Effects of Exercise on Health Outcomes and Cardiovascular Disease Risk in Cancer Survivors

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis

Abstract

Many cancer survivors are inactive, putting them at risk of developing additional diseases such as cardiovascular disease (CVD). Even though general physical activity guidelines exist, cancer survivors commonly do not meet them and engage in too much sedentary behaviour. The optimal level of physical activity and/or exercise for reducing CVD risk in cancer survivors remains unclear. High-intensity interval training (HIIT) is being used by some individuals (including those with a chronic condition such as Diabetes and CVD) as a method of achieving additional physiological benefits compared to traditional exercise modes. It remains unclear if HIIT is effective, achievable or safe for cancer survivors and if the same benefits would be seen. The studies combined in this thesis aimed to investigate the efficacy of HIIT within cancer survivors for reducing risk factors for CVD. High-intensity exercise interventions elicited significant improvements (p < 0.05) in VO2 max, strength, body mass, body fat and hip and waist circumference compared with CMIT and/or control groups. The studies reviewed showed low risk in participating in supervised high-intensity exercise interventions. A self-reported questionnaire was used to determine the changes in physical activity (PA) patterns and body weight (BW) throughout the first 12 months after a cancer diagnosis. In the 12 months post-diagnosis, cancer survivors increased their sleep time and reduced their levels of both vigorous and light PA, this may or may not be related to the increases in BW, which was observed for 60% of the participants. These negative changes in PA puts this population at risk of additional diseases such as CVD. Cancer survivors (16) within 24 months post diagnosis, were randomly assigned into the LVHIIT or CLMIT group for 36 sessions (12 weeks) of supervised exercise. The LVHIIT group performed 7 x 30 second intervals (≥ 85% maximal heart rate) and the CLMIT group performed continuous aerobic training for 20 minutes (≤ 55% maximal heart rate) on a stationary bike or treadmill. Significant improvements (time) were observed for 13 of the 23 dependent variables (ES 0.05-0.61, p=<0.05). An interaction effect was observed for six-minute walk test (18.53% [32.43-4.63] ES 0.50, p = <0.01) with the LVHIIT group demonstrating greater improvements. The study that followed incorporated a lager sample size (75) of sedentary cancer survivors (n = 75, aged 51 ± 12 y) within 24 months of diagnosis using the same exercise protocol. Significant improvements from baseline were observed for seven of the 22 variables (ES 0.35 – 0.97, p ≤ 0.05). There was an interaction effect (p < 0.01) after 12 weeks in the LVHIIT group for six-minute walk test (p < 0.01; d = 0.97; 95% CI = 0.36, 1.56; large), sit to stand test (p <0.01; d = - 0.83; 95% CI = -1.40, - 0.22; large) and waist circumference reduction (p = 0.01; d = - 0.48; CI = -1.10, 0.10; medium). An interaction effect (p < 0.01) was also observed for quality of life in both the LVHIIT (d = 1.11; 95% CI = 0.50, 1.72; large) and CLMIT (d = 0.57; 95% CI = -0.00, 1.20; moderate) compared with the control group (d = -0.15; 95% CI = -0.95, 0.65; trivial). Lowvolume high-intensity training showed promise as an effective exercise prescription within the cancer population, showing greater improvements in cardio-respiratory fitness, lower body strength and waist circumference compared with traditional CLMIT and control groups. Both LVHIIT and CLMIT improved quality of life. The impact of exercise intensity on autonomic nervous system (ANS) and immune function in breast cancer survivors is not known. The final intervention included 17 participants using the same protocol except for the rest between intervals which was increased to two minutes. A significant improvement (p ≤ 0.05) in VO2peak from pre to post intervention in both exercise groups were observed. Non-significant changes were observed in ANS function and mucosal immunity in individuals with outlying baseline levels. Both HIIT and CMIT improved cardiorespiratory fitness. CVD remains one of the highest diagnosed comorbidities in the cancer population. Cancer survivors continue to be inactive, increasing the negative impact on their health profile, increasing CVD risk factors. Traditional and generic exercise guidelines are commonly used by clinicians to assist in prescribing recommendations for increased amounts of PA in the cancer population. In this thesis the “novel” exercise modality (supervised LVHIIT) showed increased improvements in some of the health outcomes measured, when compared with traditional CMIT however CMIT still showed significant improvements, something that we were not expecting after the short amount of exercise used. In summary, LVHIIT could be considered for use as an alternative to traditional CMIT within the cancer population for improved fitness, quality of life and compliance in those who are time poor. As shown in the final study cancer survivors who had reduced measures of HPA axis and immune functions at baseline benefited most from exercise. The studies within the thesis contributed to understanding HIIT within the cancer population. HIIT could assist in the optimisation of individualised exercise prescription to reduce risk factors for CVD in cancer.
Date of Award2018
LanguageEnglish
SupervisorStuart Semple (Supervisor), Kate Pumpa (Supervisor) & Julie Cooke (Supervisor)

End User Copyright Statement

  • Copyright of theses in the University of Canberra Research Portal is retained by the copyright holder. The text may not be reproduced or communicated in print or electronic form for commercial purposes. Readers may copy, download, print and save electronic copies of whole papers for their own individual non-commercial use. Excerpts, quotations and paraphrasing must be fully referenced. Text may not be altered without permission. The University of Canberra Research Portal reserves the right to remove content at any time.

Cite this

Effects of Exercise on Health Outcomes and Cardiovascular Disease Risk in Cancer Survivors
Toohey, K. (Author). 2018

Student thesis: Doctoral Thesis