a story of epic accounting failures: from the income manipulations of Enron, WorldCom, Xerox and the multitude of other leading US companies in the early 2000s, to the role of fair value accounting for derivatives in relation to the financial crisis (then banking crisis, then sovereign debt crisis) that affects us today. Accounting is akin to an empty signifier, allowing authors of the accounting discourse to construct accounting in ways that mislead, confuse, and obfuscate the public. In association with this is that society seems to forget that accountants do this, or worse still, are lead to believe that these accounting failures are merely the work of a few ‘bad apples’ rather than recognising that the entire system is set up to mislead, confuse and obfuscate.
Original languageSpanish
Title of host publicationO profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social
EditorsRenato Ferreira Leitao Azevedo
Place of PublicationSao Paulo
PublisherEditora SENAC
Pages73-106
Number of pages34
ISBN (Print)9788539607358
Publication statusPublished - 2014

Fingerprint

Accountants
Enablers
Enron
Banking crisis
Attack
Discourse
Income
Financial crisis
Sovereign debt crises
Manipulation
Legitimacy
Fair value accounting
Derivatives

Cite this

CARTER, D., & Tauschek, M. (2014). The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality. In R. F. L. Azevedo (Ed.), O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social (pp. 73-106). Sao Paulo: Editora SENAC.
CARTER, David ; Tauschek, Marion. / The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality. O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social. editor / Renato Ferreira Leitao Azevedo. Sao Paulo : Editora SENAC, 2014. pp. 73-106
@inbook{6a0c171d27f54879ba165178abbce328,
title = "The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality",
abstract = "Accounting is in crisis. It is a crisis of legitimacy. If the leaders of Enron perceived themselves to be “the smartest guys in the room” (McLean Elkind, 2004), the problem for accounting is that it is the enabler of these crises that attack the fundamental core of what is accounting itself. In part, this is because there is no answer to this question; there is no fundamental core to the thing itself. Rhetorically, it is an open book that is free to be authored in any direction that the authors (the accountants) want to take the discussion. This is the enabler of crisis. Sadly, but unsurprisingly, the first decade of the twenty-first Century is a story of epic accounting failures: from the income manipulations of Enron, WorldCom, Xerox and the multitude of other leading US companies in the early 2000s, to the role of fair value accounting for derivatives in relation to the financial crisis (then banking crisis, then sovereign debt crisis) that affects us today. Accounting is akin to an empty signifier, allowing authors of the accounting discourse to construct accounting in ways that mislead, confuse, and obfuscate the public. In association with this is that society seems to forget that accountants do this, or worse still, are lead to believe that these accounting failures are merely the work of a few ‘bad apples’ rather than recognising that the entire system is set up to mislead, confuse and obfuscate.",
keywords = "Accounting, reality, crisis",
author = "David CARTER and Marion Tauschek",
year = "2014",
language = "Spanish",
isbn = "9788539607358",
pages = "73--106",
editor = "Azevedo, {Renato Ferreira Leitao}",
booktitle = "O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percep{\cc}{\~o}es e seu papel social",
publisher = "Editora SENAC",

}

CARTER, D & Tauschek, M 2014, The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality. in RFL Azevedo (ed.), O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social. Editora SENAC, Sao Paulo, pp. 73-106.

The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality. / CARTER, David; Tauschek, Marion.

O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social. ed. / Renato Ferreira Leitao Azevedo. Sao Paulo : Editora SENAC, 2014. p. 73-106.

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality

AU - CARTER, David

AU - Tauschek, Marion

PY - 2014

Y1 - 2014

N2 - Accounting is in crisis. It is a crisis of legitimacy. If the leaders of Enron perceived themselves to be “the smartest guys in the room” (McLean Elkind, 2004), the problem for accounting is that it is the enabler of these crises that attack the fundamental core of what is accounting itself. In part, this is because there is no answer to this question; there is no fundamental core to the thing itself. Rhetorically, it is an open book that is free to be authored in any direction that the authors (the accountants) want to take the discussion. This is the enabler of crisis. Sadly, but unsurprisingly, the first decade of the twenty-first Century is a story of epic accounting failures: from the income manipulations of Enron, WorldCom, Xerox and the multitude of other leading US companies in the early 2000s, to the role of fair value accounting for derivatives in relation to the financial crisis (then banking crisis, then sovereign debt crisis) that affects us today. Accounting is akin to an empty signifier, allowing authors of the accounting discourse to construct accounting in ways that mislead, confuse, and obfuscate the public. In association with this is that society seems to forget that accountants do this, or worse still, are lead to believe that these accounting failures are merely the work of a few ‘bad apples’ rather than recognising that the entire system is set up to mislead, confuse and obfuscate.

AB - Accounting is in crisis. It is a crisis of legitimacy. If the leaders of Enron perceived themselves to be “the smartest guys in the room” (McLean Elkind, 2004), the problem for accounting is that it is the enabler of these crises that attack the fundamental core of what is accounting itself. In part, this is because there is no answer to this question; there is no fundamental core to the thing itself. Rhetorically, it is an open book that is free to be authored in any direction that the authors (the accountants) want to take the discussion. This is the enabler of crisis. Sadly, but unsurprisingly, the first decade of the twenty-first Century is a story of epic accounting failures: from the income manipulations of Enron, WorldCom, Xerox and the multitude of other leading US companies in the early 2000s, to the role of fair value accounting for derivatives in relation to the financial crisis (then banking crisis, then sovereign debt crisis) that affects us today. Accounting is akin to an empty signifier, allowing authors of the accounting discourse to construct accounting in ways that mislead, confuse, and obfuscate the public. In association with this is that society seems to forget that accountants do this, or worse still, are lead to believe that these accounting failures are merely the work of a few ‘bad apples’ rather than recognising that the entire system is set up to mislead, confuse and obfuscate.

KW - Accounting

KW - reality

KW - crisis

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9788539607358

SP - 73

EP - 106

BT - O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social

A2 - Azevedo, Renato Ferreira Leitao

PB - Editora SENAC

CY - Sao Paulo

ER -

CARTER D, Tauschek M. The need to get real: Accounting and its role in constructing reality. In Azevedo RFL, editor, O profissional da contabilidade | Desenvolvimento de carreira, percepções e seu papel social. Sao Paulo: Editora SENAC. 2014. p. 73-106