Visual and analytical strategies in spatial visualisation

Perspectives from bilateral symmetry

Ajay Ramful, Siew Yin Ho, Tom Lowrie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

This inquiry presents two fine-grained case studies of students demonstrating different levels of cognitive functioning in relation to bilateral symmetry and reflection. The two students were asked to solve four sets of tasks and articulate their reasoning in task-based interviews. The first participant, Brittany, focused essentially on three criteria, namely (1) equidistance, (2) congruence of sides and (3) ‘exactly opposite’ as the intuitive counterpart of perpendicularity for performing reflection. On the other hand, the second participant, Sara, focused on perpendicularity and equidistance, as is the normative procedure. Brittany’s inadequate knowledge of reflection shaped her actions and served as a validation for her solutions. Intuitively, her visual strategies took over as a fallback measure to maintain congruence of sides in the absence of a formal notion of perpendicularity. In this paper, we address some of the well-known constraints that students encounter in dealing with bilateral symmetry and reflection, particularly situations involving inclined line of symmetry. Importantly, we make an attempt to show how visual and analytical strategies interact in the production of a reflected image. Our findings highlight the necessity to give more explicit attention to the notion of perpendicularity in bilateral symmetry and reflection tasks
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)443-470
Number of pages28
JournalMathematics Education Research Journal
Volume27
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Dec 2015

Fingerprint

Bilateral symmetry
visualization
Visualization
student
Congruence
Line of symmetry
Inclined
interview
Intuitive
Reasoning
Strategy
Vision

Cite this

@article{34ccc2a9bb754faba3714fe79bc5e522,
title = "Visual and analytical strategies in spatial visualisation: Perspectives from bilateral symmetry",
abstract = "This inquiry presents two fine-grained case studies of students demonstrating different levels of cognitive functioning in relation to bilateral symmetry and reflection. The two students were asked to solve four sets of tasks and articulate their reasoning in task-based interviews. The first participant, Brittany, focused essentially on three criteria, namely (1) equidistance, (2) congruence of sides and (3) ‘exactly opposite’ as the intuitive counterpart of perpendicularity for performing reflection. On the other hand, the second participant, Sara, focused on perpendicularity and equidistance, as is the normative procedure. Brittany’s inadequate knowledge of reflection shaped her actions and served as a validation for her solutions. Intuitively, her visual strategies took over as a fallback measure to maintain congruence of sides in the absence of a formal notion of perpendicularity. In this paper, we address some of the well-known constraints that students encounter in dealing with bilateral symmetry and reflection, particularly situations involving inclined line of symmetry. Importantly, we make an attempt to show how visual and analytical strategies interact in the production of a reflected image. Our findings highlight the necessity to give more explicit attention to the notion of perpendicularity in bilateral symmetry and reflection tasks",
keywords = "Analytical strategies, Bilateral symmetry, Perpendicularity, Reflection, Spatial visualisation, Visual strategies",
author = "Ajay Ramful and Ho, {Siew Yin} and Tom Lowrie",
year = "2015",
month = "12",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1007/s13394-015-0144-0",
language = "English",
volume = "27",
pages = "443--470",
journal = "Mathematics Education Research Journal",
issn = "1033-2170",
publisher = "Springer",
number = "4",

}

Visual and analytical strategies in spatial visualisation : Perspectives from bilateral symmetry. / Ramful, Ajay; Ho, Siew Yin; Lowrie, Tom.

In: Mathematics Education Research Journal, Vol. 27, No. 4, 01.12.2015, p. 443-470.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Visual and analytical strategies in spatial visualisation

T2 - Perspectives from bilateral symmetry

AU - Ramful, Ajay

AU - Ho, Siew Yin

AU - Lowrie, Tom

PY - 2015/12/1

Y1 - 2015/12/1

N2 - This inquiry presents two fine-grained case studies of students demonstrating different levels of cognitive functioning in relation to bilateral symmetry and reflection. The two students were asked to solve four sets of tasks and articulate their reasoning in task-based interviews. The first participant, Brittany, focused essentially on three criteria, namely (1) equidistance, (2) congruence of sides and (3) ‘exactly opposite’ as the intuitive counterpart of perpendicularity for performing reflection. On the other hand, the second participant, Sara, focused on perpendicularity and equidistance, as is the normative procedure. Brittany’s inadequate knowledge of reflection shaped her actions and served as a validation for her solutions. Intuitively, her visual strategies took over as a fallback measure to maintain congruence of sides in the absence of a formal notion of perpendicularity. In this paper, we address some of the well-known constraints that students encounter in dealing with bilateral symmetry and reflection, particularly situations involving inclined line of symmetry. Importantly, we make an attempt to show how visual and analytical strategies interact in the production of a reflected image. Our findings highlight the necessity to give more explicit attention to the notion of perpendicularity in bilateral symmetry and reflection tasks

AB - This inquiry presents two fine-grained case studies of students demonstrating different levels of cognitive functioning in relation to bilateral symmetry and reflection. The two students were asked to solve four sets of tasks and articulate their reasoning in task-based interviews. The first participant, Brittany, focused essentially on three criteria, namely (1) equidistance, (2) congruence of sides and (3) ‘exactly opposite’ as the intuitive counterpart of perpendicularity for performing reflection. On the other hand, the second participant, Sara, focused on perpendicularity and equidistance, as is the normative procedure. Brittany’s inadequate knowledge of reflection shaped her actions and served as a validation for her solutions. Intuitively, her visual strategies took over as a fallback measure to maintain congruence of sides in the absence of a formal notion of perpendicularity. In this paper, we address some of the well-known constraints that students encounter in dealing with bilateral symmetry and reflection, particularly situations involving inclined line of symmetry. Importantly, we make an attempt to show how visual and analytical strategies interact in the production of a reflected image. Our findings highlight the necessity to give more explicit attention to the notion of perpendicularity in bilateral symmetry and reflection tasks

KW - Analytical strategies

KW - Bilateral symmetry

KW - Perpendicularity

KW - Reflection

KW - Spatial visualisation

KW - Visual strategies

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84948462549&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1007/s13394-015-0144-0

DO - 10.1007/s13394-015-0144-0

M3 - Article

VL - 27

SP - 443

EP - 470

JO - Mathematics Education Research Journal

JF - Mathematics Education Research Journal

SN - 1033-2170

IS - 4

ER -