Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation: Lessons from the mining industry

Neil Gunningham , Darren SINCLAIR

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

Abstract

For over a decade, private enterprise and governments in North America, Western Europe and Australasia have been experimenting with an innovative approach to standard-setting variously termed ‘process-based’, ‘systems-based’ or ‘management-based’ regulation (Coglianese and Lazar 2003). In contrast with traditional prescriptive standards (which tell duty holders precisely what measures to take) or performance standards (which specify outcomes or the desired level of performance), this approach involves firms developing their own process and management system standards and developing internal planning and management practices designed to achieve regulatory or corporate
goals. Such standards—whether they are imposed by the firm on its various operations (internal regulation), by governments on firms or by industry associations on their members (external regulation)—have the considerable attractions of providing flexibility to enterprises to devise their own least-cost solutions to social challenges, of facilitating their going beyond compliance with minimum legal standards and of being applicable to a broad range of circumstances and to heterogeneous enterprises.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationRegulatory Theory
Subtitle of host publicationFoundations and applications
EditorsPeter Drahos
Place of PublicationCanberra, Australia
PublisherThe Australian National University
Chapter40
Pages711-724
Number of pages14
ISBN (Electronic)9781760461027
ISBN (Print)9781760461010
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2017
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

regulation
industry
management
firm
private enterprise
performance standard
Western Europe
flexibility
planning
costs
performance

Cite this

Gunningham , N., & SINCLAIR, D. (2017). Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation: Lessons from the mining industry. In P. Drahos (Ed.), Regulatory Theory: Foundations and applications (pp. 711-724). Canberra, Australia: The Australian National University. https://doi.org/10.22459/RT.02.2017.40
Gunningham , Neil ; SINCLAIR, Darren. / Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation : Lessons from the mining industry. Regulatory Theory: Foundations and applications. editor / Peter Drahos. Canberra, Australia : The Australian National University, 2017. pp. 711-724
@inbook{cb308eabac4f4b859213955805eb9e4d,
title = "Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation: Lessons from the mining industry",
abstract = "For over a decade, private enterprise and governments in North America, Western Europe and Australasia have been experimenting with an innovative approach to standard-setting variously termed ‘process-based’, ‘systems-based’ or ‘management-based’ regulation (Coglianese and Lazar 2003). In contrast with traditional prescriptive standards (which tell duty holders precisely what measures to take) or performance standards (which specify outcomes or the desired level of performance), this approach involves firms developing their own process and management system standards and developing internal planning and management practices designed to achieve regulatory or corporategoals. Such standards—whether they are imposed by the firm on its various operations (internal regulation), by governments on firms or by industry associations on their members (external regulation)—have the considerable attractions of providing flexibility to enterprises to devise their own least-cost solutions to social challenges, of facilitating their going beyond compliance with minimum legal standards and of being applicable to a broad range of circumstances and to heterogeneous enterprises.",
author = "Neil Gunningham and Darren SINCLAIR",
year = "2017",
doi = "10.22459/RT.02.2017.40",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781760461010",
pages = "711--724",
editor = "Peter Drahos",
booktitle = "Regulatory Theory",
publisher = "The Australian National University",

}

Gunningham , N & SINCLAIR, D 2017, Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation: Lessons from the mining industry. in P Drahos (ed.), Regulatory Theory: Foundations and applications. The Australian National University, Canberra, Australia, pp. 711-724. https://doi.org/10.22459/RT.02.2017.40

Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation : Lessons from the mining industry. / Gunningham , Neil ; SINCLAIR, Darren.

Regulatory Theory: Foundations and applications. ed. / Peter Drahos. Canberra, Australia : The Australian National University, 2017. p. 711-724.

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation

T2 - Lessons from the mining industry

AU - Gunningham , Neil

AU - SINCLAIR, Darren

PY - 2017

Y1 - 2017

N2 - For over a decade, private enterprise and governments in North America, Western Europe and Australasia have been experimenting with an innovative approach to standard-setting variously termed ‘process-based’, ‘systems-based’ or ‘management-based’ regulation (Coglianese and Lazar 2003). In contrast with traditional prescriptive standards (which tell duty holders precisely what measures to take) or performance standards (which specify outcomes or the desired level of performance), this approach involves firms developing their own process and management system standards and developing internal planning and management practices designed to achieve regulatory or corporategoals. Such standards—whether they are imposed by the firm on its various operations (internal regulation), by governments on firms or by industry associations on their members (external regulation)—have the considerable attractions of providing flexibility to enterprises to devise their own least-cost solutions to social challenges, of facilitating their going beyond compliance with minimum legal standards and of being applicable to a broad range of circumstances and to heterogeneous enterprises.

AB - For over a decade, private enterprise and governments in North America, Western Europe and Australasia have been experimenting with an innovative approach to standard-setting variously termed ‘process-based’, ‘systems-based’ or ‘management-based’ regulation (Coglianese and Lazar 2003). In contrast with traditional prescriptive standards (which tell duty holders precisely what measures to take) or performance standards (which specify outcomes or the desired level of performance), this approach involves firms developing their own process and management system standards and developing internal planning and management practices designed to achieve regulatory or corporategoals. Such standards—whether they are imposed by the firm on its various operations (internal regulation), by governments on firms or by industry associations on their members (external regulation)—have the considerable attractions of providing flexibility to enterprises to devise their own least-cost solutions to social challenges, of facilitating their going beyond compliance with minimum legal standards and of being applicable to a broad range of circumstances and to heterogeneous enterprises.

U2 - 10.22459/RT.02.2017.40

DO - 10.22459/RT.02.2017.40

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781760461010

SP - 711

EP - 724

BT - Regulatory Theory

A2 - Drahos, Peter

PB - The Australian National University

CY - Canberra, Australia

ER -

Gunningham N, SINCLAIR D. Trust, culture and the limits of management-based regulation: Lessons from the mining industry. In Drahos P, editor, Regulatory Theory: Foundations and applications. Canberra, Australia: The Australian National University. 2017. p. 711-724 https://doi.org/10.22459/RT.02.2017.40