Underwater, out of sight

Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia

Mark LINTERMANS, Jarod P. Lyon, Michael Hammer, Iain Ellis, Brendan Ebner

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

Abstract

Fish translocations are fundamentally different to those of other vertebrate groups, with orders of magnitude more individuals usually released, and these individuals usually having high subsequent mortality. Translocation programs for Australian freshwater fish have changed considerably in the last 30+ years, moving from wild-to-wild translocations to hatchery stockings for recreational fisheries. Hatchery stocking and wild-to-wild translocations are now also used for conservation purposes. Translocations are among the four most-common management interventions employed for threatened Australian freshwater fish, with the frequency of wild-to-wild translocations, stockings and rescues increasing significantly during the recent Millennium Drought (1997–2010). We document 99 translocations of Australian freshwater fish conducted for conservation purposes since the late 1980s. These were all reintroductions (releases to sites formerly occupied by the species) or reinforcements of existing populations, except for one conservation introduction. Excluding cases where it is too early to assess the outcome, or where remnant populations were present when the reintroduction occurred, 38% of the translocations claim full or partial success. However, for 16% the outcome is unknown, raising concerns about the adequacy of monitoring. Monitoring programs associated with fish translocations are often short-term, under-resourced and, for long-lived fishes, monitoring often only encompasses the first milestone of success (survival for some period after release), with subsequent milestones (breeding and establishment) left unmeasured. Case studies review new insights into fish translocation such as: optimal stocking strategies; the survivorship and dispersal of on-grown individuals (i.e. hatchery-reared beyond the juvenile stage); the use of captive maintenance and subsequent release; and the use of artificial habitats (‘natural hatcheries’) to increase production numbers. Future freshwater fish translocations require increased levels of investment and will likely benefit from combined approaches of stocking and wild-to-wild translocation, along with consideration of further conservation introductions.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationAdvances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna
EditorsD Armstrong, M Hayward, D Moro, P Seddon
Place of PublicationClayton South, Australia
PublisherCSIRO Publishing
Chapter17
Pages237-253
Number of pages17
ISBN (Electronic)97814863030321, 9781486303038
ISBN (Print)9781486303014
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

translocation
fish
hatchery
reintroduction
monitoring
survivorship
reinforcement
vertebrate
drought
fishery
breeding
stocking
mortality

Cite this

LINTERMANS, M., Lyon, J. P., Hammer, M., Ellis, I., & Ebner, B. (2015). Underwater, out of sight: Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia. In D. Armstrong, M. Hayward, D. Moro, & P. Seddon (Eds.), Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna (pp. 237-253). Clayton South, Australia: CSIRO Publishing.
LINTERMANS, Mark ; Lyon, Jarod P. ; Hammer, Michael ; Ellis, Iain ; Ebner, Brendan. / Underwater, out of sight : Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia. Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna. editor / D Armstrong ; M Hayward ; D Moro ; P Seddon. Clayton South, Australia : CSIRO Publishing, 2015. pp. 237-253
@inbook{6bf26fcf1fe84b16a7cf3d991ce105dc,
title = "Underwater, out of sight: Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia",
abstract = "Fish translocations are fundamentally different to those of other vertebrate groups, with orders of magnitude more individuals usually released, and these individuals usually having high subsequent mortality. Translocation programs for Australian freshwater fish have changed considerably in the last 30+ years, moving from wild-to-wild translocations to hatchery stockings for recreational fisheries. Hatchery stocking and wild-to-wild translocations are now also used for conservation purposes. Translocations are among the four most-common management interventions employed for threatened Australian freshwater fish, with the frequency of wild-to-wild translocations, stockings and rescues increasing significantly during the recent Millennium Drought (1997–2010). We document 99 translocations of Australian freshwater fish conducted for conservation purposes since the late 1980s. These were all reintroductions (releases to sites formerly occupied by the species) or reinforcements of existing populations, except for one conservation introduction. Excluding cases where it is too early to assess the outcome, or where remnant populations were present when the reintroduction occurred, 38{\%} of the translocations claim full or partial success. However, for 16{\%} the outcome is unknown, raising concerns about the adequacy of monitoring. Monitoring programs associated with fish translocations are often short-term, under-resourced and, for long-lived fishes, monitoring often only encompasses the first milestone of success (survival for some period after release), with subsequent milestones (breeding and establishment) left unmeasured. Case studies review new insights into fish translocation such as: optimal stocking strategies; the survivorship and dispersal of on-grown individuals (i.e. hatchery-reared beyond the juvenile stage); the use of captive maintenance and subsequent release; and the use of artificial habitats (‘natural hatcheries’) to increase production numbers. Future freshwater fish translocations require increased levels of investment and will likely benefit from combined approaches of stocking and wild-to-wild translocation, along with consideration of further conservation introductions.",
author = "Mark LINTERMANS and Lyon, {Jarod P.} and Michael Hammer and Iain Ellis and Brendan Ebner",
year = "2015",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781486303014",
pages = "237--253",
editor = "D Armstrong and M Hayward and D Moro and P Seddon",
booktitle = "Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna",
publisher = "CSIRO Publishing",

}

LINTERMANS, M, Lyon, JP, Hammer, M, Ellis, I & Ebner, B 2015, Underwater, out of sight: Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia. in D Armstrong, M Hayward, D Moro & P Seddon (eds), Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna. CSIRO Publishing, Clayton South, Australia, pp. 237-253.

Underwater, out of sight : Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia. / LINTERMANS, Mark; Lyon, Jarod P.; Hammer, Michael; Ellis, Iain; Ebner, Brendan.

Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna. ed. / D Armstrong; M Hayward; D Moro; P Seddon. Clayton South, Australia : CSIRO Publishing, 2015. p. 237-253.

Research output: A Conference proceeding or a Chapter in BookChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Underwater, out of sight

T2 - Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia

AU - LINTERMANS, Mark

AU - Lyon, Jarod P.

AU - Hammer, Michael

AU - Ellis, Iain

AU - Ebner, Brendan

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - Fish translocations are fundamentally different to those of other vertebrate groups, with orders of magnitude more individuals usually released, and these individuals usually having high subsequent mortality. Translocation programs for Australian freshwater fish have changed considerably in the last 30+ years, moving from wild-to-wild translocations to hatchery stockings for recreational fisheries. Hatchery stocking and wild-to-wild translocations are now also used for conservation purposes. Translocations are among the four most-common management interventions employed for threatened Australian freshwater fish, with the frequency of wild-to-wild translocations, stockings and rescues increasing significantly during the recent Millennium Drought (1997–2010). We document 99 translocations of Australian freshwater fish conducted for conservation purposes since the late 1980s. These were all reintroductions (releases to sites formerly occupied by the species) or reinforcements of existing populations, except for one conservation introduction. Excluding cases where it is too early to assess the outcome, or where remnant populations were present when the reintroduction occurred, 38% of the translocations claim full or partial success. However, for 16% the outcome is unknown, raising concerns about the adequacy of monitoring. Monitoring programs associated with fish translocations are often short-term, under-resourced and, for long-lived fishes, monitoring often only encompasses the first milestone of success (survival for some period after release), with subsequent milestones (breeding and establishment) left unmeasured. Case studies review new insights into fish translocation such as: optimal stocking strategies; the survivorship and dispersal of on-grown individuals (i.e. hatchery-reared beyond the juvenile stage); the use of captive maintenance and subsequent release; and the use of artificial habitats (‘natural hatcheries’) to increase production numbers. Future freshwater fish translocations require increased levels of investment and will likely benefit from combined approaches of stocking and wild-to-wild translocation, along with consideration of further conservation introductions.

AB - Fish translocations are fundamentally different to those of other vertebrate groups, with orders of magnitude more individuals usually released, and these individuals usually having high subsequent mortality. Translocation programs for Australian freshwater fish have changed considerably in the last 30+ years, moving from wild-to-wild translocations to hatchery stockings for recreational fisheries. Hatchery stocking and wild-to-wild translocations are now also used for conservation purposes. Translocations are among the four most-common management interventions employed for threatened Australian freshwater fish, with the frequency of wild-to-wild translocations, stockings and rescues increasing significantly during the recent Millennium Drought (1997–2010). We document 99 translocations of Australian freshwater fish conducted for conservation purposes since the late 1980s. These were all reintroductions (releases to sites formerly occupied by the species) or reinforcements of existing populations, except for one conservation introduction. Excluding cases where it is too early to assess the outcome, or where remnant populations were present when the reintroduction occurred, 38% of the translocations claim full or partial success. However, for 16% the outcome is unknown, raising concerns about the adequacy of monitoring. Monitoring programs associated with fish translocations are often short-term, under-resourced and, for long-lived fishes, monitoring often only encompasses the first milestone of success (survival for some period after release), with subsequent milestones (breeding and establishment) left unmeasured. Case studies review new insights into fish translocation such as: optimal stocking strategies; the survivorship and dispersal of on-grown individuals (i.e. hatchery-reared beyond the juvenile stage); the use of captive maintenance and subsequent release; and the use of artificial habitats (‘natural hatcheries’) to increase production numbers. Future freshwater fish translocations require increased levels of investment and will likely benefit from combined approaches of stocking and wild-to-wild translocation, along with consideration of further conservation introductions.

UR - https://trove.nla.gov.au/work/191628034

UR - https://ebooks.publish.csiro.au/content/advances-reintroduction-biology-australian-and-new-zealand-fauna

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781486303014

SP - 237

EP - 253

BT - Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna

A2 - Armstrong, D

A2 - Hayward, M

A2 - Moro, D

A2 - Seddon, P

PB - CSIRO Publishing

CY - Clayton South, Australia

ER -

LINTERMANS M, Lyon JP, Hammer M, Ellis I, Ebner B. Underwater, out of sight: Lessons from threatened freshwater fish translocations in Australia. In Armstrong D, Hayward M, Moro D, Seddon P, editors, Advances in Reintroduction Biology of Australian and New Zealand Fauna. Clayton South, Australia: CSIRO Publishing. 2015. p. 237-253